2 ms·
The whole generations thing was made up by the Boomers in ad agencies trying to sell more products through demographic targeting. Just as many other Boomers wer
by WorldMaker 8y ago
The whole generations thing was made up by the Boomers in ad agencies trying to sell more products through demographic targeting. Just as many other Boomers were fascinated by astrology/horoscopes and "Ages", they latched on to a lot of weird pseudo-science that stuck and says a lot more about them anything else.
They venerated their parents and placed them on a pedestal "The Greatest Generation". They hated a lot of their earliest kids, "GenX". They doted and spoiled their later kids and early grandkids, "Millennial", then decided it was fun to blame them for how much they were doted upon/spoiled.
Boomers aren't even that special in that way that they've named themselves the "Baby Boomers", sure they were a massive population boom following a couple huge wars, but demographically speaking they mostly just put the planet back into the usual Malthusian cycle. There are more GenX and Millennials than Baby Boomers, because human birthrates trend towards the exponential. The Boomers aren't some big peak in the graph of human birthrates versus deathrates, they are a rise back towards "normalcy" after a giant trough.
The next generations that are supporting the Baby Boomers as they head into retirement and senescence aren't much "smaller", they are just less equipped, due to erosions in social contracts that the Boomers inherited, and overall a larger trend back towards greed than their parents. (In those cases, they are largely right that their parents were better them in general.)
(Also, the Boomers have been aware of climate change since the 70s. Yet another thing they've left to their kids and grandkids rather than tackle themselves.)
- adwn 8y ago> The whole generations thing was made up by the Boomers in ad agencies trying to sell more products through demographic targeting. Just as many other Boomers were fascinated by astrology/horoscopes and "Ages", they latched on to a lot of weird pseudo-science that stuck and says a lot more about them anything else. And yet you're making copious use of those labels and assign traits and actions to the subsets of people labeled thus. So what is it now – made-up or real?
- WorldMaker 8y agoStill made up. Broad swath generalizations remain broad swath generalizations. I can't claim to great satire in the writing above, but certainly there is an intentional frisson of irony.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> The whole generations thing was made up by the Boomers in ad agencies trying to sell more products through demographic targeting. It wasn't made up by Boomers, and the not-Boomers who made it up weren't in ad agencies. As agencies latched on to it, though. > They venerated their parents and placed them on a pedestal "The Greatest Generation". Actually, no. That's the Silent Generation that erected that pedestal for the GG, not the Boomers. > They hated a lot of their earliest kids, "GenX". Don't see any real evidence of this. (GenX is also largely the children of the Silent Generation.) > They doted and spoiled their later kids and early grandkids, "Millennial", then decided it was fun to blame them for how much they were doted upon/spoiled. Don't see any evidence for either half of this, either. It's not Boomers writing most of the Millennial generation-shaming (that's Gen Xers) or Millennials wrtit most of the Boomer generation-shaming (that's also Gen Xers). > Boomers aren't even that special in that way that they've named themselves the "Baby Boomers", sure they were a massive population boom following a couple huge wars, Just one specific war, and you just contradicted yourself. > but demographically speaking they mostly just put the planet back into the usual Malthusian cycle. There is no “usual Malthusian cycle”. > There are more GenX and Millennials than Baby Boomers, because human birthrates trend towards the exponential. I think you mean that human birth rates tend to be constant, producing exponential growth. But even that isn't true over the relevant period: the low US birthrate during the Boomer birth years is over 20 per 1000, which in turn is greater than the high of the next generation, over which birth rates declined to a low of under 15 per 1000; there was a slight jump up then for the Millennials, where birthrate hovered between about 15.5 and 16.5 per 1000, before dropping again for the post-Millenial generation (not clear which of the competing names is going to stick for that.) There are more Millennials and Gen X, combined, than Boomers, but that's a larger span of birth years , and more recent so fewer of them, proportionately, have died. (And we're just about at the Millennial/Boomer population crossover, Gen X is still smaller than either.) > The next generations that are supporting the Baby Boomers as they head into retirement and senescence aren't much "smaller", Gen X absolutely is, but in part that's an artifact of a slightly narrower window of birth years. More to the point, they certainly have a smaller worker to retiree ratio than was the case when the Boomers were in a similar position to either Gen X or Millenials now. > Also, the Boomers have been aware of climate change since the 70s. The Boomers in general were not; it may have been the scientific consensus since the 1970s, but the Boomers weren't the people concealing that consensus in the 1970s (that was largely the Silent and Greatest generations.) The eruption of climate change as an issue ofmhigh political salience tracks pretty well with Boomers gaining political power.