8 ms·
One of the first things I remember about moving to a rich country was the absence of knockoff products sold in retail stores. It seemed amazing to me that compa
by rchaud 8y ago
One of the first things I remember about moving to a rich country was the absence of knockoff products sold in retail stores. It seemed amazing to me that companies would deal only with authorized distributors.
These days, I feel like I'm in a twilight zone where 'wealth creation' is happening by putting a fresh face on 3rd-world country business models.
First it was Uber with the "hire a random guy off the street to be my driver". Next it was Fiverr/Upwork/ etc, the digital equivalent of rounding up day labourers in the Home Depot parking lot.
Now it's Amazon selling bootleg crap at scale. What's their excuse? Some variant of "move fast, break things", no doubt.
- decebalus1 8y ago> These days, I feel like I'm in a twilight zone where 'wealth creation' is happening by putting a fresh face on 3rd-world country business models. It's not a secret that lots of business models coming out of Silicon Valley are just regulatory workarounds/loopholes. It's a matter of chance that they coincide with some 3rd world country models as the latter's fuels are survival/corruption/perceived lawlessness while over here it's 'disruption'/first-to-market and the drive to become a temporary monopoly on a regulatory loophole.
- reaperducer 8y ago"Disruption" is SV for "Easier to ask for forgiveness than permission."
- ohyeshedid 8y agoTechnology always outpaces legislation.
- reaperducer 8y agoThat’s a popular SV cliche, but it’s not true. For example, without the DMCA, neither Twitter nor YouTube would exist.
- decebalus1 8y agommm.. yes and no. Sometimes is outpaces legislation (self-driving cars, cryptocurrencies, all the privacy things) but more than often it just finds a vulnerability in the unspecified existing legislation/regulation (see airbnb, uber, lyft).
- roymurdock 8y agocost savings/increased efficiency is the name of the game, and first world regulations are costs SV can ignore. sometimes the quasi employees suffer the burden (but get increased flexibility), sometimes the consumer suffers (lower price but increased variance in quality of goods/service)
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> cost savings/increased efficiency is the name of the game I'd say "socializing losses, privatizing gains" is the name of the game. Those popular disruptive startups dump plenty of externalities on everyone around them. Don't think for a moment that anyone there is increasing efficiency for the sake of increasing efficiency globally; it's just disrupting the society and hoping money pours through the cracks.
- decebalus1 8y ago> "socializing losses, privatizing gains" Never seen this formulated as such but I really like it. I was reading a book which tangentially dealt with that [0]. It changed my perspective on how new businesses are increasingly externalizing their costs to the consumers. [0] https://www.amazon.com/Shadow-Work-Unpaid-Unseen-Jobs/dp/1619027364 https://www.amazon.com/Shadow-Work-Unpaid-Unseen-Jobs/dp/161...
- SaltyBackendGuy 8y ago> "socializing losses, privatizing gains" I also have never head it put quite this way, and realize how true it is. One example is American Football stadiums. Get the people to pay for it and charge them to go there.
- gizmo686 8y agoI don't think "externalizing their costs to the consumers" really makes sense. In an idealized market, costs should be passed onto the consumer. From what I can tell, the book you reference is just complaining that this cost changed from money to labor. It is also worth noting that, in many cases, this results in a net win for the consumer. Eg, whwn I buy from a full service gas station, I am paying someone to pump my gas, and paying the to sit idle waiting for customers, and paying (in time) to wait for them to finish. In contrast, in self service, the only cost from above I have is 1 person pumping gas (which switched from being paid with money, to being paid with labor)
- stcredzero 8y agoIt's a matter of chance that they coincide with some 3rd world country models as the latter's fuels are survival/corruption/perceived lawlessness It's not a matter of chance. The earlier government regulation was better than no regulation, but had significant downsides. Taxi regulation got corrupt and the market didn't work very well. Uber and company came in with technology that worked better than the old government bureaucracy at cleaning up and regulating the market. I can't attest to how well Fiverr works.
- chipotle_coyote 8y agoUber and company came in with technology that worked better than the old government bureaucracy at cleaning up and regulating the market. To me, at least, this assertion requires some substantiation. It seems to me that what Uber has been better at than traditional taxi services is solely the technology. I can only expect to hail a taxi on demand if I'm in a big city, airport, train station, or other transit center; if I'm in a rural area, suburb, or even a smaller city, I'll probably have to call to arrange a pickup and hope it actually arrives. (My personal luck with calling for taxis has been...spotty at best, while for Uber and Lyft so far it's been 100%.) But "cleaning up and regulating the market?" I don't see how ride-sharing services are doing anything to regulate the market, and "cleaning up" is pretty hard to measure. Ride shares tend to be cheaper than taxis, and I don't doubt that part of the cost of a taxi fare is due to regulation -- but a large part of it comes from the uncomfortable fact that Uber and Lyft are both subsidizing rides with VC money. If they actually charged enough for the ride to make a profit, average ride prices would easily double. Also, while taxi regulation is pretty corrupt, well, Uber is maybe not the poster child we want for how unregulated companies are gonna do better on that front.
- stcredzero 8y agoTo me, at least, this assertion requires some substantiation. Taxis used to be smelly and dirty. Drivers were quite cavalier in their attitudes towards customers. Hailing a taxi was difficult and chancy. I was scammed by drivers who would take me on indirect routes for more money. It seems to me that what Uber has been better at than traditional taxi services is solely the technology. That is precisely the point. I don't see how ride-sharing services are doing anything to regulate the market, and "cleaning up" is pretty hard to measure. There are now rapid and technologically mediated consequences for both drivers and riders for behaving badly. Uber drivers are always polite, and riders are always polite. Riders are now strongly motivated to never keep their drivers waiting, which was not the case for taxis. The vehicles smell better! Drivers never scam you by driving a circuitous route. It's pretty obvious to me that the market is much better regulated through the technology. Also, while taxi regulation is pretty corrupt, well, Uber is maybe not the poster child we want for how unregulated companies are gonna do better on that front. The point is that while Uber is far from a poster child -- no argument there -- the technology (read: the rapid flow of accurate information in the market) still has them doing a better job than regulatory mechanisms from the 20th century.
- wnkrshm 8y ago> These days, I feel like I'm in a twilight zone where 'wealth creation' is happening by putting a fresh face on 3rd-world country business models. Or maybe making those that scale well more accessible and socially accepted in the service economy. Is there maybe some source that you've read, someone who has analyzed that statement (3rd-world country business models = gig economy) in more detail? I don't have much time to dig but if there was a thesis or article about this I'd be super interested in reading it.
- reaperducer 8y agoSounds like he's spent a lot of time living in third-world countries, so he's speaking from experience. I've spend a good amount of time in third-world countries, and my experience aligns with his.
- cookingrobot 8y agoSome of that seems right, but I don’t agree with the Uber example. Ride sharing has been a much more convenient and reliable service than taxis, and with less fraud (broken meters or credit card machines) and less discrimination (actually willing to drive me to the neighborhood I want). And with Uber I have a record of who drove me where. This seems pretty different from being picked up by a random person on the street. I haven’t used Upwork etc, but I wouldn’t be surprised if it was a similar experience.
- roymurdock 8y agoproblem with uber from a customer perspective is if you are a single woman taking a ride, the drivers are not full time cab employees that can possibly be fired/lose their cab medallion/permits. some women i know are considering switching to licensed cabs due to the harassment they get from uber drivers with no good mechanism to report and avoid those drivers aside from never traveling alone. as a guy, i've only had good experiences (except for the opaque surge pricing which always feels extortionate)
- 52-6F-62 8y ago> as a guy, i've only had good experiences (except for the opaque surge pricing which always feels extortionate) Totally off the main topic here, but I'm also a guy and I've had one ride that was a little hair-raising. I wasn't harassed, mind. I was riding with two girls (downtown Toronto) in an Uber and the driver was clearly on speed. He was extremely chatty, actually quite friendly, but very frantic. Took many last-second turns, wrong way down one-way streets and driving over curbs to get out of the way of cars on said one-way streets. It was nuts. That said, all other rides I've had have been just fine. Often better than my experiences with Toronto cabs. There's no cash benefit for them taking the "scenic route" or "making wrong turns" which I've had less-scrupulous cabbies do to drive up the fare. That's a feature I appreciate. But I just make myself deal with transit since removing the app— their privacy measures didn't instill much confidence in me.
- reaperducer 8y ago
- pasbesoin 8y agoLet me cough up this chestnut from the '90's: "Race to the bottom." Fortunately, that bottom is rising, on average. But "first world" systems have taken a lot of abuse, along the way. In my opinion, abuse that was unnecessary. But we let the shysters in to arbitrage against the disparities, instead of helping other countries to grow for themselves into more well-rounded and autonomous entities. Maybe I'm a fool, but that's how I see it.
- Yver 8y agoI had the same feeling a few years ago when the sharing economy was the next big thing and people were prompted to subrent their flat, guest room, tools or car. Depending on who you'd ask, it was touted as the best (or the worst) of capitalism and communism combined.
- fbelzile 8y ago> Now it's Amazon selling bootleg crap at scale. What's their excuse? Some variant of "move fast, break things", no doubt. Competing with Alibaba. Amazon seems to have decided to increase product variety (through increasing foreign based stores) at the cost of losing quality control.
- 52-6F-62 8y agoThis definitely appears to be the case. I'll say one thing in Amazon's defence however— their customer service is fantastic in my experience.
- iak8god 8y ago> [Amazon's] customer service is fantastic in my experience. Try not having Prime. I tried that once, for a short while. The difference in service was striking.
- 52-6F-62 8y agoSadly I'd believe it and have heard similar before. It wouldn't even really bother me if they were up front about it. It's not uncommon to sell premium service packages, or restricted shopping (like Costco).
- trevyn 8y agoUber/Fiverr/Upwork automate the trust aspect, so I can be assured decent service or I’ll get a refund and the provider’s reputation will be dinged. Outright scams are hard to pull off in this environment. Amazon... I can only speculate what’s going on there. Maybe the resulting price pressure turns the screws on suppliers? And honestly I’ve never gotten a branded product from them that I thought was fake. This could just be a fulfillment optimization; there are obvious cost savings and efficiencies from commingling, and maybe they’re working on a solution now.
- reaperducer 8y agoAmazon... I can only speculate what’s going on there. Maybe the resulting price pressure turns the screws on suppliers? Scammers looking for places to scam, which Amazon provides by relying on customer ratings to police its suppliers, which clearly doesn't work. Most of the recent SV business models only work in a hypothetical place where everyone is good and altruistic. Look at self-driving cars. There are thousands of words written about how self-driving cars will create a transportation utopia with clean, efficient transportation for all. None of the startups address what happens when someone refuses to get out of a self-driving car. Or when a self-driving car arrives at my door and it's full of barf. Or some homeless guy decides to set up camp in there. Or it gets all graffiti tagged. Think about how people treat current modes of public transportation. Now imagine how miscreants will treat them with more privacy, and no chance of human intervention.
- plankers 8y agoOh man, can't wait to see the future graffiti all over self-driving cars. Tech dystopia, here we come! But for real, it's for these reasons that Google et al. place such a high value on systems to identify and deanonymize people. In a world where all of your biometric data can be easily identified and linked back to you, there won't be much room for bad behavior. The real question is who gets to decide what behavior qualifies as "bad."
- CaptainZapp 8y ago
- tapatio 8y agoI think Fiverr came before Uber if I'm not mistaken.
- kilo_bravo_3 8y agoMost people are greedy. They only want more for less. The overlap between people who: * pretend to be upset about ever-shrinking middle class, and * sort by lowest price and buy an obvious knockoff from an online marketplace third-party seller that takes three weeks to arrive from Shenzhen in order to save 52¢ on an item... ...is almost 100%. They don't realize that their own cheapassedness caused the shrinking. You aren't in the twilight zone, 3rd-world business models are creeping into the rest of the world because they worked so well in the 3rd-world. Except in the 3rd-world the models maximized profit for businesses while consumers had no choice due to pre-existing poverty and in what is left of the non-3rd-world they are maximizing profit for businesses while appealing to rabid cheapassed consumers.
- JohnJamesRambo 8y ago"There are three ways to make a living in this business: be first, be smarter, or cheat. Well, I don't cheat. And although I like to think we have some pretty smart people here in this room, it sure is a hell of lot easier to just be first." -Margin Call First and smarter are getting more and more taken.
- stcredzero 8y ago...putting a fresh face on 3rd-world country business models...Now it's Amazon selling bootleg crap at scale. Why does Amazon have to be limited to stores? What if they could put the right near field detection technology into a portable form factor? Like, a blanket spread on the sidewalk?
- diminoten 8y agoYou look down your nose at day laborers in front of Home Depot (and their digital counterparts) like they don't deserve to make a living. Should an Uber driver just starve to death because he doesn't fit your specific model of what a worker looks like? That's a pretty classist elitism viewpoint, and it's completely unwarranted.
- rajacombinator 8y agoThose “3rd world business models” are amazingly efficient though. Just because the “1st world” is rich doesn’t make us smart, in fact it may be the opposite. Also, when all the bootleg crap and non-bootleg crap is made in the same factories in China, what’s the difference?
- rchaud 8y agoIf by 'amazingly efficient', you mean the burden of assessing risk and quality is shifted entirely to the customer for every single transaction, then sure. I'm coming from the developing world. The lack of regulations and product safety standards, is not some kind of competitive advantage, it is a problem that leads to ever falling living standards. A fire in a clothing factory killed 1300 people in my country, an incident that would have been avoidable if the building owner enforced fire safety standards. I suppose if you think about things in terms of MR/MC curves, such loss of life is the price of efficiency.
- r00fus 8y ago> Now it's Amazon selling bootleg crap at scale. What's their excuse? Some variant of "move fast, break things", no doubt. Seems to me Amazon felt they couldn't compete against eBay or AliExpress and still be "low on prices". Essentially they chose that market (including copying sellers products and rebranding them as Essentials) over legitimate sales.
- squarefoot 8y ago"What's their excuse? Some variant of "move fast, break things", no doubt. " Possibly "sell at 50% discount, thrice"