6 ms·
As proof that I am clearly not qualified to run a nearly trillion-dollar company, I offer this advice to Amazon -- ditch the marketplace. No more third party s
by rootusrootus 8y ago
As proof that I am clearly not qualified to run a nearly trillion-dollar company, I offer this advice to Amazon -- ditch the marketplace. No more third party sellers.
I have been a reliable Amazon Prime consumer for years, but I have begun making purchases elsewhere because I can not even trust "Ships from and sold by Amazon" any more.
At the very least, quite intermingling stock. And at this point you're going to have to be public about that change and put a guarantee behind it. Your reputation is slipping.
- strictnein 8y agoAnd the prices on some of the stuff is just weird, with a lot of the Amazon provided stuff now stuck behind Amazon Prime Pantry. I used to order a lot of our daily household stuff from Amazon: cleaners, dish soap, detergent, etc. So much of that stuff now is priced just horribly. $4 for a bottle from Amazon, but it's just from Prime Pantry so you have to order a bunch of stuff or be stuck with a high shipping cost. If you go with one of the other sellers, the prices are frequently 2-3x normal retail, I guess preying on the fact that people don't realize they're getting ripped off.
- Wowfunhappy 8y ago>If you go with one of the other sellers, the prices are frequently 2-3x normal retail, I guess preying on the fact that people don't realize they're getting ripped off. And as a result, I've become much more careful about checking prices on Amazon, which can't be good for Amazon overall. By contrast, when I go to the grocery store, I generally assume the amount I'm paying is more-or-less the same as what I would pay elsewhere. (Likely a poor overall mindset on my part, but good for the store.)
- PhasmaFelis 8y agoYeah, there's a lot of specific products that are always wildly overpriced on Amazon. Mostly anything that is out of print/out of production, no matter how recently it went out or how easy it is to find, but I recently ran into it with Hanes underwear of all things--there wasn't a single seller that wasn't asking at least 50% over Target's online price. For out-of-print books/toys/games/etc., eBay is usually your best bet. Computer hardware (video cards, RAM, etc.) is often cheaper on either eBay or NewEgg. Et cetera.
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoI expect out of print stuff to fetch a high price, I'm more talking about standard grocery items. I've seen ridiculous markups on penne pasta, diet soda, certain brands of hand-soap, etc etc. Some of these items, like the pasta, are things I'd previously ordered from Amazon for a fraction of the current price. Which, again, has caused me to be much more cautious—every time I reorder something nowadays, I have to check whether the price has changed. How does Amazon expect people to use stuff like the dash button when prices can vary this much?
- reaperducer 8y agoHow does Amazon expect people to use stuff like the dash button when prices can vary this much? I have a couple of Dash buttons for Gatorade and pistachios and such. I stopped using them because I couldn't be certain of a reasonable price, or that the products wouldn't be fakes. Safety > price > convenience, Amazon.
- secabeen 8y agoThe reality is is that shipping an amazon item costs between $3-7. For expensive items, they can cover that cost out of the wholesale/retail markup, so you don't really have to pay it. For cheaper items, or items without that much of a markup, it starts showing up in the price. Now, sometimes a manufacturer will want to buy some market share, so they'll sell an item to Amazon cheaper to reduce that impact, and then it's available. However, it will usually go back up to the normal price, with them hoping that you won't notice.
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoIt's the products that suddenly shoot up to 2-3x normal retail that throw me, not the ones that change by a few dollars. But the products that double in price have made more sensitive to the ones that change by a few dollars, because I'm now on high alert for price changes in general.
- 8y ago
- tcarn 8y agoAgreed, which is why I really love camel camel camel. Makes me a much more informed consumer. I wish they had other sites that they tracked.
- secabeen 8y agoThey used to, but I think the other vendors made them stop, and they don't have the same affiliate program that Amazon does.
- reaperducer 8y agoPerhaps I spent too much of my youth watching supermarket-themed game shows, but I'm very much in tune with how much things should cost in supermarkets, and how they vary from chain to chain and region to region. It was for that reason I started buying my household stuff at Amazon — because I could save a buck or two, per item, which adds up. Then — as you pointed out — stuff got weird. Amazon's prices became consistently higher than the supermarkets. Then the third-party sellers started using "AI" pricing, so that a package of soap bars that is $3.59 at Safeway is $61 on Amazon. Then the counterfeits arrived, and now my family has a policy of not buying anything from Amazon that goes on, or in, our bodies. These days there are bargains to be had through Amazon, but only through the two-hour shipping from Whole Foods. At least in my market. (A particular cheese that is $15/pound at Kroger is $5/pound when I get it delivered from my local Whole Foods.) It's not too late to Amazon to regain trust. But it's not going to be a quick or easy process.
- godzillabrennus 8y agoFor the longest time I would have added to your list of things not to buy on Amazon anything claiming to be OEM Apple products. It was likely they were fakes and if they provide electrical power they may be a fire hazard. Amazon seemed to realize how big of a problem this was (or Apple took them aside and made it a problem for them) because they just announced they are taking action: https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/bjexb5/amazon-is-kicking-all-unauthorized-apple-refurbishers-off-the-site https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/bjexb5/amazon-is-...
- wingworks 8y agoI find it a little worrying that in that vice article they don't seem to at all talk about the counterfeiting issue that was widespread on Amazon for Apple products.
- binarysolo 8y agoAmazon manufacturer/distributor of home and kitchen goods here - the rule of thumb is that if it's <$20 (and especially if it's <$10), Amazon's pricing structure to its third party sellers basically compels low dollar items to be more expensive than retail. Basically we pay Amazon $1 or 15% of sale (whichever is higher + ~$2.50 for shipping before anything else, so after margins and what not that's a minimum of $4 going to Amazon for marketing and logistics. That's why low dollar 1-pack items feel like price gouging -- there's been years of A/B testing on the marketplace that shows a $4.99+free ship item is way more attractive than $1.99+$3 shipping. Amazon itself sells stuff direct from manufacturer at a loss or breakeven-ish cost for items under $3 because they can, but even those prices aren't hugely sustainable and they play around with algorithmic pricing themselves over time. Retail logistics for low dollar items is a Hard problem. :|
- zjaffee 8y agoIt's also worth noting that people don't think of the externalized cost of actually getting to the store verses getting these things shipped. If you have to drive a mile each way just to get that one extra item, the amount your saving from not ordering online is insignificant.
- strictnein 8y agoRetail price at Target, Walmart, etc on this is ~$2.89 a bottle. On Amazon it's the "Amazon Choice" for $13.97 for two bottles. https://www.amazon.com/Formula-409-Purpose-Cleaner-Bottles/dp/B06W2LP11M/ https://www.amazon.com/Formula-409-Purpose-Cleaner-Bottles/d... You can get the normal retail prices on all this stuff and still shop online. You just can't do that on Amazon any more.
- binarysolo 8y agoYep, Target.com is 2.89 with $25 free ship https://www.target.com/p/formula-409-powerful-all-purpose-cleaner-spray-bottle-lemon-32-oz/-/A-13162353 https://www.target.com/p/formula-409-powerful-all-purpose-cl... -- but for what its worth, the online stores are mostly loss-leaders for the big department/grocery stores trying to stay relevant against Amazon. https://money.cnn.com/2018/05/23/investing/target-earnings/index.html https://money.cnn.com/2018/05/23/investing/target-earnings/i...
- bdcravens 8y agoI think a lot of people were using Prime to small quantity low-margin items, and they were losing on shipping costs.
- davinic 8y agoAs a former marketplace seller I couldn't agree more. The only inventory I would ever want commingled is the stuff that's not quite up to new quality. It never made sense that Amazon would want that risk. When I sent it in it was only tagged by the ASIN, so I assume they couldn't even trace bad counterfeit or damaged merchandise supplied by a 3rd party merchant.
- bitrrrate 8y agoI agree with this. Amazon could still be a huge marketplace if they stocked the virtual shelves and only sold legitimate items or their own brands. Target does it and that is where my business has been going instead of Amazon.
- richsinn 8y agoFor this precise reason, I've stopped buying things like baby food, baby toiletries, skin lotion, etc. from Amazon. I now purchase direct from the respective online store, or sites like walmart.com/target.com
- antjanus 8y agoI had the same issue. And ordering the same product (even from the same "seller") is hit or miss. It's a weird story but I ordered a kids plate from Amazon. I ordered 2 that were totally fine but when I ordered a 3rd one, it was completely different quality, seemed to be a different material, and had a weird smell to it. It was "Prime" but almost immediately, you could tell it was a different product. This has happened to me a bunch and I've heard crazier stories about people ordering supplements/vitamins and getting fake bottles :( I don't trust Amazon as much either outside of a few products I trust + majority of common electronics. I wouldn't buy an HDD from Amazon for instance due to their crazy shipping shit. Also, their shipping is so fucking unreliable. I get delays on my packages at least twice a month, and they've lost packages before :(
- LeftTurnSignal 8y ago> I wouldn't buy an HDD from Amazon for instance due to their crazy shipping shit I stopped buying anything electronic from Amazon because one power to USB adapter burned up, tripped a circuit breaker, and it broke my fridge. Luckily, that was the only other thing I had plugged into that circuit at the time. Another big issue was my friend bought an Apple power adapter that started smoking after a few hours of it being plugged into the wall. Scary stuff, especially when you consider anything that goes on or in your body could be counterfeit too.
- astura 8y agoWhen people tell me they buy condoms and sex toys from Amazon,I get legitimately worried.
- AndrewHampton 8y agoIn case you're interested, Steve Yegge had a recent post about the origin of the marketplace: https://medium.com/s/story/jeff-bezos-jack-ma-and-the-quest-to-kill-ebay-bb4992dc5020 https://medium.com/s/story/jeff-bezos-jack-ma-and-the-quest-...
- rootusrootus 8y agoDefinitely an interesting read, thanks!
- jsonne 8y agoYou could eliminate most of the problem by Amazon just ditching seller central and moving to exclusively vendor central where Amazon is purchasing from the buyers but they still manage their listings, marketing, etc. Since Amazon purchases and resells the inventory I imagine they have a vested interest in it not being junk products.
- jayess 8y agoOr separate regular Amazon from the marketplace so a user can search one or the other.
- devbot9 8y agoAs a long time independent seller, Amazon has virtually already done this by gating nearly every brand under the sun. It's hard to sell so much as a box of pens without a bulk purchase invoice and a picture of you high-fiving the manufacturer's CEO.
- 51lver 8y agoRight there with you. I moved all my purchases to ebay. At least there you know who you are buying from, and many manufactures have official stores. There are still bootlegs, but you have some say in how much risk you are willing to take. Eg, don't buy classic nintendo games from overseas. If amazon let you research a seller and see if they are a knockoff mill that would be a huge step forward, but they would ALSO have to isolate inventory again for it to be reliable.
- erichocean 8y ago> As proof that I am clearly not qualified to run a nearly trillion-dollar company, I offer this advice to Amazon -- ditch the marketplace. No more third party sellers. Last I heard, it was ~50% of their revenue. And they take a 15% cut of the price, plus a per-transaction fee, for the cost of maintaining a product catalog (which they already do). Not a chance they'll drop it.
- rootusrootus 8y agoIf they do not find a way to believably eliminate the counterfeit problem, the marketplace may end up a lot more than 50% of their revenue.
- cco 8y agoMaybe a more "nearly trillion-dollar company" twist on your idea: The Prime Marketplace, only official providers, e.g. Sony, Bose, and products sold, and vetted, by Amazon only available to Prime members.
- xkjkls 8y agoThe data they get from what is popular on marketplace justifies its existence alone. Without marketplace, Amazon would be in the dark about what products they should even begin stocking.
- darksaints 8y agoI think Amazon dug themselves into a hole with this one. The Amazon Marketplace is the biggest liability to their brand reputation, but now it is also a big revenue driver. It would be in the long term interest of Amazon to ditch it, or severely clamp down on authorized marketplace participants. But Amazon is now in a sticky situation because the stock price, which they rely on for many reasons, is heavily dependent on revenue growth. AMZN's ridiculous P/E ratios aren't really ridiculous when you think about it. Everybody knows Amazon pumps most of its free cash flow back into the business, which increases their growth rates at the expense of current earnings. The prices they are getting for the stock are just the result of a market betting on the future profit potential of Amazon when the growth stops or slows to normal levels. High prices imply that investors see huge amounts of growth potential, and if you extrapolate out what that P/E means, it shows that AMZN investors see Amazon growing 10x larger (or more) than it currently is. But now Amazon has this huge liability of the Marketplace, and in order to cut it out they have to cut back their revenues by a substantial amount. And a revenue slowdown or decline signals to investors that growth is slowing. Needless to say, the anticipated future value of Amazon will cut quite drastically with a hit to revenues. Compounding the problem is the fact that so much of their compensation comes in the form of RSUs, which are new issues. This is a great growth strategy, because it reduces their dependence on free cash flow for compensation, allowing it to be used for investment. BUT, any hit to their stock price will require drastic increases in RSU grants in order to maintain personnel, further exacerbating a drop in stock prices through dilution. I don't envy the person who has to solve this problem.
- sct202 8y agoYeah it's going to be a long draw down period if they're going to try to control this without tanking themselves. Think about all the warehouse capacity that is devoted to these third party products. Not to mention the backlash if they start to block 3rd party sellers. I was reading the other day that companies (Popsockets for example) were mad that Amazon was making them switch from 3rd party vendors to direct vendors--for reasons like control on assortment, promos, and pricing.
- structural 8y agoIt's rather more likely that the marketplace won't be cut back, due to exactly the factors you've mentioned. The real issue, of course, is that all of this cheap junk sells, and sells really well, even if it's counterfeit or just junk. So there really is a lot of growth potential in that part of the business: the growth and success of Walmart over the past twenty years is further evidence of this. Probably wait for something to be announced like "Prime Plus" for premium brands as they try to figure out how to differentiate products in the market, or watch them continue to expand into new types of markets altogether... there's very little for them else to do.
- jasode 8y ago>I offer this advice to Amazon -- ditch the marketplace. No more third party sellers. But for many things I shop for, that would be extremely inconvenient for me. For example, I needed to buy replacement fuses for a Fluke multimeter. Amazon itself didn't sell it but a 3rd-party marketplace seller did. If the marketplace was shut down, I'd have to go through the hassle of registering a new account on yet another ecommerce website just to buy that fuse. In this day and age of customer databases getting hacked, I'd rather not create any new accounts unless absolutely necessary. Yes, I get the danger of counterfeit items. I did get bit by that with fake eclipse glasses from China last year but nevertheless, the 3rd-party marketplace has been a net positive for my shopping experience. I just pay attention to the seller ratings and make sure they're better than 98%.
- j79 8y ago> I just pay attention to the seller ratings and make sure they're better than 98%. Maybe I'm just extremely cynical, but you don't feel those are somehow gamed? For parts that you've described, I've actually moved to eBay as my first stop.
- jasode 8y ago>Maybe I'm just extremely cynical, but you don't feel those are somehow gamed? I think the reviews for products are gamed but I don't think the seller feedback ratings are. I used to sell used books as a Amazon marketplace seller and I once sold a book that was damaged and put that condition in the description. The buyer bought and gave me 1 star rating for it and described the damage that I already put in the description. The buyer just didn't bother to read the description before he bought it. I couldn't get Amazon to remove that unfair rating. If there's a way to game the seller feedback in a sustainable way across thousands of ratings, I'd like to know how. Sure, sellers could offer refunds to bribe customers to change their seller rating from 1 star to 5 stars (not sure if that's even possible) but eventually, the seller will run out of money with that scheme. On the other hand, product reviews are easier to hack.
- rootusrootus 8y agoThat sounds like a good match for eBay, though. Amazon is presenting itself as a store, eBay is presenting itself as a marketplace. In the same way I would run Amazon into the ground, I would suggest to eBay to embrace the marketplace and phase out the auction aspect. This is why I'm a software engineer and not a retail tycoon ;-).
- yourapostasy 8y agoJust ordered an Apple cable a couple months ago directly from Apple through their Apple Store app, and about $1K USD of Ring security gear off their web site for exactly this fraud reason. If I know I want to purchase a name brand object, I now shop at the manufacturer's site first; if I don't need the Prime delivery aspects, and there is no significant difference in pricing, then the manufacturer site gets my consumer information. And I haven't even been bitten by the Amazon commingling fraud yet, just bitten by egregiously craptastic products bought off of Amazon. I can't trust the reviews without carefully parsing them to figure out which ones are likely factory-generated. I can't trust the pricing without looking through various historical price add-ons. At that point, the cognitive load between using Amazon and choosing alternative channels is pretty meh, and I'd rather just go "straight to the source", ordering direct from the manufacturer and finding the manufacturer by looking up forum discussions. For renewing household goods, I'm finding myself shopping at my local grocery chain, Target and WalMart a lot more these days. Once Amazon pricing for the same household item shows it is more than these other sources (and often by a surprisingly large delta), Amazon doesn't get a crack at that spend for another year, as it isn't worth the cognitive bandwidth to comparison shop each time I go to the grocery store, or if Target/WalMart deliver the best price, they get the subscription for the year. I use a credit card number generator for subscriptions, so we have to renew the configuration each year. Amazon is losing its convenience value proposition, and I find taking their eye off of that ball very odd for a B2C context, but what do I know.