3 ms·
Evaluating this is tricky. On the one hand, Bloomberg claims it's a well sourced article, not a single person's unsubstantiated claim. On the other, Super Micro
by ineedasername 8y ago
Evaluating this is tricky. On the one hand, Bloomberg claims it's a well sourced article, not a single person's unsubstantiated claim. On the other, Super Micro claims an audit showed nothing, but then they have an incentive to be less than honest, or to have performed a very superficial check. And couldn't an audit simply miss the issue if the malicious functionality were embedded in an otherwise legitimate chip?
Either way, it seems like Bloomberg really should have pushed for a particular example, e.g. "look at this on model X boards for confirmation"
- kickopotomus 8y agoI am more inclined to believe Super Micro at this point. It is not just them that are denying this. Apple and Amazon have denied it as well and Apple even went so far as to write a letter to Congress[0]. With a hardware attack like the one that Bloomberg reported, there should be some actual physical evidence out in the wild but nothing has been found to date. I think that they really failed with regards to due diligence. [0]: https://www.scribd.com/document/390401381/Letter-October-8th-Version https://www.scribd.com/document/390401381/Letter-October-8th...
- fraudsyndrome 8y agoSuper Micro didn't perform the audit of themselves (that would be silly), it was done by Nardello & Co as per the article.
- ineedasername 8y agoYes, but the level of detail requested for the audit would be dictated by Super Micro. For example, if the request was to audit boards against the design specs, the audit would never catch something inserted during the design phase. Nor would it catch malicious functionality inserted as part of a legitimate chip. It seems like the potential number of attack vectors is extremely high if the design &/or manufacture process has been subverted. Alternatively, if there was no attack, it becomes exceedingly difficult to prove the negative. But that also leaves us with the perplexing situation of multiple sources-- 17 from different companies and NSA-- deceiving Bloomberg reporters. Or Bloomberg reporters themselves deceiving everyone. In the later case the motives are clear. It's a career-making story that can't easily be disproved. In the former case the motives are less clear: a desire to smear Super Micro? Who benefits? A desire to stoke anti-China fear? It's all very strange.