5 ms·
That ... sounds like it violates every bank's ToS out there, and not the abusive buried-in-fine-print part, either. Every bank could, quite reasonably, cut off
by SilasX 8y ago
That ... sounds like it violates every bank's ToS out there, and not the abusive buried-in-fine-print part, either. Every bank could, quite reasonably, cut off your access for this.
- eropple 8y agoThey could, but they won't (barring a change in the ecosystem). Basically everyone does exactly this when a bank doesn't have a federated login system. Take, for example, Personal Capital.
- SilasX 8y agoSo all these services are storing plaintext passwords for the banks?
- eropple 8y agoYup. When done as-correctly-as-possible those passwords should be encrypted on a per-user basis and keys should not be stored in the same datastore as the ciphertext. That's what we ultimately did for a project circa 2013; I assume that most folks do similarly.
- bwood 8y agoBasically, yes.
- philfrasty 8y agoIt does, but it still allows large businesses to be built on this rather fragile approach, see for example (european) SOFORT that got sold to Klarna. The only thing they did was allow you to pay directly with your bank account in online-stores that used them although banks (mostly) didn't cooperate with SOFORT (they also conveniently checked you account balance and any prior failed transactions).
- smnrchrds 8y ago> bank could, quite reasonably, cut off your access for this. It's worse than that. Sharing passwords with third-parties typically "voids the warranty." If money is stolen from your account, the bank can deny reimbursing you because giving a third-party your password voids their zero-liability guarant guarantee.
- sjtgraham 8y agoThis is actually false in many jurisdictions, including the entirety of Europe.
- tothrowaway 8y agoWhen you sign up, you grant the service the limited power of attorney to login as you. Typically a POA needs to be witnessed and/or notarized. I'm not sure how they're getting around that.