4 ms·
I just have a hard time believing incentives don't work. For example, if I lost all of my stock options today and was told I'd never get another raise or bonus
by kenjackson 16y ago
I just have a hard time believing incentives don't work. For example, if I lost all of my stock options today and was told I'd never get another raise or bonus, except CoL, I'd quit on the spot.
In fact I'd argue, if there were no financial incentives, most HNers wouldn't do startups. I know everyone likes to say they do it to change the world and the passion of something or other. But in reality I've yet to see many founders take a $50k salary only (but keeping voting power) despite the profits of the company.
- tptacek 16y agoIncentives work great. Incentives aren't the problem. The basket of formal performance-driven compensation programs colloquially referred to as "incentive pay" are the problem. Incentive pay includes: * Formal periodic performance reviews * Scheduled bonuses based on "job performance" * Ranking of employees (this is the old GE performance management paradigm; "up or out!")
- rhizome 16y agoLosing all of your stock options or having something else taken away is not a negative case for incentives, it's an example of a disincentive, which also has an effect. They aren't the same thing, and you can tell because you don't know how well you'd be working if you never had the options in the first place (and hadn't been denied them or otherwise been treated unfairly). One of the reasons you don't see many founders take a $50k/yr salary is that very few of them are truly confident of success. I once heard an aphorism, "don't trust a founder who won't put their own money into the company." It's a little pointed and unrealistic, but you get the idea. In an industry driven by a mythology of becoming the next big thing (parallels to the equally one-in-a-million mindset in the music industry), no founder can afford, professionally and with regard to reputation, to treat themselves as anything but a foregone success, and that attitude requires "competitive compensation." This means they want to be paid as much as other unsure founders. The "low-salary superboss" is a product of already-successful companies.
- kenjackson 16y agoWell I think I'd also turn down most jobs that said, "We'll pay $150k/year with no further financial incentives ever". Unless my goal was simply to to do as little work as humanly possible, yet still collect a check, I'd be hardpressed to work there. And if I did, despite non-financial that exist in the world, I really don't think you could get me to work more than 40 hours per week.
- JabavuAdams 16y agoAre you really saying that you wouldn't work more than 40 hrs per week for < $150k. It's the money that makes you put in extra hours? The thing is that there's a huge number of talented people out there who will put in extra hours because the work is interesting, or they feel that if they don't, they're letting the team down. In fact, the really really talented developers seem to care less about money (after a nice base-line), and more about the work / team. Or, other obsessive (and useful) qualities make them unable to say no to work, etc. So, who would a company prefer to hire? Obviously, the qualified person who would work for free, because it's their passion. Interestingly, $150k/yr is a lot more than I've ever made, but that's neither here nor there.
- kenjackson 16y agoAre you really saying that you wouldn't work more than 40 hrs per week for < $150k. If there were no other financial incentives, absolutely. I have no problem saying, "No" to work. I bust my butt doing 100 hour weeks so that you can ship Mario Halo World and make $500M opening weekend, I deserve to be compensated. Even if I love the work, I can spend that 60 hours per week that you're not paying me to work on something else I love. It's one thing to be RMS and working on your lifes passion for free. It's another thing to, as an employer, expect to ask someone to forego tucking their son in for the next 6 months, because you need to make $200M, but will not compensate them at all. I don't doubt there's people that will volunteer to do it out of some sense of passion or loyalty, but it won't be me. I know what I'm worth.
- kenjackson 16y ago
- gamble 16y agoIt's not only about the money, but it's still about money. No matter what the company's 'mission', anything that changes the distribution of equity or profits will bring out that truth awfully quick.
- jacques_chester 16y agoAn insight gleaned from Donna Meadows is that profit is not the purpose of a company's existence. Profit is merely survival, it's what facilitates the company staying "in the game". Her view is that the purpose of companies is to grow.
- nostrademons 16y agoThat observation was made by Peter Drucker, fairly soon after WW2. Profit is the cost of continuing to do business; it's necessary to ensure that you are allocating your efforts efficiently, but is not the intrinsic raison d'etre of a corporation. His view was that the purpose of companies was to serve a social purpose. The purpose of Google is so that people can find information. The purpose of Microsoft is so that people can use their computers. The purpose of Merck is to keep people healthy. I like this viewpoint a whole lot better than Milton Friedman's corruption ("the purpose of a corporation is to increase shareholder value"), where an abstract measuring stick necessary to ensure corporate accountability somehow became the whole principle that society was organized around.
- jacques_chester 16y agoThanks for correcting me.