My comment is that blanket statements here are inappropriate, and I certainly don't imagine there are only two states a cat can exist in. There are many, many b

My comment is that blanket statements here are inappropriate, and I certainly don't imagine there are only two states a cat can exist in. There are many, many breeds of cats and cats have distinct personalities. Statements like 'contradicts their nature' cannot be made about something as broad as 'all cats', because there are so many natures being discussed.