6 ms·
If the House's conclusion is that software of this complexity is impossible to secure, then it seems reasonable that we should treat any data stored in it as in
by danShumway 8y ago
If the House's conclusion is that software of this complexity is impossible to secure, then it seems reasonable that we should treat any data stored in it as insecure. Maybe companies as complex as Equifax shouldn't have access to the data they have access to.
I'm pretty tired of companies telling me that it's fine for them to hoover up extremely sensitive information like my social security number and then turning around after a breach and saying, "well, there was nothing we could do."
It can't be both. If it's impossible to secure companies, then maybe Merriott shouldn't be asking for anybody's real name when they sign up for a hotel. Maybe we should stop using credit agencies for identity verification and start investing government resources into a separate 2-factor system. Maybe you should have a legally protected right to lie to businesses that ask for your personal information.
Equifax leaked personal information for 50% of the US population. If you were voting, and there was a 50% chance that your ballet and voting history was going to be leaked publicly after the election, you would expect either:
A) Someone is so incompetent that they're going to jail, or
B) The system we're using is so fundamentally broken that we need to rethink the core paradigms of how it's built.
To me, a report like this sounds like the House is saying that where corporate security is concerned, B is the answer.
- mpd 8y ago> as complex as Equifax I can only imagine that this point becomes lawsuits that span decades.
- rhizome 8y agoSomeone is so incompetent that they're going to jail, or On this point, I can see no other explanation except that government and business are colluding against the people whose data is being leaked in order to normalize a lack of privacy. Token fines are handed out on the order of seconds worth of annual profit, sometimes minutes, but nobody's going to jail, certainly nobody in the boardroom or executive bathroom. Because fuck you that's why. Not only this, but we certainly aren't going to be able to sue as individuals over it, but why not? Why does personal data only have a value when someone sells it, why not at rest as well? These leaks contribute to financial criteria that are used to determine interest rates paid on loans, e.g., so a number value is calculable. I'm not holding my breath. Target should have had to close stores to close the shortfall from leak penalties, and Equifax and Marriott should have their corporate charters dissolved.
- mr_overalls 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture
- rhizome 8y agoI don't even think it's that, it's just been evolution through convenience. Corporate lobbyists say "hey don't create any pain around data leaks k?" and legislative aides say "that sounds cool, can someone pass the shrimp?" If there's a Occam-friendly alternative explanation I'm all ears, but I've been looking for a while and I haven't found anything.
- txcwpalpha 8y agoSending someone to jail just because they're deemed "incompetent" by some subjective measure is a good way to make sure that nobody ever takes that job position. Chief Info Sec Officer positions are already hard enough to fill because most competent cybersec people are wary of inevitably being fired because of some random breach that is mostly out of their control. If you add even just the threat of jailtime onto that, hardly anyone is even going to dare taking on the CISO role. And that certainly doesn't do anything to make our data more secure. Stern punishments for fraud/lying/cheating on security audits would be great, but punishments for "incompetence" would have the opposite effect.
- 8y ago
- jonwachob91 8y ago>>> maybe Merriott shouldn't be asking for anybody's real name when they sign up for a hotel It's important to distinguish that it wasn't actually Marriott that had the data breach. It was starwoods resorts, now a marriott owned entity, but at the time of the breach it was not a marriott property. Marriott is being attributed to the guilty party b/c they now own starwood, but Marriott's systems were never breached, so marriott should keep doing what they are doing (presumably) and transition all the starwood systems over to the more secure marriott systems (which I believe they already said they are doing).
- danShumway 8y agoThat's a really good point, Marriott just had an unlucky purchase. That being said, between the recent Google+ breaches, to the older Target breaches, it increasingly feels like I'm flipping a coin when I trust companies with data. Based on Marriott's handling of this breach, they seem to be decent at security. But I don't know how as a consumer I could tell that in advance of all of this.
- jonwachob91 8y agoYou are 100%, and it's not just the data we provide to companies we buy products from. I got snail mail last week from an employer I haven't worked for in almost 3 years that said an administrator accidentally sent a mass email to a few thousand individuals with my bank account information, and the bank account information of everyone that was on that email chain (and I'm assuming a few other prior employees). WTF.
- arduanika 8y ago> Marriott just had an unlucky purchase M&A is a culprit in no small number of these cases, so let's be crystal clear: M&A does not absolve anyone of responsibility. Let me know when the underwriting bankers have their bonuses garnished for lack of due diligence, and then you can tell me about how "it wasn't actually Marriott that had the data breach". Let's say it loudly and clearly: no, it was Marriott that had the data breach.
- usertest1 8y agoGood
- dylan604 8y ago>and start investing government resources into a separate 2-factor system Gov't issued Yubikeys or a new gov't issued "smart ID" with a 2-factor system as part of it?
- arduanika 8y agoC) Wipe out the stockholders Sending some fall guy to jail is shooting the messenger. The message from the stockholders is: we don't care about security or privacy. The message the feds should send back to them is: well you should. Conversely, no one's going to "rethink the core paradigms" without some money on the line.
- passive 8y agoI think this is probably where this needs to go (prison time is interesting, but if we can't get it for financiers who profit off of crashing the economy, we'll never get it for ostensible negligence). Establish standards for the value of stolen data. Something like the worst possible case. So for Equifax, which is potentially a gold mine for identity theft, fine them the average stolen identity cost (~$1300), for each of the 143 million records. 200 billion dollars (probably even 20 billion) seems it would be sufficient enough incentive to properly secure our data. I also suspect we would need some kind of regular auditing, to ensure companies could afford a breach. Something like this would be a substantial drain on startups, as it would add another significant risk factor. In the long run, what probably needs to happen is some kind of "data insurance", and we just expect that all companies working with our personal data carry it (or possibly even legislate that they carry it, similar to automobiles). It would make things easier for startups, who would pay much cheaper rates while their adoption was low, while also incentivizing them to limit their data collection to only what they needed. Disclaimer: I work in the insurance industry, focused particularly on property insurance for disaster prone areas. Lately it feels like there are a lot of parallels between how personal data is stored these days, and Florida in the 90s.
- txcwpalpha 8y agoDoing cybersec consulting, the majority of the clients I worked with already had data breach insurance. The funny thing is that such insurance actually just makes it easier for these companies to cheap out on actual security. What's better for the bottom line, paying $50 million for a strong security program (that will probably get hacked anyway), or pay $20 million for a good insurance policy that will just cover all our damages when we get hacked? (the actual path chosen is usually somewhere in the middle, but I hope you see my point)
- powvans 8y agoMaybe you should have a legally protected right to lie to businesses that ask for your personal information. This is interesting. I almost always fudge my birthday a bit when asked for it. If I'm applying for a loan or opening a bank account or dealing with the government, of course I provide the correct information. But it feels like a really bad idea to provide my actual birthday to strangers whether on the Internet or not.
- nihonde 8y agoAs with all disinformation, eventually the truth is meaningless. In your example, eventually the wrong answers may gain credence as correct, and you’ll find yourself unable to “verify” your own birthday when you really need to! Still, I find the option of sowing disinformation a pragmatic and sensible decision in the face of relentless and dangerous incompetence without any accountability or consequence.