8 ms·
The Most Effective Weapon on the Modern Battlefield Is Concrete (2016)
- dssu 8y agoProbably shouldn't have enjoyed an article on concrete this much
- cpmsmith 8y agoArchive: https://web.archive.org/web/20181210211633/https://mwi.usma.edu/effective-weapon-modern-battlefield-concrete/ https://web.archive.org/web/20181210211633/https://mwi.usma....
- NegativeLatency 8y agoThanks, wasn't loading for me.
- wging 8y agoSee also: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12962776 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12962776
- adolph 8y agoSee also the Hesco bastion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hesco_bastion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hesco_bastion
- all2 8y agohttp://www.bjp-online.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/Majeed02-1024x768.jpg http://www.bjp-online.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/Majeed0... These 30 foot jersey barriers (they called them t-walls) went up around Bagram Air Field when I was there on vacation in 2010. Before that, all that they had was a 16 foot chain link with concertina on top. Not really great at stopping bullets.
- billforsternz 8y agoDidn't think I'd ever see "Bagram Air Field" and "vacation" in the same sentence.
- all2 8y agoPerhaps there is some sarcasm there. Maybe a certain amount of playfulness.
- billforsternz 8y agoWell played sir.
- metaphor 8y agoHesco's drag-a-container-to-deploy product[1] is quite clever. [1] https://www.hesco.com/products/mil-units/raid/ https://www.hesco.com/products/mil-units/raid/
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- v_lisivka 8y agoCurrently, the most effective weapon is false news, and other tools of information war. Facebook, Twitter, and Youtube will spread them almost for free.
- v_lisivka 8y agoCan anybody explain why this comment has so much downvotes, please?
- matchbok 8y agoBecause this article is about concrete.
- v_lisivka 8y agoArticle is not about concrete. It's about effectiveness of concrete on modern battlefield (especially in guerilla-like war), with false claim that it's most effective weapon. As officer of army at war, I know that concrete will not help much at battlefield. Hard concrete causes ricochet, soft concrete spreads fragments. Concrete is not movable. Concrete is hard to recycle. Concrete is hard to destroy in case of retreat. In case of guerilla-like war, propaganda, agents, double agents, and false news are much more effective, about thousand times more effective than concrete. Make double agent in a guerilla, then spread false news about his glory, then shot in the back everybody who will join him. Problem solved.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- beginningguava 8y ago>At over $600 a barrier, the cost of concrete during the eight years of the Iraq War was billions of dollars Does anyone have any insight as to why resistance forces are seemingly so much more effective today compared to the past? Rebels were able to bleed the US of billions with the threat of a cheap car bomb In the past there didn't seem to be situations like Vietnam and the middle east with guerrilla warfare being able to drag things out for years and making things so costly. Is it because the US isn't willing to go total war and massacre civilians until they give up Mongolian style or what?
- fake-name 8y ago> Is it because the US isn't willing to go total war and massacre civilians until they give up and stop aiding rebels or what? Or maybe because we did stuff like that, and it lead to more resistance. You can't murder your way to peace. Killing for peace just leads to everyone being dead.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- hutzlibu 8y agoSure you can murder your way to (temporary) peace. Empires did it all history long. But they could do it (mostly) openly and did not had to pretend to be nice, so they could do it consequently. Killing until the rebell spirit was crushed and enslaved. The problem empires face today is that this behavior is not acceptable anymore and the empires have to act like they are there for the local people. So conquering, but not calling it like that and pretending to be nice while doing it. Hypocrite. And does not work so effective in terms of control. Because if you kill only those who indeed fight against you, than yes, their relatives are your next enemies etc. Related: What Ghandi achieved in India he probably could not have done if the Nazis would have been the enemy empire as the british empire allready was bound by human rights. The Nazi Empire was not.
- jandrese 8y ago
- gbolcer 8y agoThe most effective weapon on the modern space battlefield is boron-nanotube foamed concrete, though it'll probably work on earth too. (PhoamBCon)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ohiovr 8y agoThe title made me think of the killdozer.
- yread 8y agoPrevious discussion with 192 comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12962776 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12962776
- lixtra 8y ago> In response to the situation, the US forces basically engaged in siege warfare. But atypical to historic examples, instead of attacking to break through fortified wall, they imposed the siege on the enemy by building walls. This concept is about 2000 years old. [1] [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Alesia https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Alesia
- azernik 8y agoSo common there's even a word for it: circumvallation. Not just that, but it's also fairly common for the besieging army to also have to worry about an enemy field army trying to relieve the besieged area, and so have to build a contravallation - another wall facing outwards outside of the circumvallation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Investment_(military) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Investment_(military) The only really new and interesting part is the challenge of besieging a single neighborhood within a larger conurbation - historical examples usually include a large open space between the defender's fortifications and the circumvallation.
- lixtra 8y ago> The only really new and interesting part is the challenge of besieging a single neighborhood within a larger conurbation. Ghettos in the third reich come to mind. They were less an element of conventional warefare but definitely an element of extermination warefare. Without the ghetto the killing would have happened less orderly. Sick.
- azernik 8y agoTactically, the "element of extermination warfare" made the character of that fighting very different than what's going on in Iraq.
- arbuge 8y agoAnother famous example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siege_of_Masada#Roman_siege https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siege_of_Masada#Roman_siege The Romans seemed to have been particularly fond of this technique.
- peterwwillis 8y agoAlthough this article highlights soldiers as building barriers, the majority of base construction on the modern battlefield is done by contractors. This article from 2013 is, well, "interesting" to put it lightly: https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2013/05/contractors-385-billion-military-bases/ https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2013/05/contractors-385... A company controlled by Dick Cheney made the most money in the Iraq & Afghanistan wars. It's probable that those wars would have been logistically impossible otherwise, considering how many contracts they held and how vital a role they played. Someone said that control of a superior supply chain wins wars [or at least, delays their resolution]. But private contractors, not the US Military, control the supply chain. They supply virtually every aspect of the temporary-cities that are U.S. wartime bases. Without them, we can't have these wars. And the people who run them work in the highest levels of government. It's less conspiracy theory than blatant war profiteering. I think this brings up two interesting points. (1) If you control the corporations that profit, and you influence the government's war policy as well as budget, you can create wars for profit. Would we even have these wars if contractors weren't involved? And (2), if the contracting companies "went away" tomorrow, would we still have the military might we imagine we have?
- ArchTypical 8y ago> They supply virtually every aspect of the temporary-cities that are U.S. wartime bases. Without them, we can't have these wars. I don't believe this at all. We don't need these 'green zones' to run a war, as the US has done many times before. We did need them to run a specific kind of war, which was a blitzkrieg occupation. Not saying it was a bad plan, it certainly achieved some measure of success, but pretending that it's the only way to engage in war is unwise.
- manigandham 8y agoIf there are no private contractors then the US Military would just takeover those duties itself.
- alistairSH 8y agoI believe that was the OP's point. If these roles are filled by soldiers instead of contractors, the profit motive for war goes away. At the time, the VP's company was providing billions of dollars of support for the war in the Middle East. While he had divested himself while in VP, to think there was no influence would be naive.
- jhallenworld 8y agoHedgerows served the same purpose in the past. I thought one of the justifications for the English enclosure acts was national defense, but now I can't find a reference. In any case, French hedgerows certainly made the D-day invasion difficult.
- masonic 8y agoFrench hedgerows were a typical property-boundary mechanism long before retreating Germans utilized them for defense.
- kawera 8y agoNorth Korea uses concrete traps in the DMZ: https://99percentinvisible.org/article/hostile-terrain-tank-traps-fake-towns-secret-tunnels-korean-borderlands/ https://99percentinvisible.org/article/hostile-terrain-tank-...
- trhway 8y agoso, an autonomous self-propeller 3d printer using sand and solar to build the walls is the weapon of the future.
- timoth3y 8y agoGeneral Smedley Butler's "War Is A Racket" is every bit as relevant today as it was when he published is it in 1935. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_Is_a_Racket https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_Is_a_Racket For those of you who have never heard of Smedley Butler, he was a rare kind of American hero. WWI commander, advocate for veteran's rights, and single handly thwarted a Fascist coup in the United States.
- cphoover 8y agoWouldn't AI be cheaper, With recognition + automated interdiction likely being more effective in the long run? This is what I don't understand about Trump's "border wall", aren't there more effective means like drones and advanced surveillance of the border?
- mrnitrate 8y agoInteresting Rebuttal: Concrete Barriers: A False Counterinsurgency Idol (2017) https://mwi.usma.edu/concrete-barriers-false-counterinsurgency-idol/ https://mwi.usma.edu/concrete-barriers-false-counterinsurgen...