3 ms·
>> He ends the essay with "All I am saying is to give Ps (and Qs) a chance.". But who exactly is this aimed at? It's a slightly garbled (and so not immediately
by YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
>> He ends the essay with "All I am saying is to give Ps (and Qs) a chance.". But who exactly is this aimed at?
It's a slightly garbled (and so not immediately recognisable, perhaps) pun on the verse "All that we're saying/ is give peace a chance" from John Lennon's "Give Peace a Chance".
So it's not addressed to anyone- it's just his attempt at injecting a bit of levity in the debate.
EDIT:
>> If Ps (and Qs) is a better approach then do the research and publish the results.
Well, people have done that, yes. For example, the Evans and Grefenstette paper Marcus' article cites towards the end has shown in a very clear manner the power of combining symbolic with sub-symbolic approaches, as has the work of, off the top of my head, Artur D'avila Garcez (neuro-symbolic computation), Luciano Serafini (a differentiable logic), and many others.
And yet, my intuition at least is that most people who have heard about Deep Learning, haven't heard about that work.
- laichzeit0 8y agoThis comes across a bit like the Tanenbaum–Torvalds monolithic/microkernel debate in the 90s. Tanenbaum in this case is Marcus and Torvalds is LeCunn. There are so many well established benchmarks out there. Just build whatever this symbolic system is that you're advocating and beat the benchmarks. Or maybe create your own benchmarks and then we can also apply Deep Learning to those problems too and see who wins? Until then, no one really has to pay any serious attention to these clamourings.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoThat's what the work I mentioned above does- it beats benchmarks and shows impressive results. The work by Evans and Grefenstette in particular is all out of chewing gum [1]. Somewhat depressingly, your comment makes me guess that you really think that none of that work has actually been done, that it's somehow all theoretical or speculative, or just a lot of twitter talk by Gary Marcus. That couldn't be farther from the truth. It's really the case that many people have no idea about AI beyond a quick article in the popular press here and there, and despite this, they have already formed very strong opinions about it. _________________ [1] Here: https://deepmind.com/blog/learning-explanatory-rules-noisy-data/ https://deepmind.com/blog/learning-explanatory-rules-noisy-d... Note that the above overview of their paper is published on DeepMind's website (the two are DeepMind employees). You can rest assured that DeepMind in particular, would never support the publication of a paper that doesn't demonstrate impressive results.