6 ms·
Reinventing the wheel without any clear advantage. Plus codes don't seem to have any advantage over widely used MGRS (Military Grid Reference System). https:/
by nabla9 8y ago
Reinventing the wheel without any clear advantage.
Plus codes don't seem to have any advantage over widely used MGRS (Military Grid Reference System). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_Grid_Reference_System https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_Grid_Reference_System
- chronial 8y agoI find them a lot more human-friendly, but I guess that's subjective. The example from the wiki page you linked: MGRS: 4QFJ12345678 Plus Code: 835M+Q7 Honolulu
- dzhiurgis 8y agoWait a second. So 835M+Q7 is not a full identifier? You need to specify city too? Ain't that gonna cause problems?
- arghwhat 8y agoIt's a referenced plus-code, which "saves" 4 digits. Instead of being a true location like the full plus code, coordinates, or MGRS, a referenced plus-code requires a referenced location to resolve (think "124 meters north of the postal office"), and the precision becomes entirely dependent on the precision of the services used to resolve the reference location (i.e. Google Maps might consider the exact location for "Honolulu" to be somewhere else on the island of Honolulu than Bing Maps).
- detaro 8y agoNo, they do not work relative to a point. You replace the first 4 digits of the code (the area code) with a location name that's clearly in the area, the following digits stay the same. The name resolution of the location can be off by kilometers and it still works.
- arghwhat 8y agoWhile you are correct in stating that the point is only used to resolve the area, you conclusion is off by kilometers (he he he). When using a point to resolve a 4-digit code (1x1 degree, approx 100x100km), it is true that anywhere within the same 4-digit-equivalent area will result in the same location. However, while this improves the average case compared to point referencing, it makes the worst case absolutely horrendous: You'll end up referring to a wrong long/lat degree, meaning an error of over 100km! The closer you are to the edge of a lat/long degree, the more vulnerable you are. If your location is, say, 10 meters from the edge, then 10 meters geocoding imprecision is all it takes to cause a >100km error. Which is exactly why the plus-code readme says the following, as I have quoted before: > If the reference location is derived from a town or city name, it is dependent on the accuracy of the geocoding service. Although one service may place "Zurich" close to the Google office, another may move it by a hundred meters or more, and this could be enough to prevent the original code being recovered. Rather than a large city size feature to generate the reference location, it is better to use smaller, neighbourhood features, that will not have as much variation in their geocode results. In order for the reference system to work, references must either be close to the center of a lat/long degree (which allows great error margins on geocoding), or use points which have consistently high precision. Neither case result in memorable reference codes like "XYZ Honolulu", so just using the extra 4 digits is the only sensible choice.
- arghwhat 8y agoThat's only a partial plus-code, though, which relies on external positioning of Honolulu. The full plus-code is 4 digits longer, and with the plus itself, it's 11 chars vs. 12 for MGRS at 10m precision (14 for 1m, which is more than plus-codes can do). If MGRS was too long, it could simply get a new encoding and be done with, or add the abbreviation system. Also, that particular plus-code you used as example is not recommended. Reference points should be small features that will have low geocoding variance. Larger points like cities, or here whole islands, as there can be very large variance to the exact location derived from the name (i.e. the pinpoint location Google Maps finds you when you just search for Honolulu). From the README: > Rather than a large city size feature to generate the reference location, it is better to use smaller, neighbourhood features, that will not have as much variation in their geocode results.
- chronial 8y ago> That's only a partial plus-code, though, which relies on external positioning of Honolulu. Yes, a concept that is very human-friendly. > Also, that particular plus-code you used as example is not recommended. Reference points should be small features that will have low geocoding variance. Larger points like cities, or here whole islands, as there can be very large variance to the exact location derived from the name (i.e. the pinpoint location Google Maps finds you when you just search for Honolulu). You should take that up with the google devs I guess. The code I gave was generated by google maps.
- arghwhat 8y ago> Yes, a concept that is very human-friendly. It's also entirely broken, rendering the system unusable if you expect sub-kilometer positioning across different geocoding providers. Whether something entirely defective is "human friendly" doesn't really matter. > You should take that up with the google devs I guess. The code I gave was generated by google maps. Not my responsibility. That they cannot even use it correctly as per their own docs themselves doesn't make for a good sales pitch. In fact, Google Maps cannot process plus codes using arbitrary reference locations, making use per the plus-code documentation impossible with it. To give an idea of why that plus code is borked: Honolulu @ Google Maps: 21.3069444,-157.8583333 Honolulu @ Bing Maps: 21.30493,-157.85788 The difference is around 300 meters, which results in an absolutely awful error margin, and I'd argue that this is very much one of the best-case scenarios. That's worse than if they had added 2 more characters to the plus code, and just removed the Honolulu part.
- nabla9 8y agoMGRS has variable precision just like Plus code. 4QFJ12345678 has precision 10 m. Example of plus code with comparable accuracy: 73F69J3M+VV 10 km accuracy in MGRS is just six letters: 4QFJ16 100 km accuracy is just 4 letters: 4QFJ
- chronial 8y agoThe Plus code I gave as an example addresses a 14x14m square, Not 10 km.
- widforss 8y agoMy exact thought. This is identical to MGRS, except that you lose the "cartesian coordinates locally" feature.
- andkenneth 8y agoMGRS doesn't allow you to ommit the larger value coordinate chars instead of a city/place name. MGRS doesn't use a charset that doesn't have ambiguous charachters. Just two. Might be minor, but it's not no advantage at all.
- markild 8y agoCouldn't you "kinda" achieve the same with MGRS? I've seen a few maps where the first page states what grid zone and 100,000-meter zone the map is in (for the honolulu-example, "Honolulu" would imply 4QFJ).
- phicoh 8y agoIn my opinion, a big disavantage of MGRS is that it is based on UTM. These days nobody uses UTM and UTM is hard to grasp if all you are used to is lat/lon coordinates. So the clear advantage of Plus Codes over MGRS is that it is based on lat/lon
- Waterluvian 8y agoNobody uses UTM? Whaaaat? UTM is widely used in many many geographic endeavours. It was the de-facto standard for almost any analytical work during my master's and I bet still is. When you're dealing with smaller areas than a country or the whole planet, there's a ton of value of using linear units instead of arcs. Once you try to do any meaningful spatial analysis, you're projecting your lat/lng to a linear unit. And UTM is possibly your first choice of projection depending on context.
- widforss 8y agoUTM is widely used and is the standard way of expressing position within many countries, where lat/lon is second-class citizen on everything but phone navigators.
- kiriakasis 8y agoI imagine that you wanted to put focus on "second-class", but if we focus on "everything" we would have a compelling argument for lat/lon as a base for a transmission format.
- teilo 8y agoSpherical coordinates systems are always a tradeoff between usability and simplicity. Plus Codes are certainly simple, easier to calculate, and consistent, but UTM has clear advantages in that it utilizes a Mercator projection adjusted for the contour of the earth, so that distances remain close to scale within any given grid zone… …except in Norway. In Plus Codes, the scaling is lost, and the distance covered by coordinates of equal precision changes dramatically with latitude. Of course, there is also the fact that the mapping ellipsoid used by UTM changed at some point, so old coordinates can be off by up to 200 meters compared to the current mapping. But the current system has been in use long since the advent of GPS, so it's really not an issue.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- johnx123-up 8y agoWhat about Geohash https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geohash https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geohash ?