7 ms·
In The Netherlands some cyclists have this brilliant idea to put their lights on flash/flicker. I suppose some think they'll be easier to get noticed. It is no
by Fnoord 8y ago
In The Netherlands some cyclists have this brilliant idea to put their lights on flash/flicker. I suppose some think they'll be easier to get noticed.
It is not allowed by law (the light has to be either constantly on, or it may be turned off if it isn't dark), it can trigger epilepsy, it is distracting, and it is selfish and not 'cool' at all.
It also appears to be common in PC desktops to enable all kind of LEDs, without allowing them to be disabled. Especially in all kind of colours (which Razor dubbed 'Chroma'). Not my cup of tea, a waste of aesthetic and electricity but the worst thing about it is that I pay premium for such feature because it is deemed 'cool' by the target market.
FWIW, I use a strong light in the morning to wake up. It doesn't flash.
- Tharkun 8y agoBelgium had similar rules for cyclists, but recently updated them. Cycling around like a strobing christmas tree is now allowed. sigh
- fingerlocks 8y agoFlashing bike lights are ubiquitous in the United States. I prefer them because I can distinguish a cyclist from what could be a slow car missing a tail light.
- arendtio 8y agoWell, I don't like those lights either, but calling it selfish, is kinda hard when you compare it to how many cyclists get killed every year because some motorist didn't see them.
- mverwijs 8y agoMy focus constantly shifts back to the blinking, missing that bike that has no lights on or less-obvious lights on.
- Doxin 8y agoThe problem being that judging the motion of a blinking light is nearly impossible. A blinking light is both more attention grabbing and less safe for the user.
- Freak_NL 8y agoThis is something that should really be solved by regulating bicycle lights sold, or a very broad public awareness campaign. These cheap Chinese LED lights for the bicycle all come with a blink-setting, and like the <blink>-tag of yore, it serves no practical purpose. People tend to think blinking means you are easier to spot in the dark, which is true in the sense that it grabs attention, but as you mention, you can't really extrapolate where someone is going with a blinking light. The use of the blinking setting is usually born from naivety. People use the setting, because it is included with the light — why else would it be there, if not to use it? Now imagine if every cyclist on a busy cycleway used the blink-setting. At that point this behaviour is downright selfish. It's not too hard to regulate really. After all, you are already legally limited in what you can use (white/yellow front, red back, no blinking).
- simtel20 8y agoI believe the blink mode is documented as extending the battery life, at least in the manuals I've read.
- magicalhippo 8y agoThe significant battery drain is driving the LED when it's on, so having it on only half of the time effectively doubles the battery life.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Doxin 8y agoThat still doesn't explain the (rather common) lights with about 7 different types of blinking.
- upofadown 8y agoIn an urban environment there will usually be more than enough light to see and predict the course of a cyclist. The trick is attracting the attention of people that are not looking in the first place. Flashing lights work very well for stimulating peripheral vision in a moving visual field.
- lbotos 8y agoAs someone who just spent a week in the Netherlands, they are super serious about their biking infra and have gone great lengths to make it safe: https://www.dutchreach.org/car-child-murder-protests-safer-nl-roads/ https://www.dutchreach.org/car-child-murder-protests-safer-n... In the NL, yes I might call it selfish. In NYC, not so much.
- Yetanfou 8y agoBlinking lights save power and lead to longer battery life, hence the cycle lights with different blink settings. The power savings can be substantial, one of the back lights I use switches between 'full on' (3 leds, full power) and 'walking blink' (¼ second on/off). Subtract the (negligible) power used by the timer IC and you end up with a factor 6 difference in favour of the blinking light. Here in Sweden blinking lights are still allowed, one of the places where you'll meet them is on the railroad as Swedish trains have blinking back lights.
- jacobush 8y agoBlinking headlights on bicycles are not allowed in Sweden. (It's hard to argue with the market forces of millions little LED lamps though, combined with disregard or not knowing about the law.) http://www.gp.se/nyheter/g%C3%B6teborg/inga-blinkande-framljus-p%C3%A5-cykeln-1.48667 http://www.gp.se/nyheter/g%C3%B6teborg/inga-blinkande-framlj...
- Yetanfou 8y agoHeadlights, no. Blinking taillights are allowed though (with a minimum blink frequency of ~3.3 Hz / 200 per minute) and those are the ones I mentioned. Blinking taillights do make bicycles stand out more which can only help in a country like Sweden where cycle paths are as rare as hen's teeth. In the Netherlands (where I'm from originally) this is less urgent as there are plenty of cycle paths.
- jacobush 8y agoIf you speak of for instance Stockholm, they are rare. In some other cities (I don't want to out myself) they are everywhere.
- adrianN 8y agoIf you find blinking lights on cyclists annoying, that means you noticed them. So they accomplish their mission. Blinking lights are significantly easier to notice from peripheral vision.
- DanBC 8y agoSeeing something is not the same as having enough information about that thing to avoid an accident. The christmas tree effect probably doesn't keep cyclists safe, although it's tricky to research this.
- adrianN 8y agoWell you certainly have more information than if you don't see them at all.
- Freak_NL 8y agoBut less information than with a non-blinking light. By blinking you are making it harder to extrapolate direction and speed from your observations.
- DanBC 8y agoYou're saying "don't see them at all", but we don't know if that's what happens. We don't know that drivers don't see fixed lights, or see flashing lights more often. And we don't know what information they get from the lights.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- 24gttghh 8y ago>Seeing something is not the same as having enough information about that thing to avoid an accident. I'm really confused by this thinking. If there is a blinking white light pointed at you it means the cyclist is on the other side of the road, traveling with traffic in the opposite direction. If it is blinking red then you are approaching the cyclist traveling in the same direction as you, on your side of the road. If you see both lights blinking, with the white light on the left, then the bike is traveling left across your direction of travel. White on the right for the opposite. What information am I missing here? I feel like any of these combinations should be enough for a driver to notice a cyclist and to give them a sufficiently wide berth.
- Steve44 8y agoThere are quite a lot of these in the UK too, again I'm not sure of the legality. As a driver I've two things to say about them. Firstly, they do make it easier to spot the cyclist over a solid light so that's a good thing. However, it's almost impossible to track their movement and that is a very very bad thing. The best solution I feel is to have a flashing light which draws attention in addition to a solid light which is much easier to keep track of in your peripheral.
- 4ndr3vv 8y agoThe rules in the UK have changed somewhat over the years; it used to be that flashing lights were only permitted in addition to a constant lamp. Now its fine to only use flashing lights - Rule 60 of the highway code: "At night your cycle MUST have white front and red rear lights lit. It MUST also be fitted with a red rear reflector (and amber pedal reflectors, if manufactured after 1/10/85). White front reflectors and spoke reflectors will also help you to be seen. Flashing lights are permitted but it is recommended that cyclists who are riding in areas without street lighting use a steady front lamp."
- Already__Taken 8y agoWith the insane brightness now possible I wish they had to meet the same light pattern rules car headlights do. I think that would help the flashing being so distracting.
- rootusrootus 8y agoI occasionally run across bicyclists now with modern LED lights that are more blinding than automobile headlights.
- jacobush 8y agoPray you don't run across this bike light: https://hackaday.com/2018/10/17/diy-arc-light-makes-an-unnecessarily-powerful-bicycle-headlight/ https://hackaday.com/2018/10/17/diy-arc-light-makes-an-unnec...
- fyfy18 8y agoHere in the south of Spain I regularly see scooters (mopeds) that are 20+ years old. Older scooters often have headlights that are so dim you can barely see them (the bulbs just get dimmer, they don't burn out). As a car driver I'd much prefer to see a bright and flashing light so I notice the vehicle, and a bicycle doesn't make any noise so I'm not going to hear it.
- akvadrako 8y agoIt's more about saving battery life than being noticed. And as they are illegal to use they should probably be illegal to buy, at least when marketed as bike lamps.
- PedroBatista 8y agoIt's not only about the flicker, but sometimes those lights are as intense as high-beams! But cyclists tend to get a pass with almost everything for some reason.
- rhinoceraptor 8y agoYou have a much greater need on a bike to see road detail, you need to look out for potholes and sticks on the road. In a car, you just need to be able to see the road lines and reflect light off of signs. I use a 1200 lumen bike light, powered by two 3500mah 18650s.
- PedroBatista 8y agoThat's great for you, now imagine the guy coming the opposite direction being blasted with 1200 lumen in the eyes. Sure you made him aware of your presence but you also made him blind to any other stuff or people besides you.
- brokenmachine 8y agoThey get a pass for having lights because they are the most vulnerable people on the road.
- monkeynotes 8y agoSurvival is inherently 'selfish', selfishness is the fundamental basis of organic life.
- Fnoord 8y agoThat doesn't justify this behavior. If I were in a trolley problem and would have to decide between my own life or my daughter's I would die to save her life. Likewise, if this society does things which endanger my daughter's life I'd like such threats eliminated. I'm convinced this is one of the destructive examples, especially if it becomes popular or the norm.
- monkeynotes 8y agoYour daughter's life is pretty closely tied to the survival of your genes. This sort of philosophical debate has been discussed for centuries though.
- brokenmachine 8y agoSo if your daughter was cycling, would you want her to have flashing lights so she can be seen by drivers?
- Fnoord 8y agoOf course not, she'll be seen by normal lights.
- monkeynotes 8y agoWell, according to some research flashing lights are more likely to be noticed: https://www.lrc.rpi.edu/resources/pdf/iesna01a.pdf https://www.lrc.rpi.edu/resources/pdf/iesna01a.pdf > Flashing lights will be perceived as having higher brightness than steady-burning lights, up to a flash frequency of about 15 flashes per second. Such brightness enhancement can aid in conspicuity, and several rear lighting systems have been designed to have a flash rate between 5 and 9 flashes per second in order to maximize their perceived brightness. I think deep down we all know this anyway, which is why we want flashing lights if we are on a bike amongst traffic. Why on earth would emergency vehicles and maintenance vehicles use flashing lights if they were equally effective to steady lighting? Your daughter's bike would be far more noticeable with flashing lights.
- cimmanom 8y agoI thought only certain frequencies trigger epilepsy?