4 ms·
You're completely wrong. On a fixed guideway system--that includes vanilla railways and things like monorails--a train that is stopped completely blocks the en
by jcranmer 8y ago
You're completely wrong.
On a fixed guideway system--that includes vanilla railways and things like monorails--a train that is stopped completely blocks the entire track, and cannot be routed around except via switches. The minimum headway between trains is dominated by switch fouling: how long it will take a train to pass over the switch, and then for the switch to switch to a different track, before the signal can go green again. You'll also want some extra padding on top of that for timetabled trains, to take into account unexpected long station dwells and schedule recovery.
The throughput of most subways is about 26 trains per hour. With good signalling and track management, you can push it to about 36 trains per hour on a branched line; an unbranched line (which simplifies management a lot!) can get up to 45 trains per hour, but those are definitely not typical numbers. Train length doesn't impact these numbers much, definitely not at the scale of variation being discussed.
Express trains require dedicated tracks to be able to bypass parked trains, or insanely good timetable-keeping to not get stuck behind a local train before a bypass. NYC built a lot of its trunks to 4 tracks, which allows it to make local/express trains, but most systems have found it's easier to just build another 2-track trunk a few blocks away than to try to add 4-tracks to the 2-track trunk.
The idea of trying to use tiny cars with much narrower safety margins for headways is the idea behind personal rapid transit, but PRT systems have been shown to have utterly lousy throughputs: pulling 10,000 people/hour on a trunk PRT line would be a significant milestone, whereas the standard 8-car train on a 26TPH subway easily pulls 25,000 people/hour without needing much effort.
- avn2109 8y agoThis is a really great comment and should be much higher on the page, and I appreciate that you took the time to write it all out.
- steve_gh 8y ago26 trains an hour is pushing it hard. The London underground generally runs at about 24 TPH at rush hour on a single line (in each direction) If you go to a moving block signalling system you can push the system a bit harder, but the problem is that as the trains get more crowded, their braking distance increases (which increases the block size - so fewer TPH). Also, at rush hour the dwell time at each station increases because more people are getting on and off - again impacting the headway. So pushing the TPH on a metro line is hard...
- iggldiggl 8y ago> The London underground generally runs at about 24 TPH at rush hour on a single line (in each direction) Not quite. All of the resignalled lines manage more than that. The Central line reaches something between 27 and 30 tph, the Jubilee Line 30 tph (and I think there are still plans to go even higher) and the Victoria Line 36 tph. The Northern Line is a bit special because of its branching, but the single section south of Kennington towards Morden manages 30 tph as well. And even the Subsurface Lines (which for the largest part are still conventionally signalled, although not for much longer) manage around 27½ tph on the north (Baker Street - Aldgate) and south (Tower Hill - Gloucester Road) sides of the circle. > the problem is that as the trains get more crowded, their braking distance increases A properly designed brake system will a) be designed to achieve the required deceleration even under maximum loading b) include load compensation, i.e. the braking force for each car is adjusted depending on its loading to achieve the same deceleration so no, that shouldn't really matter.
- adrianmonk 8y agoBasically, I see three ways of looking at what Boring Company is trying to do: 1. It is being built by people who don't know what they're doing and don't understand the field, and it isn't going to work. (This seems to be the way you look at it.) 2. They expect to be able to reduce the costs of tunneling so drastically that the lower throughput of PRT won't even be a problem. 3. They plan to use an unprecedented level of automation to advance the state of the art in how PRT can be done. (This is my guess.) Obviously, nobody really knows which of the above is the case. They haven't shared a lot of detail. But in support of the idea that it _could_ be #3, there's a reason I think there's room for innovation in PRT. It's so expensive to build any transit system that relatively few attempts have been made at PRT. And some things have changed since many of those tries, mainly advances in automation. So for example, if switching is a bottleneck for headway, maybe there is a way to build a much faster switch but nobody has put the R&D money into it yet.
- iggldiggl 8y ago> The minimum headway between trains is dominated by switch fouling: how long it will take a train to pass over the switch, and then for the switch to switch to a different track, before the signal can go green again. The absolute minimum spacing between two trains running non-stop one after the other perhaps. Unless you imagine a system where at each station the line splits into two or three separate tracks, for all practical purposes however the actual limiting factor will be stations, as the combination of platform reoccupation time and dwell times will significantly larger than switch fouling time alone.