5 ms·
It's a very good point. A lot of smart people jumped into an area that if I'm feeling very generous I would call "unproven". And I'm all for startups trying new
by wpietri 8y ago
It's a very good point. A lot of smart people jumped into an area that if I'm feeling very generous I would call "unproven". And I'm all for startups trying new things, but we could have learned just as much about the possible utility of cryptocurrencies with 100x less resources.
My main worry now is that some of the people will have been damaged by this. Some of the interest we can write off as irrational exuberance; hopefully some will have gotten their fingers usefully burned and will be more careful choosing what they work on next time. But a lot of the field was somewhere between chasing a bubble and outright scammy.
It reminds me of people I've seen burned by MLM schemes. Some say, "never again!" But some really buy into the get-rich-quick thinking and will keep on making the same mistake in different forms. "This time it will be different!" But it never is.
- WilliamEdward 8y agoThis is the financial version of natural selection. I don't feel bad for people losing their money over something that had little purchasing power and was very obviously unstable.
- decentralised 8y ago>I would call "unproven". Why wouldn't you call it novel? It's only 10 year old technology at this stage.
- jakelazaroff 8y agoBecause the vast majority of crypto/blockchain things are either outright scams, obviously doomed to fail ("it's Yelp but crypto!") or misapplied ("we're using blockchain intternally"). I honestly can't think of a single crypto startup that's had a compelling product. Edit: typos.
- decentralised 8y agoHow does that make them less novel? Your impression that the "vast majority of crypto/blockchain thing are either outright scams" is a personal opinion for which you can't find supporting evidence. The SEC has only issued a hand full of notifications and LOST the only court case I've seen so far.
- jakelazaroff 8y ago"Scam" was only one of three categories I mentioned, but regardless here's a nice long list: https://www.scambitcoin.com/blacklist https://www.scambitcoin.com/blacklist Ten years into the Web we had Google, Amazon, Geocities, eBay, Flash games, and thousands of existing companies moving their operations online. What is a single blockchain-related success we can point to other than cryptocurrency exchanges?
- decentralised 8y agoWho manages that list? Why do you trust it? edit: I looked through the site and most of the "scams" seemed more like basic phishing sites than actual blockchains or cryptocurrencies
- DonHopkins 8y agoYour anecdote is irrelevant. Scam sites usually give up their bitcoin related domains when they fail, which invariably get taken over by basic phishing sites. You should look on the Internet Archive to see what the scam sites were actually doing, before they went out of business and had their domains taken over by phishers. Funny that you trust and parrot Bitcoin scammers, but you don't trust a list of Bitcoin scammers. Afraid some you've invested in, hyped and promoted yourself might show up?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- decentralised 8y agoWhat anecdote? I've pointed out that most of the scams didn't actually involve a blockchain or tokens, as the SEC cases against a few of them show. The question of who manages the list is important so we can tell what method was used and what's the motivation to keep it. One of the areas I'm most interested is cryptoeconomics and of course fairness and transparency matter to me which is why I wonder why would you defend this site as if you knew it to be true and accurate.
- adam 8y agoYou might check out numer.ai, along with their coming data marketplace, Erasure. They've been running for awhile...
- berbec 8y agoWhat other ten year old technologies, that went on to be successful, were as useless for their stated purpose as crypto? If crypto is money, can I: Spend it at Amazon? My grocery store? My corner deli? Pay my rent? Pay my employees? If crypto is a store of value can I trust it will have any rational storage value over any time period?
- yxhuvud 8y agoDigital cameras, when invented back in the 70s. It took decades until they were usable, and still another decade until they started to approach the quality of nondigital.
- berbec 8y agoGreat example!
- gl00pp 8y agoAnd the industry leader (Kodak) at the time didn't think digital would be useful and delayed R&D. But don't worry they came up with Kodakcoin!
- DonHopkins 8y agoTo convert Kodakcoin to cash, you have to send rolls of 12 Kodakcoins at a time off for a week to the lab to be developed. But just wait until some day there will finally be a Coinomat booth in every shopping center parking lot that can develop your Kodakcoins into cash in only 24 hours!
- lalaland1125 8y agoYes, but the real world advantages of digital cameras were apparent from the very start. Currently there are zero real world practical use cases for cryptocurrency that aren't associated with illegal activity. If anyone knows of legal applications of cryptocurrency, feel free to respond. I'd love to be proven wrong.
- throwawaymath 8y agoWhy not both?