3 ms·
The body gets "scavenged", and then it gets cremated. The ash people get in an urn or necklace is very, very little amount of the total amount of ash. I carry
by Fnoord 8y ago
The body gets "scavenged", and then it gets cremated. The ash people get in an urn or necklace is very, very little amount of the total amount of ash.
I carry a donor, and I want to be cremated as well (since I find it pathetic to use land after I passed away). If I die, I want whoever is left on Earth to benefit from my legacy. Mainly my family, but also others who are in need. I'd only be grateful if someone else would do the same for me if they'd pass away.
This is why I support the modernisation that being a donor is opt-out in 2019 instead of opt-in (in NL).
As far as I'm concerned, those who are donor get priority over those who are not donor, to avoid leeches (akin to people who don't vaccinate who benefit from those who do).
- eveningcoffee 8y agoI find this potentially very dangerous because this may motivate people who are supposed to save you to value the value of your body parts over the value of your life.
- Fnoord 8y agoNot judging you [1] but I do find that a very misanthropic view of humankind. Those who save you are unable to know beforehand to whom your body parts are going to get used to. Doctors don't even know this beforehand either. Perhaps if you got very rare characteristics. I've had to make the decision in the past to give my father, who was already very ill, one of my kidneys. That's a very difficult and emotional decision to make... [1] I used to be not a registered donor because I didn't want anyone except my nearest family members to know about this. However, knowing about it right after death because it is in your wallet or registered on the internet can save lives.
- eveningcoffee 8y agoI do not find myself misanthropic but I do not live in an idealistic bubble. It does not matter if doctors know who would use your body parts. They even may be idealistic - you may help to save multiple lives. So they will make a decision, even perhaps subconscious, between your life and those potential saved lives. There is a nice scene at the beginning of Dr Strange movie about this. There should be some checks and balances so that the doctors will not become butchers. Perhaps the need to get an agreement of a close relative.
- kwhitefoot 8y ago> since I find it pathetic to use land after I passed away You aen't using it up. You, or your heirs, etc., just rent the plot for a while. Where I live every resident is entitled to a plot in the local churchyard for twenty years, if you, or your family, want more then you pay a fee for more years. The town has been in existence for at least two hundred years yet the size of the graveyard increases only as the population increases. My wife's ashes were buried there last year and there is room on the gravestone for my name and that of my children if they want it so it could be occupied for another hundred years. However, it is more likely that twenty years after my death the plot will be reused by another family. This occupies about one square metre. The house I live in occupies about 900 square metres of land so I don't think my wife's ashes are occupying a disproportionate amount of space. Don't take this as criticism, just another point of view.
- Fnoord 8y agoI live in a dense country, I'd rather see the space and money get used for other things such as a playground, or directly to my daughter, or an NGO such as BOF (national equiv to EFF).
- testplzignore 8y agoI guess this must be a regional thing dependent on population density. Where I live in the US, I have seen plots from my ancestors who died 150 years ago. I've never known of any relatives whose plots have been reused. Though the rate at which cemeteries are created/expanded is much lower than I would expect, even accounting for the fact that only ~50% of the population is buried. I've often wondered how to explain the discrepancy...
- extra88 8y agoIn the US, burial plots being for a single individual forever is the norm. Cemeteries basically build up a fund to pay for maintenance in perpetuity. What you describe is more the norm in Europe, I don’t know about elsewhere. https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2018/04/17/603360426/how-american-cemeteries-promise-to-keep-your-grave-forever https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2018/04/17/603360426/how-...