4 ms·
As much as I agree with Tim's premise, this article is mostly useless politicking. The internet suffers from a combination of the tragedy of the commons and wha
by davemp 8y ago
As much as I agree with Tim's premise, this article is mostly useless politicking. The internet suffers from a combination of the tragedy of the commons and what I call tragedy of the new world. [1] The tragedy also afflicts governments, corporations, and foundations. Excuse me if I am skeptical that governments and organizations will fix their inherent issues reflected by the internet. Tim asking politely will not be enough I'm afraid. Meanwhile I'm relatively happy in my current, non-abusive world of HN!
[1]: https://freetradersoftware.com/pages/The_Tragedy_of_The_New_World.html https://freetradersoftware.com/pages/The_Tragedy_of_The_New_...
The tragedy of the new world is a cycle where a group of smart, resource people start a platform that solves some glaring problems. The platform works beautifully and a thriving community of smart, resourceful people come in gathers. More problems arise and are squashed like a game of Whac-A-Mole. Eventually the founders lose their inspiration, quit, retire or die. The remaining members, now of much increased size and diluted merit, cling to processes left behind. As time passes these processes devolve into tradition, ritual, or meme. Due to some unforeseeable change in the structure of the original problem, the rituals stop working. For as long as possible, the members (of much increased size and diluted merit) continue to attempt shoving a square problem through a round process. Eventually a new body of leaders, also of much increased size and diluted merit, come up with a high dimensional hyper plane process to solve the problem. High dimensional hyper planes are impossible for humans to visualize so most don’t understand why the square problem doesn’t fit. After much scratching of heads, the platform dies as people leave to dilute the merit of the new world.
- sfilargi 8y ago> Meanwhile I'm relatively happy in my current, non-abusive world of HN! Sorry for going a bit off-topic, but is it non-abusive or is it our little bubble?
- int0x80 8y agoBoth?
- EGreg 8y agoMeanwhile I'm relatively happy in my current, non-abusive world of HN! Doesn’t what you wrote also apply to HN?
- davemp 8y agoCertainly. HN is still relatively low scale. The average comment is still of reasonable quality. I’ve only been trolled a few times here. I feel the dilution, but I’m pretty content jamming my square needs into a circle and not a deca dimensional pit of doom (:Reddit).
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]