2 ms·
That analogy doesn't speak to me. It brushes over a lot of complexity, infuses value judgments and trivialises important issues. 1) Global warming is not reall
by roenxi 8y ago
That analogy doesn't speak to me. It brushes over a lot of complexity, infuses value judgments and trivialises important issues.
1) Global warming is not really comparable to cancer. Cancer is a healthy system getting disrupted and ending, global warming is simply a system changing. The type of change threatened by AGW is very scary and expensive, but the future is going to involve radical change anyway. Deciding what the change is likely to entail and how many resources to set aside for dealing with it is an important part of the debate.
2) It appears you are invoking a variant of Pascal's Wager. Pascal's Wager is fundamentally unsound. It ignores the fact that we make decisions in a finite world, and some risks are too small to devote attention to (because there are an effectively infinite number of trivial risks that we need trivial effort to deal with, resulting in an infinite demand for finite resources). Resources are limited, if we did believe that climate change was 'not real', then devoting anything to motigating it would be unacceptable.
- jhanschoo 8y agoIf we should change the perspective over from a person to the immune system of a person, it should be an apt analogy. Death by cancer is a system changing from an environment hospitable to the immune system to one extremely hostile to the immune system.