7 ms·
I've said it before, and I'll say it again: There will never be fully driverless cars until we have true AI. The only thing we might have are dedicated lanes o
by ars 8y ago
I've said it before, and I'll say it again: There will never be fully driverless cars until we have true AI.
The only thing we might have are dedicated lanes on interstates for driverless cars, like railroad tracks.
In city driving will never happen without AI.
This is a strong claim, but I'm sticking to it.
- Lxr 8y agoWhat is “true AI” in your opinion?
- jon_richards 8y agoAny sufficiently misunderstood computer program is indistinguishable from AI.
- arbie 8y agoThen I've been writing true AI all my life!
- gameswithgo 8y agothat which powers the first fully driverless cars, apparently.
- ars 8y ago> What is “true AI” in your opinion? Able to teach itself anything from unstructured (unprepared) data.
- wongarsu 8y agoWhich would already make it superhuman. We are good at learning, but not that good.
- jimmy1 8y agoI have a variation of your claim since I think "true AI" is unfeasible: we will never have fully driverless cars until we build the infrastructure to support them, and in that case, we would have been 100 times better off building trains anyways.
- username223 8y agoThanks, I hadn't thought to express it that way. It seems like most of the people optimistic about driverless cars live in the US, and are now trying to deploy them in desert grid-cities like Phoenix. They should try driving almost anywhere else, where the roads have evolved over centuries to support vehicles (cars, but before that carriages) controlled by humans cooperating to get from place to place. Why build robots to operate in that environment, when you can build them their own lane?
- philwelch 8y agoIt’s also not really a meaningful claim, in that you’re mostly just designating city driving as your personal Turing test.
- jobigoud 8y agoHe's saying driving is an AI-hard problem. From all the tasks that humans do we don't know which are AI-hard and which can be done by non sapient software, classifying problems is useful.
- philwelch 8y agoAnd I'm saying "AI-hard" isn't a great classification. Is there a known approach to AI that will result in some android who is can learn human languages and human abilities the same way human children do? Is there any reason to think that getting better and better and better at building self-driving cars or computer vision algorithms or any other AI application is going to magically result in some machine gaining "sapience" and somehow having the ability to do unrelated tasks? Is the contention that if someone does develop a self-driving car, that car will also be able to compose an opera or something if we let it? If we do have a self-driving car, should we try and teach it to write poetry or something? Would this car's failure to learn how to compose a sonnet falsify the contention that self-driving cars are "AI-hard"? To me this all sounds like some type of weird meatbag chauvinism, where it's absolutely impossible to perform any complicated task that a computer hasn't managed to do a good enough job of yet without resorting to building some sort of Commander Data in our image. And, while that may be true for such human abilities as "being able to do a wide variety of genuinely hard things if they are taught, especially at a really young age" or "arguing about abstract concepts we don't fully understand ourselves", driving a car is...well, it's not that hard. Human beings in car cultures learn to do it, but if those same human beings grew up in horse nomad cultures, they would learn to ride horses and shoot arrows from horseback really well, and if they grew up in a different culture they'd get a different skill. Being versatile enough to develop any of those skills given the right childhood experiences seems much harder than any one of those specific skills.
- rootusrootus 8y agoI've got a standing bet with several of my friends that is along those same lines. I haven't gone quite as far as saying it will require true AI, but I did put down money (just dinner, I'm not a big roller :)) saying we're a minimum of 10 years away from being able to buy any kind of level 5 car.
- buboard 8y agospoken like a True Scotsman