3 ms·
I worry this will lead to a further reduction in privacy for average users, as Slack is pushed toward "enterprise" features which are basically just giving your
by freedomben 8y ago
I worry this will lead to a further reduction in privacy for average users, as Slack is pushed toward "enterprise" features which are basically just giving your boss the ability to read all your private messages.
That said, I think it's naive and foolish to have an expectation of privacy on your work slack. Should you have privacy? Yes, absolutely. Do I expect it? No, not at all.
- kevindong 8y agoWhy should an employer not be able to read messages that employees send to one another for the purpose of doing their job?
- dawnerd 8y agoWell if its called a private chat... It's kind of expected that it'd be private.
- BurritoAlPastor 8y agoSlack actually uses the term “Direct Message”, so there’s no textual expectation of privacy.
- freedomben 8y agoPerfectly fair question. I view it much like having a conversation in the hallway or by the watercooler. It would be creepy and weird, and unexpected, to have microphones and cameras all over the office so the boss can record your conversations and eavesdrop whenever they like. It also screams micro-management if the boss needs to drop in, even if you are just using it "for the purpose of doing [your] job." I tend to feel that if you trust your employees so little, then you should just fire them. Conversely if my employer trusted me so little, I should probably quit. Where I would probably make an exception would be if one of the employees filed an HR complaint or something, then I think looking at the existing record would be fine. But, it should be limited in scope to that incident.
- cozicoolmail 8y agoI personally do not think it is a right of an employee to have privacy when having a discussion with another employee, over a work medium, about a work related matter. Just because using the ability to read private messages screams micro-management, it doesn't mean that it's not occasionally necessary to discover instances of harassment or abuse.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- donaltroddyn 8y agoHere in Ireland, we have pretty strict legislation around surveillance in the workplace. Any monitoring has to fulfil the three requirements of being necessary, legitimate, and proportional. It has already been demonstrated that monitoring employee email to ensure that confidential information is not being shared is not consider proportionate (in a normal workplace), so I don't believe that monitoring direct messages in Slack would be lawful here.
- seattle_spring 8y agoThat already exists. The CEO of my last company used it to weed out dissidents.
- skewart 8y agoSlack gives your boss the ability to read all your private messages today. They have for a while now. You probably shouldn't expect privacy in any workplace app, or even when connected to a company network, given how many companies route traffic through proxies that inspect packets for data exfiltration and who knows what else.
- freedomben 8y agoThis is only partially true (unless it has changed in the last few months). IIRC they have to enable that setting, and it does not apply retroactively. Also, employees will be notified if the switch is off and it is turned on. But I agree, don't expect any privacy on a company network, with a company machine, and/or on company-paid apps.
- skewart 8y agoTrue, a company has to enable it, though I wouldn't bet on employees necessarily being notified. Slack's help site page about message export doesn't mention anything about notifying employees on higher tier paid plans (though that doesn't necessarily mean it doesn't happen) [1]. Either way, I'd be willing to bet a lot of money that Slack would happily disable that feature if a seven figure deal were on the line. All that said, it's also not really true that "your boss" can read your private messages, in practice most of the time. Most companies that do this kind of data export just dump it to a warehouse and hold it for safe keeping just in case. Some random director of engineering probably couldn't get access to it unless they were willing to jump through a lot of hoops. Though, Slack's Discovery API does seem to make it easy to create user-friendly interfaces for searching through private messages. But I doubt a lot of companies are doing that. [1] https://get.slack.help/hc/en-us/articles/204897248-Guide-to-Slack-import-and-export-tools https://get.slack.help/hc/en-us/articles/204897248-Guide-to-...
- artursapek 8y agoIf you can't prove a communication channel is private by encryption you put in place yourself, you should consider it compromised. Expecting any amount of privacy from Slack is laughable.