4 ms·
Can anyone perhaps explain a little better what is meant by the interior volume of a black hole grows forever (while the surface area of the event horizon stays
by hn_throwaway_99 8y ago
Can anyone perhaps explain a little better what is meant by the interior volume of a black hole grows forever (while the surface area of the event horizon stays relatively constant)? Felt like the article tried to touch on that but I certainly didn't understand it.
- tuespetre 8y agoIt makes me think of Gabriel’s horn. Like, out here space is finite while time is infinite, but in there, space becomes infinite and time infinite. Very amateur opinion, mind you.
- stmfreak 8y agoImagine a cone with a fixed diameter for the base. That represents the black hole’s external event horizon. Now stretch the point of the cone away from the base... forever, as the singularity warps space time more and more. The volume of the cone (inside the event horizon) will grow as the point moves further away from the base.
- pdonis 8y agoCan you give a reference to a paper that describes the math behind this?
- raattgift 8y agoNeglecting evaporation, it's a lot closer to Yen Chin Ong's results (and those he cites, especially Christodoulou and Rovelli [2]) than most of the comments throughout this discussion, in that with a careful choice of time coordinate a spacelike spherical sector of a Schwarzschild black hole could evolve roughly similarly. Of course, one has enormous freedom to choose spacelike hypersurfaces through a Schwarzschild black hole, so such a result is not especially interesting without some sort of uniqueness proof for the idea, and I don't think that's achievable. (cf [2]). I'm also not sure this is what GP has in mind. - -- [1] https://arxiv.org/abs/1503.08245 https://arxiv.org/abs/1503.08245 (§ 2) (simpler overview: https://www.kth.se/profile/ycong/page/the-interior-volumes-of-black-holes https://www.kth.se/profile/ycong/page/the-interior-volumes-o... ) [2] https://arxiv.org/abs/1411.2854 https://arxiv.org/abs/1411.2854 (§ IV)
- pdonis 8y agoThanks for the references. The Rovelli paper seems to be the key one deriving the claimed result. I have to say the result looks contrived to me: they are constructing spacelike surfaces with increasing volume only by what I would call severe gerrymandering. But that's probably off topic for this discussion.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoThank you! I think that's about the best possible layman's explanation that I could (in the weird world of trying to think in higher dimensions) understand.
- pdonis 8y ago> Can anyone perhaps explain a little better what is meant by the interior volume of a black hole grows forever There is no reference to an actual paper in the article (which is typical for these pop science sensationalist websites), so it's difficult to tell what this is supposed to refer to. As far as I know, it's actually an effect of a particular choice of coordinates inside the horizon, so it's debatable whether it actually has physical meaning.
- mirimir 8y ago> As far as I know, it's actually an effect of a particular choice of coordinates inside the horizon, so it's debatable whether it actually has physical meaning. What's the point of science with no "physical meaning"?
- stareatgoats 8y agoI sense that a lot of advanced maths is like that. It may turn out to have a "physical meaning" at some point - or not.
- mirimir 8y agoSure, but math <> science.
- raattgift 8y ago> There is no reference to an actual paper in the article Hover over the underlined "proposed a solution" in the first paragraph and see https://arxiv.org/abs/1810.11563 https://arxiv.org/abs/1810.11563 -- although the article certainly doesn't go so far as to point to e.g. §23 and the Conclusion, so I at least partly agree with you. I don't have much time for AdS arguments, so haven't done more than quickly skim for relevance to the Quanta article (which I also just skimmed for much the same reason). > these pop science sensationalist websites I can't really agree with characterizing Quanta as either "pop science" or "sensationalist", and presumably the Simons Foundation, it's backer, would disagree even more strongly. FWIW, Preskill liked the article. https://twitter.com/preskill/status/1070865055732916225 https://twitter.com/preskill/status/1070865055732916225 Even though I just skimmed, I certainly agree with the first sentence of Susskind's lecture's Conclusion, even without reading much of the rest of it. :-) (I also agree with the Conclusion's final sentence on p. 83. In fact, the whole last two paragraphs!) For my part, the Quanta article doesn't seem to have done Susskind or the lecture any great disservice. For that alone, I think the OP author should be commended.