3 ms·
As someone who posted one of those RMSs that got closed, I understand your reasoning but am not pleased with the execution. My RMS was not spam. I'd been part
by dbingham 16y ago
As someone who posted one of those RMSs that got closed, I understand your reasoning but am not pleased with the execution.
My RMS was not spam. I'd been participating on the site and had posted feedback to multiple RMSs posted by other people. I only had 50 karma, because many of those RMS posts never made it to the front page or ever got more than a few comments.
I was already getting great and very useful feedback on my own RMS and it had spent some time on the front page with about 23 upvotes. Then it was closed with out warning. I never received an e-mail - or a comment telling me why it was closed. Only that commenting to it was suddenly shut off.
Five seconds would have shown that my RMS was not spam. Reading the comments alone would have shown that. At the very least, I think users posting with in what appears to be the current rule of things deserve the courtesy of a comment or e-mail explaining why their post was killed.
What is the karma threshold or an RMS post?