4 ms·
DNT was added to stop a congressional investigation (and so potentially actual regulation). It did enough at the time to prevent anything happening until it ble
by olliej 8y ago
DNT was added to stop a congressional investigation (and so potentially actual regulation). It did enough at the time to prevent anything happening until it blew over.
No browser ever expected it to do anything other than provide additional tracking metadata.
- ethbro 8y agoOr, as PR people phrase it, to adjust the optics of tracking. That said, I think the DNT flag being formalized is important to web development. Previously, one of the core arguments of advertisers was "people do not care about being tracked". Individuals choosing to turn on DNT demolishes that. Unfortunately, browsers turning it on by default muddles that indicator or intent, even if it's good for individuals.
- hobs 8y agoIt only muddles things if you think people want to be tracked by default. Otherwise it just implements the default everyone already know and advertisers bullshit about.
- dorgo 8y agoThe argument of advertisers is not that people want to be tracked by default. It is that they don't care. DNT had a chance to proof otherwise. But "enabled by default" means that the browsers care, not (necessarily) the users.
- SiVal 8y agoAnd Duck Duck Go's just-released study (https://spreadprivacy.com/google-filter-bubble-study/ https://spreadprivacy.com/google-filter-bubble-study/) shows that Google tracks you, not just DNT or not, but whether you are logged in or not, incognito or not, probably no matter what you do. When Google recently silently made Chrome log you in whether you logged yourself in or not, I switched to a different (previously unused, non-Chrome) browser on a new computer, and without logging in to anything Google (but from the same house), I went to YouTube. It asked me to log in, but I didn't. It proceeded to suggest mainly links to very niche-interest, low-view-count videos I had previously in the past few days, making it clear that it had at least a very good guess who I was anyway. Apparently, asking me to log in was mostly just asking for my permission for what they were going to do whether I agreed or not.
- kiriakasis 8y agoregarding the duckduckgo study there is a bit more to say. Their methodology was pretty flawed and to top it all they also results "positive" to this kind of analysis. This does not implies that google does not track incognito users either.
- judge2020 8y agoRegardless of whether or not the DDG study is accurate, it should be taken with a grain of salt since DDG has a clear incentive to get more people onto their search instead of Google.
- SiVal 8y agoOf course, I agree, which is why I included my own experience as a third example, or the 333rd example, or whatever it is by now. At some point all the tests with different flaws, all the personal experiences that may have other explanations, all the Google statements, the discoveries by companies and governments with vested interests...are all finding the same thing. It adds up to Google tracking us in all sorts of ways, many of which we aren't aware of, in order to give themselves the power to do things on an enormous scale, many of which we aren't aware of.
- smsm42 8y agoIf their study is accurate, why it needs to be suspect just because they want people to use their service? If I provided a good service and my competitor provided a bad one, and I said "this guy does bad stuff, use my stuff instead" and you knew it's true - would you still use bad service just because I'd profit from you using the good one? That makes no sense.
- dylan604 8y agoWho would you trust to run a report like this? The EFF? They have a dog in the hunt too. Congress? Since they believe the internet is made of tubes, I don't trust them either. I can't think of anyone with the skillz to do this type of report will not have a bias one way or the other.
- 8y ago