8 ms·
Why Black Hole Interiors Grow Almost Forever
- m_mueller 8y agoCould this be the source of dark energy and lead to the realization that the universe is a black hole interior?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- shdh 8y agoTurtles all the way down?
- 2bitencryption 8y agothat would seem to explain the "big bang" :) an explosion from an infinitely dense point that is ever-growing, which began in a higher-order universe as a black hole that we now inhabit. (of course I know nothing of science, this is all just pop-sci in my head, but boy is it fun to think about)
- thechao 8y agoBe wary of saying things like "from an infinitely dense point" because you might mistakenly think the universe is expanding from some distinguished point in our space. Instead, the infinitely dense position was in time, and the universe has always been (we think) infinitely big.
- platz 8y agoYeah it's like all points exploded at the same time, but we can only trace our light cone back to one of them.
- halter73 8y agoThanks for pointing this out. I've always thought about the initial singularity as a point in both time and space. Is it still correct to say all the matter that makes up our observable universe started out at a single point in space? Since the singularity was infinitely dense, this at least seems possible.
- thechao 8y agoI'm about to do something terrible, but it helped me immensely to understand the Big Bang. Let's pretend we have a magic box that tells us how space expands over time: V(t) So, t starts at '0', which we're gonna call 't0', and goes until 'now'. So V could be small, it could be big. We don't know, and it kinda doesn't matter. The reason is that the way the Big Bang works is like this: (t - t0) * V(t) So, when t == t0 (the beginning of time), it doesn't matter what shape space (V) has, the size of the universe (spacetime) is '0'.
- yaks_hairbrush 8y agoOne very important difference between the big bang and the interior of the black hole: Within the event horizon of a black hole, there is always a singularity in your future. In our universe, that singularity is in our past. One interpretation: the big bang theory describes a white hole -- the time-reversed version of a black hole.
- IggleSniggle 8y agoImagine our universe is contained within a blackhole. If time and space invert at the event horizon, could it be that the Big Bang was the event horizon of our black hole, that we are forced forward through time by the pull of our black hole interior, and that the expansion of the universe is actually just metatime passing, and as we move through space we are actually moving forward and back in metatime, with the expansion of our universe being an expression of increasing constraints due to metatime’s metaspace as we get closer to the center of our blackhole?
- thefounder 8y agoYes.
- m_mueller 8y agoI could imagine that the “Big Rip” is what we experience when we asymptotically approach the singularity. The strangeness of black holes could mean that falling into a single point is actually experienced as space flying apart faster than light.
- qubex 8y agoEinstein-Cartan Theory (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Einstein%E2%80%93Cartan_theory https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Einstein%E2%80%93Cartan_theo...) introduces a torsion term to General Relativity’s field equations that is not incompatible with observations and provides both an avenue for explaining the cosmological constant (https://arxiv.org/abs/1607.01128 https://arxiv.org/abs/1607.01128) and “big bounce” motivation for the beginning of our current universal epoch (https://arxiv.org/abs/1512.06074 https://arxiv.org/abs/1512.06074).
- rabito 8y agoI wonder if the space region in the interior of a black hole expands the same way as regular space around it. If so, it would seem to be possible for a super massive black hole to be so big that it would be impossible to actually reach the singularity. If there is enough space the singularity would "move" faster than light. Essentially another event horizon within the black hole protecting travelers from the singularity. This would lead to a stable universe like ours. Though about this a few days ago and it seemed like an interesting idea.
- comepradz 8y agoI remember from a youtube video that the spacetime inside the black hole flipped around, where space becomes temporal dimension and time becomes spatial dimension (i.e. time is traversable in either direction while the singularity becomes an inevitable place in the "future").
- rabito 8y agoThat is true, the time and space axis gets flipped at the event horizon. This also happens to a fast moving objects due to relativistic effects, although the roatation is usually not very high unless you go really fast. Seehttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minkowski_diagram https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minkowski_diagram However that doesn't mean you can't move when you cross the event horizon. You can do that like usual (except for gravity pulling you inside. You can. It only means outside observer won't be able to see what you're doing, because of the time dilation (and the event horizon of course). This kinda implies time and space are the same thing, it just depends on your point of view. Still have to see about that :D
- jgrowl 8y agoTo be pedantic, it's not that they are the same thing, but that they are intrinsically tied together: Time begins at the moment of first inflation.
- pdonis 8y ago> the time and space axis gets flipped at the event horizon. This also happens to a fast moving objects due to relativistic effects Neither of these things are true, and I have no idea how you are getting either of them from the Wikipedia article you linked to. Penrose-Terrell rotation, which affects how objects appear to observers when they are moving at relativistic speeds relative to those observers, does not "flip" the time or space axes; it's an optical effect due to the finite speed of light. As I noted in another post upthread, the "flip" of time and space axes inside a black hole's horizon is a property of a particular choice of coordinates, not of spacetime itself. > This kinda implies time and space are the same thing No, they aren't, because there is still a fundamental difference between timelike and spacelike directions in spacetime. That is true regardless of how you choose coordinate axes.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoCan anyone perhaps explain a little better what is meant by the interior volume of a black hole grows forever (while the surface area of the event horizon stays relatively constant)? Felt like the article tried to touch on that but I certainly didn't understand it.
- tuespetre 8y agoIt makes me think of Gabriel’s horn. Like, out here space is finite while time is infinite, but in there, space becomes infinite and time infinite. Very amateur opinion, mind you.
- stmfreak 8y agoImagine a cone with a fixed diameter for the base. That represents the black hole’s external event horizon. Now stretch the point of the cone away from the base... forever, as the singularity warps space time more and more. The volume of the cone (inside the event horizon) will grow as the point moves further away from the base.
- pdonis 8y agoCan you give a reference to a paper that describes the math behind this?
- raattgift 8y agoNeglecting evaporation, it's a lot closer to Yen Chin Ong's results (and those he cites, especially Christodoulou and Rovelli [2]) than most of the comments throughout this discussion, in that with a careful choice of time coordinate a spacelike spherical sector of a Schwarzschild black hole could evolve roughly similarly. Of course, one has enormous freedom to choose spacelike hypersurfaces through a Schwarzschild black hole, so such a result is not especially interesting without some sort of uniqueness proof for the idea, and I don't think that's achievable. (cf [2]). I'm also not sure this is what GP has in mind. - -- [1] https://arxiv.org/abs/1503.08245 https://arxiv.org/abs/1503.08245 (§ 2) (simpler overview: https://www.kth.se/profile/ycong/page/the-interior-volumes-of-black-holes https://www.kth.se/profile/ycong/page/the-interior-volumes-o... ) [2] https://arxiv.org/abs/1411.2854 https://arxiv.org/abs/1411.2854 (§ IV)
- richardw 8y agoI've wondered if the increasing acceleration towards the center slows time down for a particle. As speed tends towards that of light, time slows down and space expands. Is that vaguely in alignment with the actual models?
- goombastic 8y agoAre we inside one of these things as well?
- quickthrower2 8y agoYep, but the outer thing is a simulation running in a kubernetes cluster
- thefounder 8y agoLet's find a bug and get out this thing!
- mirimir 8y agoOK, so what experimental evidence supports the idea that the interior volume of a black hole is growing? That is, what do we observe about black holes that'd be different if interior volume wasn't growing? Or is this just a consequence of current black hole theory, with no explicit experimental support?
- qubex 8y agoNothing. The event horizon is an absolute limit on observability and literally means “the threshold beyond which nothing ever happens”.
- mirimir 8y agoYes. But TFA is all about what's happening there. So (and I apologize, if this seems rude) how is this different from talk about angels dancing on pins? Is it just that, somehow, this became a discussion of mathematics? I am, obviously, a hard-core experimentalist ;)
- branweb 8y agoAs I understand it, the ever-increasing interior volume of a black hole is deduced from the equations that support general relativity theory, which itself is supported by experimental evidence, so I think that's how it differs.
- jostmey 8y agoThe scientific process requires experimental observation and is the gold-standard for determining truth. But the scientific process has limits and does not work on every problem. It is important to understand that not all research uses the scientific method--a lot of research does not. I think that's okay provided the authors do not try to dress up their research to make it seem like it is science when it is not.
- ordu 8y ago
- sriku 8y agoWe must be living inside a black hole.
- quickthrower2 8y agoHelp I'm trapped inside a universe factory!
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- cobbzilla 8y agoArmchair theoretical physics philosophizing— if complexity (~spacetime) inside the black hole is growing at the fastest rate possible, where does all this stuff go? It doesn’t stay within the black hole, instead it fuels dark energy expansion throughout the universe, through some unknown process akin to how oceanic subduction of tectonic plates recycles continental land through mountain-building and volcanism. There is some mysterious “mantle” of the universe where all this space gets tumbled and transformed into dark energy expansion. Possible? Or crackpot theory?
- darckPlanck 8y agoMore likely that there’s just A LOT of room at Planck scales, once you override the strong and weak nuclear forces, and the classic understanding of subatomic equilibrium that permits electrons to grant atomic nuclei their usual elbow room. Consider our traditional model for the atom, according to quantum electro/chromo-dynamics. Now take all that extra space provided, and fill it to the brim with squished, crushed star detritus. It’s on the order of pinheads to football stadiums. What if you filled up a cubic football field with pinheads snipped off the top of a pin? Now, not just the field, but the whole stadium, including the cheap seats. Fill all the seats with pure atomic nuclei the size of a head of a pin, and nothing else. Take a single helium atom, and use that normal volume as a pre-defined knapsack to stuff more matter into. Now take the mass of as many helium atoms as you can get your hands on, and fill up the volume of that first helium atom with the mass of its peers, until every last planck length is retaining its full quantity of potential mass. Furthermore, I’m thinking it’s likely that black holes are so extreme that you get a runaway crush that overrides the normal volume of all the usual protons, electrons and neutrons, to get degenerate quark soup. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Degenerate_matter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Degenerate_matter
- cobbzilla 8y agoI’m not talking about the matter within the black hole, but the spacetime itself that is constantly “flowing” into the hole and getting stretched infinitely towards the singularity. What if, before reaching the singularity, which is perhaps not possible, the spacetime is “shredded” into Planck-scale entities, which populate an invisible “backplane” that coexists with the visible universe (outside of black holes). the energy of this backplane somehow “pushes” dark energy to expand space everywhere in the universe.
- ineedasername 8y agoI wonder if the authors here are just making an obscure Dr. Who "bigger on the inside" reference. Did they claim the exterior of the black hole, were it visible, would resembles a blue box?
- sroussey 8y agoThat’s pretty funny! I think black holes convert matter to dark matter that leaks across the universe in a different dimension. But my proof was a dream...