3 ms·
Their most important point stems from the name: "Autopilot". That right there begins the host of issues that arose from how Tesla marketed their features in a w
by ineedasername 8y ago
Their most important point stems from the name: "Autopilot". That right there begins the host of issues that arose from how Tesla marketed their features in a way that oversold them. And I am genuinely impressed by what Tesla has accomplished with their system, it's just that it's safe use-cases are much, much narrower a true "autopilot"
I wonder if there is even a safe "in between" phase between normal driving and truly, fully self-driving vehicles. Or will many people put too much trust in the tech to make it a safer alternative until it's much more mature. Think of airplane pilots, where "autopilot" is also not really a fully self-flying/landing/takeoff system: they have tons of specialized training to hammer home the limitations and work safely within the system. There's even a body of research literature on the topic of when too much automation makes pilots too complacent, and decades of engineering with that problem in mind.
It all just makes me think that Waymo may have it right in not targeting any type of transitional state between traditional and full automation.
- labcomputer 8y agoTo be fair, the Tesla Autopilot functions at a higher than an aviation autopilot. In aviation, an autopilot follows a fixed path and makes no attempt to avoid other aircraft or terrain. There is no such thing as an automated takeoff. Automated landings, in practice, require the pilot to hand-fly the last part of the approach (except at a fleetingly small number of airports with cat IIIc approaches, where a ground navaid, not GPS, provides a high precision signal to guide the autopilot). State of the art automation of aircraft speed consists of the pilot dialing a different speed to the autothrottle, which is effectively a traditional, non-adaptive cruise control.
- leetcrew 8y ago> I wonder if there is even a safe "in between" phase between normal driving and truly, fully self-driving vehicles. Or will many people put too much trust in the tech to make it a safer alternative until it's much more mature. the prevailing opinion on this forum seems to be that these semi-autonomous driver aids are inherently unsafe because the driver inevitably stops paying attention. but are they actually worse that a typical human driving manually? I know we've seen a bunch of high-profile news stories about tesla autopilot malfunctions and inattentive safety drivers, but is there any real data to suggest that these systems are as bad as portrayed?