3 ms·
Designer babies are inevitable. From a sheer evolutionary perspective, the group willing to use a successful design mechanism is going to beat out the one that
by jerf 8y ago
Designer babies are inevitable. From a sheer evolutionary perspective, the group willing to use a successful design mechanism is going to beat out the one that is not over the course of a few generations.
However, the problem here is that we do not currently have the ability to create designer babies. We have a few clumsy tools that resemble the tools we'd actually need to do it, but in much the same way that a butcher's knife resembles a scalpel. It's an improvement over the era where what we had was a jackhammer, but it's still not suitable for the task. Any attempt to get serious about human germ-line editing with the current toolset isn't going to work. That means, there is very little likelihood of successful, happy outcomes, and a lot of room for unhappy, dangerous, or deadly outcomes.
Before people seriously start trying this, we need to tip that balance to a point where it's at least interesting to discuss. An ethical discussion would have to revolve around costs and benefits, and it's a really easy discussion when it's basically all costs and no benefits. We don't need to invoke any particular philosophy or argue about utilitarianism or the virtues of deontology or what we should be deontological about in that scenario.
So while I don't have a complete answer, one step to the "risk reduction" you ask for is that we still need better tooling so we're not trying to do the equivalent of performing brain surgery with a butcher's knife, before there's even anything all that interesting to discuss. We should have those discussions sooner rather than later, but as the article alludes to, "we" collectively actually have. (The fact we have no ability to enforce that discussion is a problem of some sort, though.)
At least human germ-line experimentation isn't infectious, though.
- maxerickson 8y agoAt least until someone decides to use a gene drive to do it.
- jerf 8y agoAssuming you're referring to my comment about it not being infectious, gene drives (based on my quick reading about them :) ) are still not what I'd call infectious. But they can get you into a rather nasty long-term scenario where in order to produce a viable baby, the only option is to continue to use gene engineering techniques because all "natural" conceptions will be non-viable because of previous edits and gene drives and such. I've seen some variants of this idea in "the literature" (i.e., science fiction), but perhaps nothing quite as stark as that. Most of "the literature" tends to assume that even in a heavily gene-gineered world, if you just stop engineering, something viable will still survive.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> From a sheer evolutionary perspective, the group willing to use a successful design mechanism is going to beat out the one that is not over the course of a few generations. Not if the latter is willing and able to summarily exterminate the former in the first generation (or earlier, when they are still developing the tools.)
- jerf 8y agoPossible, but with the current geopolitical line up, general attitude towards ethics by various cultures, and so on, the people willing to exterminate others for such reasons and the people who are willing to heavily use "designer baby" tech appear to generally be the same people, so it didn't seem worth mentioning as a possible outcome.