4 ms·
Great point about core frequency being important for per-core licensing. I wonder if any software with per-core licensing has tried to take a possibly 'fairer'
by GordonS 8y ago
Great point about core frequency being important for per-core licensing.
I wonder if any software with per-core licensing has tried to take a possibly 'fairer' approach, for example by summing the frequency of all cores? E.g. 4x cores at 2GHz is 8GHz?
It's not that straightforward a comparison, I know, just wondering if anyone has tried something different here.
- tyingq 8y agoOracle tried that. It was called "Universal Power Unit" pricing. http://houseofbrick.com/oracle-universal-power-unit-licensing/ http://houseofbrick.com/oracle-universal-power-unit-licensin...
- waterhouse 8y agoInteresting. Why did they get rid of it? "Moore’s law could quickly make this type of licensing financially unattractive to the licensees. At the rate in which compute performance increases, the cost of a UPU license doubles about every two years. The industry quickly caught on to this and called Oracle out, which is why the UPU licensing model was very short lived." Well, clock speeds are no longer changing very much, so today I don't think there would be that much difference between "price = cores * speed" and "price = cores", so I suspect UPUs would be fine. Currently, "price = cores" gives this weird market distortion where there's an incentive to get individually-fast, disproportionately-expensive cores to run software that might well be embarrassingly parallel. Perhaps it functions as price discrimination for those willing to put in the effort to customize systems like that. Eh, who knows.
- tyingq 8y agoThese days, there are more viable alternatives to Oracle than there were back then. UPU was complex to administer, and had the primary purpose of extracting more money from customers. I suspect Oracle doesn't want to give customers a reason to start looking for alternatives.
- ams6110 8y agoI'm not sure there are really viable alternatives. If all you need is a big CRUD database, sure there are alternatives, but there always were. Anyone buying Oracle for that was throwing money away. If your enterprise is more fully committed to the Oracle platform, or if you need a support model where you can open a ticket had have people working on it 24x7, possibly on-site, until it's resolved, then no, you can't just drop in PostGres or EnterpriseDB.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Retric 8y agoTeradata a competitor at the high end and Microsoft SQL server is an example at the low customers still want significant support. The enterprise market is not competitive the way gas stations are, but major vendors do compete. In many ways Oracle is the low end of these solutions, but few companies actually need giant databases with thousands of drives.
- justinclift 8y agoNit-pick, it's "Postgres" not "PostGres". :)
- gameswithgo 8y agoWhatever metric you use people will game it. Sum of all frequency and you might see AVX-512 being used a lot or something
- dhd415 8y agoSQL Server switched from CPU-based licensing to core-based licensing as of their 2012 version and they included a "core factor" that reduced licensing costs if you were running on AMD cores to 75% of the cost for Intel cores to account for AMD's then-lower per-core performance. http://download.microsoft.com/download/7/3/c/73cad4e0-d0b5-4be5-ab49-d5b886a5ae00/sql_server_2012_licensing_reference_guide.pdf http://download.microsoft.com/download/7/3/c/73cad4e0-d0b5-4...
- polskibus 8y agoAre you sure that lower core factor applies to EPYC ? The document http://download.microsoft.com/download/4/4/5/445627B4-9AB0-4AED-BCCD-C7AC5ADAF6B2/CoreFactorTable_4_1_2014.pdf http://download.microsoft.com/download/4/4/5/445627B4-9AB0-4... mentions only old Opterons.
- dhd415 8y agoThat applied only to certain AMD CPUs that were available in 2012. It's just an example in which there was some effort to take a "fairer" approach to per-core licensing. It's especially notable since the EPYC line is evidence of the great strides that AMD has made since then when MS just gave you a blanket discount for running SQL Server on AMD cores.
- snuxoll 8y agoIBM does this with their PVU model, everyone HATES it because it's a logistical nightmare to deal with (except IBM, of course).
- lostmyoldone 8y agoOT, but isn't the entire "per core" licensing scheme completely absurd for many products? Since we know that in any significant system the effects of latencies in various cache hierarchies, buses, networks, storage, and cross process synchronization makes enormous difference in performance it's easy to see the CPU performance alone is not really a good predictor of system performance. Thus, with a price calculated per CPU core the solution space narrows significantly, and experience tells us that solutions where per core licensing is involved tend to include expensive, hard to support networking and storage hardware which few would buy if not per core licensing had taken that option away. If you want to charge per unit of work, then figure out how to do just that, and don't charge for what is effectively a theoretical peak unit of load?