4 ms·
If the problem is that some people don't have a checking account, wouldn't it better to provide them with a cheap/free checking account? Even if all local shop
by mcv 8y ago
If the problem is that some people don't have a checking account, wouldn't it better to provide them with a cheap/free checking account?
Even if all local shops accept cash, there's still tons of stuff you can't do without a checking account.
On the topic of cash-free living: I only use cash for 3 things these days: to buy cheese, to pay my cleaning lady, and for my son's weekly allowance. Even the babysitters accept online payment these days.
- chrisseaton 8y ago> wouldn't it better to provide them with a cheap/free checking account? I don't know about everywhere in the world, but aren't most 'checking' (most people don't use checks any more) or current accounts already free? They make money off investing your deposit. How much are people paying for their current accounts?
- lsc 8y agoIn the USA, most checking accounts are "free" as in "Free if you jump through hoops" - I mean, often they are hoops that are trivial for those of us who have a good job, like "free if you have direct deposit" I mean, remember that if banks are making money off investing your deposit, they don't have much interest in maintaining accounts for people who don't have much money to invest. I know at times when I didn't have direct deposit (corp to corp contractor, before I figured out how to setup all the requisite infrastructure on my end) I usually ended up paying like $10 a month or more for my personal checking. Every time I went in the bank, the teller would have some different wacky scheme for getting me free checking, usually involving transferring money between my accounts every month... but it was a lot more work keeping up with how to get the free checking (the requirements for people without direct deposit kept changing) and $10/month was cheaper than the time to figure it out. But, I mean my point is that I think checking is not free if you don't have a decent job. add to that the money they charge you if you aren't organized enough to make sure there is enough money in the account to cover the fee, and yeah, I can totally see how poor people wouldn't have a checking account.
- amaccuish 8y agoAhh, here in the UK you have to ask for a cheque book. And all the big banks have free basic current accounts. I have never paid for my accounts e.g.
- mcv 8y agoI believe I pay a couple of bucks a year for a bank pass that lets me pay or use ATMs everywhere in the world. I don't know if it would be cheaper or free if I got a more limited pass. Most Dutch bank accounts do cost a bit, as far as I know. I remember when this was first introduced in the late 1980s, and I immediately switched banks then. But by now the amounts is negligible, and the convenience of modern banking easily worth it.
- privateSFacct 8y ago1) What is more secure - Venmo behind face ID on an apple phone or a checking account that literally anyone who has the numbers (which you give when you write a check) can take money out of, either by creating a versa check or doing an ACH debit so all your money disappears? You are a poor person - are you in a good position to see dispute resolution through? 2) Garnishment orders - can the state or other collectors garnish the checking account - so all your money disappears? 3) Will the bank allow the account to go negative, charging major fees, then blacklisting you with checksystems? 4) How controllable is saving money in these accounts? Some folks "save" money by not cashing their checks, then going to a check cashing place when they need the money. Is it possible that a few % of population have medical debt, tax debt or other support orders that make using a normal checking account difficult? Past experience with fraud or being ripped off in a checking account?
- RhysU 8y ago> What is more secure - Venmo behind face ID on an apple phone... Anything broadcasting transactions, by default, with no way to turn off egregious abuses strikes me as a personal security risk. See https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.wsj.com/amp/articles/whats-wrong-with-your-venmo-account-and-how-to-fix-it-1543932128 https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.wsj.com/amp/articles/whats-...
- mcv 8y ago1) Why would you allow other people to take money out of your account? Modern checking accounts require two-factor authentication. (And who even uses checks these days?) 2) Not without a court order I would hope. 3) Depends on what you choose and what the bank will allow. It's safer not to. 4) I'm still puzzled over the relevance of checks. I admit, every time I discuss such financial issues with Americans, I keep being surprised by how medieval American banking still is. Isn't there a market for modern banks over there?
- ilovetux 8y agoWhy do you need cash for buying cheese specifically?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mcv 8y agoExcellent question! I wondered if anyone would pick up on that. It appears the owner of my favourite cheese shop is a bit of a Luddite. Or at least, he refuses to get a pin transaction machine, and only accepts cash payment. No idea why. Might be ideological in some way.