3 ms·
Edit: substantive counter-arguments would be highly appreciated I think the biggest problem with your argument is its lack of originality. Every labor-saving
by CamperBob2 8y ago
Edit: substantive counter-arguments would be highly appreciated
I think the biggest problem with your argument is its lack of originality. Every labor-saving innovation in history has been greeted with "This is a death sentence for humanity" or equivalent sentiments, and the naysayers have never once been correct. You need to flesh out your argument by explaining exactly how It's Different This Time.
Your purpose as a human being is not to do a machine's job poorly. Think more of yourself and your fellow humans.
- nuguy 8y agoThe lack of critical thought is entirely on your side of the court. Automation has not yet lead to negative things, therefore it never will? Once a job or task is automated, it can never be done by humans again. This is because within any market, the most competitive entity propagates and the others do not. The less competitive entities are starved of resources and stop existing. As AI approaches sentience, it will become the most competitive entity in more and more cases. When AI becomes comparable to humans, it will displace humans in every instance unless there is a conscious effort to subvert the market economy model and intentionally use less competitive options, otherwise known as abstaining from AI. However, some entities don’t care about a consensus to abstain and will use AI anyway. A country for example will always win against its adversaries if it uses AI. At the end of the day, AI will ratchet forward uncontrollably and the only entities left standing will be those who use AI. This is an inescapable and inherit characteristic of AI. Most AI experts concede to this, but wave their hands and say it’s a long way off. The only way for humanity to continue is for AI to be banished. And by the way, this is all assuming that AI never maliciously targets human life on its own or otherwise for any reason whatsoever.
- CamperBob2 8y agoThe lack of critical thought is entirely on your side of the court. (Shrug) At least I have historical precedent on my side, so I don't have to fall back on a list of bare-assertion fallacies.
- nuguy 8y agoA bare-assertion fallacy is a “fallacy that makes no attempt to use logic in order to justify its conclusion.” Did you accidentally not read the whole paragraph of logic that I wrote in my comment? It’s right there dude. Pick one of the links in the chain of my logic to scrutinize. That’s how rational debate works. Maybe you disagree that the most competitive entity always propagates in a free market? Maybe you disagree that the world and everything in it is a kind of free market? Maybe you disagree that machines can recreate any aspect of the human mind? I literally just don’t understand where I’ve gone wrong. Please point out where I’ve gone wrong in this.