6 ms·
This guy doesn't know what AMP does. AMP is a subset of HTML that can be validated safe to prerender. That means instant page loads for the user, not merely fas
by lern_too_spel 8y ago
This guy doesn't know what AMP does. AMP is a subset of HTML that can be validated safe to prerender. That means instant page loads for the user, not merely fast.
- smadge 8y agoWhat do you mean by “safe to prerender?”
- lern_too_spel 8y agoUser isn't deanonymized to the publisher, publisher analytics and ads don't register page views, page can be trivially transformed to lazy load below the fold, etc.
- tyingq 8y agoThe outside bits of a Trojan horse are attractive for a reason.
- lern_too_spel 8y agoIt is the only available solution to a real problem. If you have a better solution, by all means, be a hero. Meanwhile, the rest of the search and content aggregation industry has gone with AMP, which works today.
- untog 8y ago> the rest of the search and content aggregation industry has gone with AMP Because Google effectively gave them no choice.
- lern_too_spel 8y ago> Because Google effectively gave them no choice. I'm talking about link aggregators and search engines, not publishers. They could have come up with another solution, but they decided to use AMP, which provides the same benefits to them as it provides to Google.
- saagarjha 8y ago> It is the only available solution to a real problem. Don't shove JavaScript and random bloat into your website? That's what I do.
- lern_too_spel 8y agoThat doesn't result in instant, not merely fast, page loads. That's the same mistake the author made, as I pointed out in the GGGP post.
- saagarjha 8y agoCalling AMP pages "instant" loads is disingenuous because Google preloads them before they are opened. Google is free to do this for my website too, but they don't.
- lern_too_spel 8y ago> Google is free to do this for my website too, but they don't. As my GGGGGP post said, that is the entire point of AMP. It can be validated safe to preload, which is not possible for HTML pages in general. So no, Google, Bing, Pinterest, Baidu, LinkedIn, and other sites that preload AMP pages are not free to do this for your website unless it is written in AMP.
- saagarjha 8y ago> It can be validated safe to preload, which is not possible for HTML pages in general. What does this even mean? My browser already preloads websites in the background, AMP or not. So assuming I don't go through Google, you could call going to my website via the address bar "instant" as well.
- lern_too_spel 8y agoCopying my cousin commemt: > User isn't deanonymized to the publisher, publisher analytics and ads don't register page views, page can be trivially transformed to lazy load below the fold, etc. This is all explained in the AMP documentation itself. There was even an article about it on HN not too long ago (https://medium.com/@pbakaus/why-amp-caches-exist-cd7938da2456 https://medium.com/@pbakaus/why-amp-caches-exist-cd7938da245...). People like the author who criticize AMP without knowing what problem it solves are willfully ignorant. This all works on the open web without signing an agreement with the traffic source, unlike Facebook's and Apple's proprietary instant article solutions. That's why it has been adopted by so many other search engines and link aggregators.
- dmitriid 8y agoThey are not ”instant”. When you visit Google search, Google preloads AMP (and doesn’t preload anything else). The only readon AMP id fast is because Google has search monopoly and preloads its own non-standard things ahead of time, effectively penalising everyone else.
- lern_too_spel 8y agoReread GP post. AMP is a subset of HTML that can be validated to be safe to preload. That's why Google and others preload it.
- dmitriid 8y agoIt's a subset of HTML that Google has full control over and whose only purpose is to lock publishers into a model that benefits Google, and Google alone. BTW. This "subset" is invalid HTML. Just so you know.
- lern_too_spel 8y agoIf it benefits Google and Google alone, why do Microsoft, Pinterest, Twitter, LinkedIn, WordPress, Baidu, and Weibo (among others) also prerender AMP pages? The reality is that every link aggregator and search engine wants instant results, and your conspiracy theory falls apart as soon as you understand that. What part of AMP is invalid HTML? It is a competitor to Facebook instant articles and Apple News that works on the open web.
- dmitriid 8y ago> If it benefits Google and Google alone, why do Because publishers jumped on bandwagon and started deploying AMP pages en masse. Just because someone else besides Google implemented AMP pages doesn't mean that their intent and purpose is something else than what I wrote. > What part of AMP is invalid HTML? <html :lightning emoji:> // is invalid // script attributes are invalid <script async custom-element="amp-carousel" src="https://cdn.ampproject.org/v0/amp-carousel-0.1.js"> <style amp-boilerplate> I once found more, I couldn't be bothered again.