4 ms·
What gives you the impression a significant number of Americans support direct democracy?
by pvg 8y ago
What gives you the impression a significant number of Americans support direct democracy?
- redthrowaway 8y agoThe fact that California is nearly ungovernable due to it?
- pvg 8y agoWhether that's a fact or not, it doesn't seem to have much to do with whether lots of Americans support direct democracy. The California process itself is well over a century old.
- mars4rp 8y agocan you elaborate, please?
- dragonwriter 8y agoCalifornia is perfectly governable. There used to be a perennial budgeting problem due to a supermajority requirement which, like all of the CA Constitution, was directly adopted, but that was solved by the people withdrawing the requirement.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> What gives you the impression a significant number of Americans support direct democracy? The fact that most states have at least some degree of it, and the people don't use it to abolish itself in favor of purely representative democracy.
- pvg 8y agoThese all tend to be from the Progressive Era. By the same argument, we can conclude most Americans are deeply paranoid about the dangers of direct democracy because the founders of the US were. Neither is terribly convincing.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> These all tend to be from the Progressive Era. And they all contain the mechanisms by which, if people didn't like them, they could be undone. > By the same argument, we can conclude most Americans are deeply paranoid about the dangers of direct democracy because the founders of the US were. No, you can't, because to be “by the same argument”, you'd have to. show that, in a case where it was procedurally possible for the people directly to institute or remove direct democracy, they generally choose to avoid it entirely. Which is exactly the opposite of reality.
- pvg 8y agoI don't because I'm not asking what is procedurally possible. I'm asking what is the evidence that right now, piles and piles of Americans support direct democracy. There are zillions of aspects of government that exist and that alone (or the fact that they haven't been reformed away) doesn't indicate widespread support or non-support of them. This is about as weak an indication as the historical arguments which tell you something about how some Americans felt at the time.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> I'm asking what is the evidence that right now, piles and piles of Americans support direct democracy. And the evidence is that they have it and choose to keep it, since its existence allows them to remove or further limit it should they wish to.
- remarkEon 8y agoThe United States has been on a long bend toward more direct democracy because it’s self reinforcing. How would you “remove” direct democracy? Put it to a “vote of the people”? Okay. Now you have to convince them that they should give up their “power” to directly inform their governance. Who is going to vote for this? As more and more people become accustomed to voting on more and more issues that were previously the exclusive purview of their elected representatives, of course they’re going to want more of that same structure. You get to a point where you’re putting enormously complex issues to a vote, which is just kind of mind boggling to me. Not sure if we’re agreeing or disagreeing, but to state my position explicitly direct democracy is the final form of decline for civil republican government. After that you’re headed for authoritarianism, be it left or right. “Should they wish to” is frankly wishful thinking.
- mc32 8y agoBallot measures, initiatives are an example of this tendency.