2 ms·
It's based on a delusion of centralized control. It does not require maliciousness, simple-minded benevolence leads to the same thing. There's a problem that ex
by mindslight 8y ago
It's based on a delusion of centralized control. It does not require maliciousness, simple-minded benevolence leads to the same thing. There's a problem that exists, and they need to solve it, so more control can only help - or so the thinking goes.
Plus, a law like this only really sets the stage for future actions. If it turns out those type of actions are unnecessary or have detrimental effects, the capability can be restrained in the future! And it is true that the egregious totalitarian scenarios we're thinking of won't be done immediately. The frog will just slowly boil over time as the invasive behavior is normalized and gradually used for more and more routine policing.
It takes a very principled stance to assert that the unenumerable harm such laws do to the future outweighs the immediate threat of the day. Which is why totalitarian laws such at this gain more ground after violent media spectacles.