5 ms·
This is cool. I think it will be helpful to have more sports that don’t have gender or sex separated categories and finding activities where there aren’t biolog
by prepend 8y ago
This is cool. I think it will be helpful to have more sports that don’t have gender or sex separated categories and finding activities where there aren’t biological advantages is important.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoWhy? Virtually all sports (including this one - see the comment from travisoneill1) have gender-related biological differences one way or the other. Why try to minimize this fact?
- warent 8y agoIt has nothing to do with minimizing anything. Sometimes it's just cool to see men and women compete at things they can be equals at, e.g. business, right? So, acknowledging that men and women have biological differences, I'd still like to see more things we can equally compete in, just for the entertainment/competitive spirit if nothing else. EDIT: Although gp did say it would be "helpful." So, yeah, I don't know what they meant by that, but this is my take on it anyhow.
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoA problem with this is that 'equal' tends to equate to fields where measuring performance is not really possible in an objective fashion. E.g. - how would you measure business performance? Is Bill Gates a Bobby Fischer of business, or is he a smart guy who had a great run of right place/right time? In reality there's a good reason that most competitive fields are not equal by any means. In many fields there are even racial/ethnic divides where physiological differences tend to be much smaller than those between sexes. It's because while any world class competitor (in anything) might be many orders of magnitude more capable than a layperson, in general the differences between the individuals at the top is very small. Because of this even the slightest difference is something that can radically shift the balance. As an example consider the LZR swimsuit [1] by Speedo. In the Beijing Olympics 23 of 25 world records broken were done by swimmers wearing an LZR suit. It had such a huge impact on swimming that the suit is now banned, along with possible derivatives of it. You might expect it's some amazing insta-swimmer, but it's just a regular swimsuit that's nicely engineered resulting in about a quarter less drag than their previous swimsuit. But these changes alone enabled swimmers to shave an average of about 2% off their lap times, which was way more than enough to just destroy just about all previous records. The ratios of your hips, legs, weight distributions, etc all are vastly different between men and women. And different, though less so, between races. Even consider all the physical differences implied by simply having breasts. Occasionally you'll find a genetic outlier, but in cases where the normal distribution tends to overlap strongly with the ideal performance distribution you're going to get a landslide of results. For instance Kenya makes up a tiny chunk of the world's population, but dominates pretty much all marathon running competitions. Even more interesting is it's not just Kenyans, but a tiny ethnic minority within Kenya that's doing this dominating. Some 0.06% of the world's population ends up dominating marathon racing. Most tellingly, Kenya was basically a nonplayer in these events until cultural changes in the 80s started bringing Kenya (and other East African nations) up to the standards of the west in terms of nutrition and general technology. There was a great article on this all a while back [2]. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LZR_Racer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LZR_Racer [2] - https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2012/04/why-kenyans-make-such-great-runners-a-story-of-genes-and-cultures/256015/ https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2012/04/wh...
- scarejunba 8y agoIf the records stand, then it means it’s going to be real damn hard for anyone to beat them without the same suit, right? Interesting. Maybe they’ll stand forever.
- Udik 8y ago> cool to see men and women compete at things they can be equals at, e.g. business, right? Funny that you are using the business example just assuming that they must be equal. There is no data that I know of to support this.
- warent 8y agoYou can reason through it with existing evidence: 1. It can be reasonably agreed that (as of 2018) becoming a billionaire with a successful (profitable; influential) business empire is the peak of business success. 2. Women encounter more prejudice/sexism in business than men. 3. Becoming a self-made billionaire is more challenging as a female than a male. 4. There are both male and female self-made billionaires. The conclusion is that women can be at least as competent as men in business.
- Udik 8y agoYour conclusion sets a precise numerical (in)equality: Female competence >= Male competence. Your data is entirely non existent and/ or handwavy. Let's assume that 1) is a good metric. Then 2) needs to be argued for and quantified. 3) follows from the (missing) quantification of 2, plus some other parameter for its impact. 4) Also needs to be numerically quantified: what's the ratio between male and female billionaires? So we're back at square one: you believe your parameters to be whatever they need to be to make your conclusion true. That doesn't prove much, does it?
- belorn 8y agoOne large argument is that there is larger biological differences than gender-related ones, and we usually do not split the player base based on the biggest biological differences. There is some small exception for sports which historically has a close connection to betting (horse racing and boxing), but then we have sports like baseball which is not separated based on height. We could introduce a general rule where if a biological trait has above a statistical threshold of being beneficial, then the sport should split based on that trait. I would love see a statistician explore that and paint us a picture of how the most popular sports would look like.
- Traubenfuchs 8y agoSome people are very upset about biological reality subverting the notion that there is no difference between men and women.
- dvfjsdhgfv 8y ago> gender-related biological differences I think in this particular case it's OK to write "sex differences".
- prepend 8y agoLet me clarify and expand. I don’t want to minimize existing sports. They are great and people love them dearly. I think that new sports that don’t have biological biases based on sex or gender will be interesting mainly because the competitor base is doubled and the fan base is larger. So having more potential competitors should lead to better contests and having different events merged into a single means more viewers per events. For example, esports not having gender categories is a positive. Or this type of endurance running is cool. Although I don’t expect there are too many viewers for a 67 hour event, having an event that allows people regardless of sex means more events possible.
- baddox 8y agoIt’s hard to imagine many competitive events where biological advantages wouldn’t be important.
- prepend 8y agoI can’t think of too many. Maybe target shooting. Or darts. It’s now a fun data analysis project to look for Olympic sports with continuous, ratio dats that results in ranking where men and women are similar. And start there.
- baddox 8y agoI wasn’t thinking about only biological differences between men and women, but that’s a prominent dichotomy to look at. I think that one big problem with trying to find a competitive event where men and women don’t seem to have biological differences in performance is that, at least according to my impression of the United States, it’s more socially acceptable for boys to obsess over and dedicate a lot of time toward a very specific sport/competition/hobby/interest. I suspect that regardless of any purely biological differences, this cultural tendency will tend to favor males in most competitive events that are fairly well-known and have well-established rules.
- ordu 8y agoIf women can do better with ultrarunning, than it is not an example of an activity where biological advantages are not important. Quite contrary.
- flukus 8y agoHow important do you consider younger girls having female role models in sports and having professional female athletes? Non-segregated sports that don't rely on physical strength, speed, etc still tend to be almost exclusively men in the extreme corner of the bell curve that professional athletes occupy, so getting rid of gender segregation would result in fewer professional women in sports.
- ykevinator 8y agoI think it creates false hope. I'd much rather see role models who present realistic goals like teachers and scientists. Sports and entertainment dangle low work high income fantasies.
- tertius 8y agoFor me personally, athletic achievement signals hard work. Which is quite useful. Now I'm sure not everyone thinks that way. Certainly kids who actually engage in sport will realize this.
- prepend 8y agoI don’t have a good answer to how important sex and gender is for young people in choosing role models. My biggest role models in sport don’t share a gender, nationality, or race with me. It’s hard to say how I would have acted if they had more in common with me. Interesting. Maybe the question, if you think gender is really important for role modeling, is what other physical characteristics would be useful to segregate sports by. I think segregating by sex is valuable when there are sex biases (I don’t know of many gender biases in sports), but segregating to increase participation would be something to think about.