3 ms·
> Any worse than RCP 8.5 and the earth enters a runaway greenhouse. At that point the atmosphere turns into Venus, and life on Earth really would be over. I do
by hn_throwaway_99 8y ago
> Any worse than RCP 8.5 and the earth enters a runaway greenhouse. At that point the atmosphere turns into Venus, and life on Earth really would be over.
I don't see how that would be possible (and at least the scientists at the ICPP don't believe it would be possible either, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Runaway_greenhouse_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Runaway_greenhouse_effect).
At the end of the day, it is believed that all or almost all of the oil, coal and natural gas we use comes from biogenic sources, meaning it used to be in the atmosphere at some point in the past. We're basically taking what was once in the air, then stored underground, and putting it back out in the air again. Much (if not most?) of Earth's history has been without any ice caps, so it's not like this state will lead to a Venus-like Earth.
Of course, a 4-8 degree hotter Earth without ice caps still means the deaths of billions of people, so I'm not saying it's not a total disaster, but I just don't see how a runaway greenhouse effect is possible just from burning fossil fuels.
- usaar333 8y agoThe sun was dimmer in the past, so similar co2 levels as then mean more warning. https://www.skepticalscience.com/co2-higher-in-past.htm https://www.skepticalscience.com/co2-higher-in-past.htm
- acqq 8y ago> Much (if not most?) of Earth's history has been without any ice caps, so it's not like this state will lead to a Venus-like Earth. But much of Earth's history has been without land plants too. They appeared only after 90% of Earth history already passed: only 450 million years ago. Earth exists for 4.5 billion years. (Also to compare, we started burning gasoline after 99.999997% of the Earth history already passed, and managed to burn during that small time period the half of all easily reachable oil in the Earth crust! For which the Earth needed... effectively all 4.5 billion years to manage to accumulate there. The size of what we did is mind-boggling on so many levels. Ah, yes, also during much of the Earth history there was effectively no oxygen in the atmosphere: it appeared in "breathable" quantities only after 77% of the current Earth's age already passed, if the Earth would be a 90-year-old lady: the oxygen exists only since she was 70, plants since she's 81, and we burned the half of easily reachable oil in only the last 1 minute 34 seconds)
- hwillis 8y ago> I don't see how that would be possible (and at least the scientists at the ICPP don't believe it would be possible either That's down to the fact that emitting more than 8.5 RCP requires some insane choices. Like, as you say, burning pretty much everything. A low-end runaway greenhouse can happen with 12 W/m^2 forcing[1], which would mean temperature changes ~20 C compared to 4-8, and multiple times more CO2. > At the end of the day, it is believed that all or almost all of the oil, coal and natural gas we use comes from biogenic sources, meaning it used to be in the atmosphere at some point in the past. That is a very, very silly way to look at it. The total weight of carbon in the air is 870 gigatons. There are 1000 gigatons in ocean life, 2000 gigatons in the terrestrial biosphere, and 4000 gigatons in fossil fuel reserves. The fact that it was in the atmosphere at one point is irrelevant; I've drunk thousands of gallons of water in my lifetime. If you were to return those to my body all at once, I would explode. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Runaway_climate_change https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Runaway_climate_change