4 ms·
most of the critics seem to miss the point that Facebook grew really fast Growth rate is not an excuse for the evils that have been enabled by Facebook. It is
by reaperducer 8y ago
most of the critics seem to miss the point that Facebook grew really fast
Growth rate is not an excuse for the evils that have been enabled by Facebook. It is perfectly within Facebook's power to slow its growth to a rate it can actually manage.
And don't play the "shareholder" card. Zuck is the majority shareholder, and can do whatever he wants with the company, including making it not be evil.
Is there another app that, indeed, connects the world?
E-mail. The PSTN. Text messages. Actual mail.
WhatsApp, YouTube, and probably several hundred others that I don't know about because I'm not much of an SMS person.
- minitel 8y ago> Growth rate is not an excuse for the evils that have been enabled by Facebook. This sort of over the top moral grandstanding is, ironically, the sort of "evil" that many have attributed to Social Media. Yet it looks to me like the same sort of pearl clutching that soccer moms were doing about Satanism during the 1980's (for instance).
- yourbandsucks 8y agoI quit facebook in 2010, so don't take me for any sort of fanboy, but what 'evils' were 'enabled', specifically? It looks like most of the election stuff was normal humans reposting things of their own volition. Yeah, there were lots of lies in it, some of it was actual fake newspapers being run out of Macedonia or whatever, but are we making facebook a scapegoat just for being the medium? Before 2016, I never heard anyone saying FB had an obligation to fact-check political speech.. Maybe we, as a society, need to figure out how to handle social media rather than expecting a guy like Zuck to do it for us.
- empath75 8y agoJust a little light genocide: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/15/technology/myanmar-facebook-genocide.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/15/technology/myanmar-facebo...
- yourbandsucks 8y agoI didn't know about that, thanks for the link. Here's my beef, though: People still did that. Facebook isn't your daddy, and Zuckerberg will never be a different person. Facebook isn't the problem. We are.
- ben_w 8y agoIf you know how to manipulate 1% of the population — never knowing who, in advance, just that it’s on average 1% — and you sell that power to the highest bidder, I’d totally argue you’re responsible for whatever the winner does with that power. Especially if you go to great lengths to keep the bidders anonymous, or even merely allow them to make themselves unknown to you because “we can’t scale that”.
- yourbandsucks 8y agoBut it doesn't sound like Facebook sold anything here? Obviously in hindsight some posts should have been censored and accounts banned to prevent violence, but I'm honestly not surprised they failed to.. We're expecting some dweebs in the valley to understand Myanmar social dynamics?
- ben_w 8y ago> We're expecting some dweebs in the valley to understand Myanmar social dynamics? If they do business there? Yes! If they cannot hire people who can understand it for them, that is still a problem. If they merely forget, that is still a problem.
- apersona 8y ago> and you sell that power to the highest bidder You make it sound like FB knew that the accounts that "...posed as fans of pop stars and national heroes" were run by a military operation. > because "we can't scale that" And how would you scale that? I don't think there is any easy solution (or even an "ideal" solution). Not to mention that FB is on now dealing with actual dam military operations by an authoritarian government. How would you defend yourself against that?
- satya71 8y agoPlease look up how Facebook enabled the Rohingya genocide in Myanmar.
- apersona 8y agoEven without Facebook, what's preventing Myanmar's authoritarian government from flooding their own media with propaganda still?
- twothumbsup 8y agoFacebook owns WhatsApp FYI
- baby 8y ago> E-mail. The PSTN. Text messages. Actual mail. Nope. These doesn't. But it's hard to understand if you actually haven't travelled the world. These all miss the "discovery" part of the experience. People also change phone numbers and email all the time, but they keep their facebook account.
- SwellJoe 8y agoThey keep their facebook account, until they don't. Large numbers of people have opted out of facebook in recent years. Just because it's been around for a few years, doesn't mean it is permanent. Nobody is finding me on MySpace to stay in touch (at least not in the last decade...and even then it took me a year to see the message because I hadn't logged in in longer than that), and while facebook has proven to be longer lasting than MySpace, we don't have enough evidence to say they'll be relevant in ten or twenty more years. Also, I've had the same cell phone number for approximately 20 years (and I only changed the number then because I wanted one with an area code in the city I was doing business in...which seems like a quaint requirement today). I am legally allowed to take my number with me when I change carriers. I have no legal right, or technical means, to carry my facebook profile URL with me if I move somewhere else. I hate phones, but if we're talking about longevity of connectivity...phones do alright compared to social networks.
- baby 8y ago> Large numbers of people have opted out of facebook in recent years It is still a minority in my personal experience (which is what matters for me). > Also, I've had the same cell phone number for approximately 20 years I think you're probably a few generations above me, probably none of my friends still have the same phone number, I know I've changed a dozen of times in the last 10 years. It's easy to keep the same cellphone number if you live all your life in the same country, but that's not my life or my friends life.
- gmmeyer 8y agoWhatsApp is owned by Facebook