6 ms·
Why wouldn't Googlers make a union? I think Microsoft had one back in days, but it was microscopic.
by baybal2 8y ago
Why wouldn't Googlers make a union? I think Microsoft had one back in days, but it was microscopic.
- duxup 8y agoAt least in the US, unions tend to cover jobs where there is a lot of manual labor and etc. They tend to heavily emphasize seniority over most anything, and in doing so straight up discourage merit based pay. Many have strict rules about what position is offered to who and when (seniority wins again). They're not very effective / desirable for higher skill jobs IMO where merit and skills change rapidly. Granted that's all very general and I'm sure there are exceptions but unions (I hear they're different elsewhere) in the US are kinda wonky, not very agile, and can become an negative entity in many ways as they serve their own interests.
- ForHackernews 8y agoThis isn't strictly true. Professional athletes in major leagues are unionized, and their jobs are highly specialized and well paid. The Writers Guild of America is another union that represents a non-manual labor profession. You could also consider the American Medical Association as a pseudounion guild that restricts entry into the medical field and keeps wages high.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoAs well as the Screen Actor's Guild. "SAG-AFTRA represents approximately 160,000 actors, announcers, broadcast journalists, dancers, DJs, news writers, news editors, program hosts, puppeteers, recording artists, singers, stunt performers, voiceover artists and other media professionals." https://www.sagaftra.org/home https://www.sagaftra.org/home
- duxup 8y agoMy wife was a part of a union that covered theater workers. Their group medical benefits were "you pay for it and submit each bill individually". It was pretty brutal, they showed no interest in changing it at the time.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- toomuchtodo 8y agoProgress is a function of effort, not time. Default to action, push whenever feasible to fix what is broken.
- duxup 8y agoI find many union's efforts to be lacking generally.
- santoriv 8y agoAs well as the American Federation of Musicians. When I was a freelance orchestral musician I loved the union. There was a huge difference in how you were treated during union vs non-union gigs.
- duxup 8y agoLike I said it was a general statement, but professional athletes are kinda a different animal considering their "laobr" is in high demand and very rare at their skill level. That's a pretty distant comparison. Same goes for doctors where they're not readily replaceable considering training / licensing requirements.
- samfisher83 8y agoPro Athletes are like 1% of the 1%. Even the 12th guy on the roster was like the best player on his college team. I am not sure if everyone in google was the best coder in their college.
- SilasX 8y ago>Like I said it was a general statement, but professional athletes are kinda a different animal considering their "laobr" is in high demand and very rare at their skill level. Er, what? That was the point. You: Unions are mainly effective for low-skill, manual jobs. ForHackernews: But they have them for professional athletes and actors too. You: Irrelevant, they're a whole different animal. Yes, the point all along was that the union model applies to different animals/worker-types.
- Apocryphon 8y agoAlso, they failed to address screenwriters, who have a creative specialist occupation that is vaguely more similar to software engineers.
- SilasX 8y agoInteresting, never thought about that one. And it's also similar in terms of tons of unqualified people trying to get in, and a low barrier to entry (in terms of producing recognizable work)...
- samfisher83 8y agoAMA is great for doctors. You need a license to practice you don't need a license to code. I don't think it wouldn't really apply to programmers.
- mkirklions 8y agoThe AMA is everything that is wrong with American Healthcare. They have enforced the Physician monopoly to the point where its cronyism. There is a reason Physicians make 300k/yr.
- ryandrake 8y agoBut it’s good for the members of the profession, which is the point of its existence. No doubt a similarly structured “programmers’ guild” would be equally good—for programmers.
- stale2002 8y agoIt would only be good for the programmers who kiss the ring and the already priviledged. It will screw over everyone else. I will never ever support an organization that puts up artificial barriers to what is currently a very open work industry. I would join the group just to sabotage it if they tried to keep out bootcampers or people without a CS degree. Anyone should be allowed to program.
- ForHackernews 8y agoIMO, there should professional licensing gated by an exam, similar to the accounting or actuarial professions. Anyone who can pass the exams gets in. But the flip side of being a real profession is you're liable if you store passwords in plaintext.
- llampx 8y agoOn the other hand, they are the reason a doctor or lawyer trained in India can not come to the US and directly start practicing, aside from the Indian lawyer not knowing US law, which they could potentially learn just as they learn java. No negative sentiment implied here. I am an immigrant myself.
- ryanmercer 8y agoAnd federal government employees have a union, the American Federation of Government Employees, the vast majority of which are office workers. Something like 670,000 members.
- xeromal 8y agoYeah, exactly. In a lot of unions in the states, if you have 5 years experience, you make x amount of money regardless of skill. The benefits are usually VERY nice though.
- duxup 8y agoDepends on the union benefits wise. Teaching ... not so much.
- moate 8y agoThere are plenty of truths in your point, but there are TONS of unions that aren't "manual labor" related. The top 3 US unions by membership are Teachers and Public Servant. There's also entertainment unions (All pro sports, SAG, etc). These represent millions of US workers. There are trade offs to collective bargaining, especially if you feel you're at the top of the skill curve among workers (If you're in the 1% of workers, why would your value be helped by bargaining with the other 99%) but the idea is always that in any negotiation of you vs. "the company" the advantage is typically in favor of the company because of the deferred costs across the entire organization. The larger the company gets, the greater this advantage becomes. Yes, there are other companies competing for top talent, and coding is an exceptionally in demand skill (which BTW, many hiring managers still prioritize seniority/experience over true meritocracy) which helps in the short term but since everyone is pushing coding education initiatives, I can't imagine this will be the state of things in the future. Right now, since there's more Senior Dev job openings than people with Senior Dev skills, there may be a slightly more neutral negotiation table. We'll see how that plays out in 10 years. Any time you have a large group of people, there's going to be disagreements about organizational choices or decisions as to how best to allocate resources. If you're unwilling to buy into the group, it's always going to feel like an albatross instead of a benefit. A coders union could be a good thing in the long term. Right now, the sector is still too chaotic, and lots of people are making stupid amount of money. If that starts changing...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tanilama 8y agoIsn't Unions against the idea of contractors? That takes work away from the union workers?
- gwbas1c 8y agoMake sure you understand the difference between a contractor and an employee. Often people who should be employees are classified as contractors. In this case, a union would advocate that contractors are really misclassified employees.
- aerotwelve 8y agoUnions, in general, aren't monolithic. How the average trade union member may feel about contractors within their field would likely depend on the industry they work in. Further, these groups aren't mutually exclusive in some cases. Many contract electricians are unionized, for example.
- darpa_escapee 8y agoNo, contractor and freelancer unions exist.
- gwbas1c 8y agoUnions are for situations where individual workers can not negotiate well. That's why the term "collective bargaining" is often interchangeable. IT workers are typically considered professionals why can negotiate for themselves. The general rule of thumb is how "replaceable" a worker is. Someone like a doctor or a hard to find engineer is considered professional, and thus a union is not needed. Someone who has a lot of handholding on their job, and can easily be replaced by someone else who will train quickly, is what a union is for. Thus, a union might work for the cleaning crew, foodservice crew, and maybe even Waymo testers. It won't work for software engineers, because engineers should be able to negotiate for themselves.
- nrook 8y agoI'm not sure I quite grasp this argument. Google is a popular, high-demand employer, and lots of people want to work there. But Google still found it useful to conspire with other tech companies[1] in order to hold down wages. The reverse should also be true: The sorts of engineers who can get a job at Google are in high demand. But, if they bargained as a group, they could probably get even more money. [1] https://www.reuters.com/article/apple-google-ruling/u-s-judge-approves-415-mln-settlement-in-tech-worker-lawsuit-idUSL1N11908520150903 https://www.reuters.com/article/apple-google-ruling/u-s-judg...
- ryandrake 8y ago> It won't work for software engineers, because engineers should be able to negotiate for themselves. Why? Is there something about software that inherently makes its practitioners shrewd negotiators? Part of what keeps software salaries down is the uncapped supply of talent competing for a small number of jobs. Tough to expect much negotiating power.
- Apocryphon 8y agoNot to mention it flies in the face of many popular “engineers suck at negotiating, let me teach you how to” blog posts on HN: https://hn.algolia.com/?query=negotiation&sort=byPopularity&prefix&page=0&dateRange=all&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?query=negotiation&sort=byPopularity&...
- tomatotomato37 8y agoIt's not a good idea while CS salaries are so exaggerated next to other engineering salaries: the top 10% of earners complaining about working conditions will come off as a bit entitled to the other 90%. Wait for salaries to normalize or maybe concentrate on creating a trade association instead and steering the industry through that
- stale2002 8y agoUhhh, no thanks. I have no desire to increase the amount of people who have control over my working environment and getting in between my employment contracts that I negotiate with potential employers. Having only one entity that can screw up my working conditions (the employer) is much better than having 2 entities that can screw it up (both the employer and the union.) When dealing with a single entity, the relationship is clear. I negotiate with them, and offer my work in exchange for a contract that we both agree on. It would screw up incentives to have a third party who has significant control over my mutually agreed contracts.