3 ms·
Do you have any benchmarks? Gentoo's Portage is also Python, and it always seemed much faster than apt or yum. Sure, you never want to search for something with
by Jach 16y ago
Do you have any benchmarks? Gentoo's Portage is also Python, and it always seemed much faster than apt or yum. Sure, you never want to search for something with it (use eix, which exists for the same reason "locate" exists instead of "find"), but since the bottleneck seems to be more on the speed of the hard drive it doesn't seem like it matters much what language the package manager is in. Plus part of Portage's speed is concurrent downloads as well as allowing concurrent emerges running.
- rwmj 16y agoNo I don't have any benchmarks. After getting into an argument with one of the yum developers some time ago, I did sit down and attempt to benchmark apt vs yum, but it's impossible to do this. Fedora and Debian are completely different distros, so benchmarking two package installs isn't fair -- the package you are installing might be configured completely differently or have more dependencies on one distro than the other, so it's just not a fair test. Nevertheless, yum does feel slower, and anyone who uses both daily like I do would tend to agree. Does Portage do full dependency resolution? That's what kills package managers (see my posting above yours).
- nodata 16y agoI don't see why HN has to switch to feelings all of a sudden, just for this article. Benchmarks are what count. > so it's just not a fair test. There are statistical methods for counteracting that, but I don't see the point. It would be non-impossible to construct a test where you tested the overhead of the package management system.