3 ms·
Cool, and on an individual human level I'm happy for the parents. But at the larger societal level I find such procedures very disturbing. I don't mean to sou
by sandworm101 8y ago
Cool, and on an individual human level I'm happy for the parents. But at the larger societal level I find such procedures very disturbing. I don't mean to sound like a eugenicist, everyone has the right to have kids imho, but the resources spent to create this one kid were immense. There are far easier ways for these parents to have genetic children, a surrogacy being top of the list.
The possibility of men carrying children is scientifically interesting, but again the human race is not struggling for kids. We are a growing population. I'd rather the resources spent on these procedures go towards vaccinations or the basic medical treatments that so many people lack on this planet.
- pc86 8y agoWe have enough scientists to work on multiple things concurrently. There is always something "more worthy" of research/funding/time/facility allocation/manpower than whatever it is you're working on at the moment.
- sandworm101 8y agoResearch is one thing, it advances human knowledge. My issue is with the procedure that comes from the research. I would not support this becoming a therapy, something to be used not to advance knowledge but to cure disease. I'm all for the experiment. I get worried when people talk about this as another answer to infertility, or those who suggest it as a means for men to carry babies. Similarly, I have no issue with some of the so-called "vampire" experiments, blood transfusions between young and old (ie moving blood both ways). Much can be learned through this (liver functions, immune cells etc). But I would very much against such a thing becoming a standard therapy beyond the lab.
- pc86 8y agoThis would be a surprisingly backward and anti-science viewpoint for the general public, let alone HN.
- jschwartzi 8y agoThe human race is not struggling for children, but many individual women certainly are. This is a technology that could help these women achieve something that they desire, and we shouldn't ignore that just because there are other problems to be solved too. Surrogacy is fraught with its own problems. Whomever you choose to be the surrogate has to carry the baby to term for 9 months. And they connect with the child while carrying it. If you ask a friend to do it, it puts a strain on the relationship regardless of whether they agree.
- ravenstine 8y agoI find it troubling in these sense that it's another repetition in the pattern of technology being developed to satisfy innate human desires as opposed to actually bettering the human being. It can be said that such advances can lead to a bettering of the human being, but I have my doubts as to whether even 1% of the effort we are currently putting forth(collectively speaking) will lead to us becoming "better" creatures with a greater understanding of the universe and our place within it. If we're so disinterested in actual betterment, as opposed to taking ourselves apart and reassembling our pieces in novel ways, then we are really no better than bacteria developing new ways to mutate and multiply.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> technology being developed to satisfy innate human desires as opposed to actually bettering the human being Society works better when everyone is allowed, to the maximum extent reasonably possible, to draw this line on their own. The entirety of art, for example, could be categorized as either.
- ravenstine 8y agoAllowed and enabled. If even the brightest of us have to focus so much of their time on finding income, housing, and families, that really doesn't leave much time for them to as accurately draw those lines as they could.
- PhasmaFelis 8y agoYou're right that transplanting a womb from a corpse to a living woman doesn't scale well, for a lot of reasons, but this seems like a big step toward other, more practical womb-replacement treatments in the future.