5 ms·
What's really striking is how user-hostile this conversation is. Forget about whether the user wants to share their data or not - it's all about what Facebook w
by AlexandrB 8y ago
What's really striking is how user-hostile this conversation is. Forget about whether the user wants to share their data or not - it's all about what Facebook wants to do. In this case, that's snuffing competition by denying access, in the case of Cambridge Analytica, it's sharing data for purposes of shady data "research".
- ryanwaggoner 8y agoIf you own a grocery store and there's a guy on the other side of town who is cheaper, the people who come to your store because it's more convenient would love for you to be forced to just give away half your space to your competitor. Doesn't mean it's "user hostile" to refuse to do so.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- oliveshell 8y agoI agree; of course that isn’t. But being forced to give away half your physical retail space is hardly the same thing as just letting them keep using an API that you provide explicitly for such use. Also, more broadly: one would have quite a hard time making the case that Facebook isn’t nakedly, gleefully, and rapaciously user-hostile.
- ryanwaggoner 8y agoI don't agree, but it's probably not worth making the case. Facebook has billions of users. I assume you think that they want to leave, but they "can't", or that they just don't know how hostile Facebook is towards them. I think a lot of people who hate Facebook just have a hard time believing that most people just don't care about the same things you do, or to the same degree. They're still on Facebook and Instagram and Whatsapp because they see the world differently from you.
- traek 8y ago> But being forced to give away half your physical retail space is hardly the same thing as just letting them keep using an API that you provide explicitly for such use. In this case, Facebook was deprecating the API and declined to provide special whitelist access to a competitor.
- kevindqc 8y agoSo they just heard about Vine, and decided to deprecate the API the same day? That doesn't sound right to me. That conversation seems to indicate they just wanted to block them ASAP (same day), nothing to do with deprecation?
- traek 8y ago> So they just heard about Vine, and decided to deprecate the API the same day? No? Where are you getting this read from? The documents clearly show them discussing it from a year prior to shutting down Vine's API access, and planning on announcing it publicly ~6 months prior. I can't find anything from a quick google search on when the API deprecation actually took effect, but assuming the timeline from Exhibit 43 is accurate, Twitter actually had whitelisted access for over 3 months before being shut down.
- Mahn 8y agoThere's nothing that Facebook did here than any other company, in tech or otherwise, wouldn't have done. And for the record, Facebook did not "share data with Cambridge Analytica for shady research purposes". A rogue third party developer created one of those shitty quiz apps for Facebook, and then proceed to get users to signup for it; several million did, which allowed said developer to harvest data thanks to the very permissive APIs that Facebook provided at the time. He then proceeded to sell this data to Cambridge Analytica. Facebook has a responsibility in what happened there, but "Facebook sold data to Cambridge Analytica" is a widly misconstrued story.
- altcognito 8y ago"A rogue third party developer" We are all rogue third party developers, and clearly, the priority, much like most businesses is to make a profit, and the customers/ethics come second. I love the fact that you get bent out of shape that Facebook didn't sell it though, it's a theme I've seen with Facebook employees: "But we didn't sell it!" I'm not sure if they are lamenting the fact they didn't sell it but I sure as hell can tell what they give a damn about. If you want to hide under "anybody would have done it", lets take a trip down histories gravestones and figure out whether or not we should bother trying to do the right thing because it is the right thing to do.
- deogeo 8y ago> There's nothing that Facebook did here than any other company, in tech or otherwise, wouldn't have done. Dubious, but still good point. Meaning legislation to force companies to behave slightly less unethically is all the more direly needed.
- nathan_long 8y ago> There's nothing that Facebook did here than any other company, in tech or otherwise, wouldn't have done. This isn't true. Lots of companies wouldn't steal users' call logs - eg, Mozilla, Signal, and plenty of boring, normal ones who make TODO list apps or whatever. It also isn't relevant. See how that argument flies in criminal court. "Anybody else would have stolen that car." What we see here (again) is that FB does nasty things and it's in the public interest to stop them - along with "any other company" who does the same things.
- cjhopman 8y agoYeah, that seemed unexpectedly flippant/dismissive. But a couple things: 1. If you look at the docs, that's from Exhibit 44 which indicates that it's actually an excerpt from a messenger discussion, not email 2. Twitter had previously blocked both Instagram and Tumblr in the same way 3. Facebook had previously blocked Twitter in the same way 4. In some of the other docs here, you can see that there was much more discussion about what their policy should be around reciprocity and apps competing with facebook's features 5. The first line of that indicates that there was likely discussion/planning about this before that conversation
- hkt 8y agoYeah, so much for openness and connecting people. Funny that the committee ended up being the open ones.