5 ms·
I only use firefox. But I don't feel like I can strongly recommend it because of the long list of bad decisions. - Google analytics baked into about:addons -
by gpm 8y ago
I only use firefox. But I don't feel like I can strongly recommend it because of the long list of bad decisions.
- Google analytics baked into about:addons
- Sending data to Cliqz
- Pocket, as a service being added to the topbar
- Pocket, as a service being added to the default home/newtab page
- Firefox hello
- Completely banning unsigned addons
- Mr. Robot advert
- And now probably this
I want a browser that is reliable, high quality, respects my privacy, and nothing else. I don't want addons baked into it. I don't want to be spied on.
- nykolasz 8y agoAgree. Isn't that why we have extensions for?
- PurpleRamen 8y agoMaybe we need a light fork which removes all those problematic parts on each release?
- markstos 8y agoSome of this problematic points are historical and resolved, like the Mr. Robot advert.
- btgis 8y agoThe fact that there are so many points just means we all have to sit and wait to see what the Mozilla Corporation does next. It does not matter if they resolve every grave transgression they do, I already have 0 trust placed on them.
- PurpleRamen 8y agoMaybe with a user-orientated fork the ability which allowed the Mr. Robot-thing would be gone too. As I remember it's a sketchy part which is not neccessary for the basic functionality.
- mtgx 8y ago> Pocket, as a service being added to the topbar > Pocket, as a service being added to the default home/newtab page Is that really worse than Mozilla allowing all of your Google searches (from the new tabs) to go through Google? At least it owns Pocket. Mozilla needs to make money somehow. Promoting its own services doesn't seem nearly as bad as the partnership with Google, in my opinion.
- zaarn 8y agoWell, unsigned addons are banned in the branded release browser. If you use the developer edition, nightly or compile Firefox yourself then you can install unsigned addons into Firefox. The last option also enables you to turn of Pocket and a variety of other services.
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoDoes anyone maintain a branch with precompiled builds that has sideloading turned on + no Pocket / other services? Preferably with autoupdate still working? Firefox is my primary browser on Windows, and I'd love to have this stuff removed, but I'm really not at a point where I can be compiling the code myself.
- craftyguy 8y agoIcecat[0] might be the closest thing to what you are looking for. It's part of the GNU project. 0. https://www.gnu.org/software/gnuzilla/ https://www.gnu.org/software/gnuzilla/
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoNo binary releases for Windows. :(
- raw_creations 8y ago38.8.0 was the last one. https://ftp.gnu.org/gnu/gnuzilla/38.8.0/ https://ftp.gnu.org/gnu/gnuzilla/38.8.0/
- gpm 8y agoI use to use nightly, then I found out they spy on you a lot more if you use nightly. I suspect the same applies to developer edition. [0] https://utcc.utoronto.ca/~cks/space/blog/web/FirefoxNoNightly https://utcc.utoronto.ca/~cks/space/blog/web/FirefoxNoNightl... [1] https://lobste.rs/s/ri4kny/you_probably_don_t_want_run_firefox#c_nsxsqd https://lobste.rs/s/ri4kny/you_probably_don_t_want_run_firef...
- levosmetalo 8y agoIn that case you would be better served by Google Chrome. I bet it doesn't have Pocket and Firefox hello.
- gpm 8y agoGoogle chrome has it's own set of problems that I think are worse. Namely giving Google the ability to make services that only work on its browser (which Google has been doing). The unfortunate part of this is that how much weight you assign to the twos actions is subjective, so I can't tell other people "you should definitely be using firefox instead" in good faith.
- nmy 8y agoDon't throw the baby out with the bathwater. These are minor things compared to having no other good choice but the Google browser.
- craftyguy 8y agoI've never found the "choose this, because the other option(s) suck more" to be a particularly flattering argument for web browsers, programming languages, cars, or politicians.
- SahAssar 8y agoIt's not supposed to be flattering. It's just saying it's the least bad option.
- kibwen 8y agoThe modern aversion to "lesser of two evils" is a thinly-disguised post-hoc rationalization for apathy (or worse, nihilism). It's not even false equivalence, because that would suggest trying to paint both "evils" as equal; no, this is simply saying that, when presented with two choices where one is better than the other, we might as well make the worse choice, because who cares?
- gpm 8y agoDisagreed. You should personally should choose the lesser of two evils when those are your only choices. Promoting the lesser evil is not such an easy call though. From a practical standpoint, promoting an evil, even if it's a lesser evil, has the potential for harming your own reputation as a reliable source. It is also fundamentally morally questionable, of course what is morally right and wrong is a matter of much debate. Suppose a psycopath calls you up and says "I'm going to do one of two things, shoot a random 5 year old named Joseph, or shoot two random 5 year olds named Kate, which should I do?". Assume for the hypothetical that you know they are telling the truth, and there is nothing you can do about the situation but choosing what you say back. In my view of the world saying "shoot Joseph" still makes you morally culpable, even though you were avoiding a worse situation.
- btgis 8y ago>- Pocket, as a service being added to the default home/newtab page Firefox now shows you ads on your home page by default. It's diabolical. I trust a well-configured Chrome (and with that I mean using the options dialog, not the cryptic about:config) more than Firefox. Even after having a well configured about:config, they managed to remotely install the Mr. Robot advertisement addon on my computer. I freaked out when I saw it. The Mozilla Corporation would do very well with a big change of leadership.
- boomboomsubban 8y agoGNU IceCat, or presumably most of these things are compile options.
- octosphere 8y agoYou missed a few things: - They have telemetry turned as the default - They are experimenting with TLS over HTTPS and use beloved Cloudflare to handle every DNS request - They are always in the headlines about some shady 'addon' or 'extension' been sold off and taken over by shady actors - The TorBundle which is a fork of FF ESR is always in the headlines as been unsecure and way behind FF mainline release
- gpm 8y agoYes, I'm sure I missed some things, I was trying to keep the list as non controversial as possible. Here are some specific responses. 1. Agreed, but at least they do prompt fairly early letting you turn it off. 2. I'm only looking at things in the release version of firefox. As I note elsewhere they treat nightly/beta users much worse. Longterm TLS over HTTPS is great for privacy, and they had to choose some provider, so I'm mostly fine with this. 3. This isn't their fault, the same applies to chrome. An extension is a third party piece of software you choose to install. 4. Again, a third party piece of software, not under their control. Further they are actively working to improve this situation and bring Tor onto mainline firefox!
- octosphere 8y ago> TLS over HTTPS Sorry I meant DNS over HTTPS
- gpm 8y agolol, so did I :)
- jammygit 8y agoCould you elaborate about the tor browser?
- octosphere 8y ago> Could you elaborate about the tor browser? Currently Tor is behind mainline Firefox in terms of security because it's a fork of Firefox ESR[1]. Pay attention to this part[2]: > Unlike other release channels, ESRs are not updated with new features every six weeks. They are instead supported for more than a year, updating with major security or stability fixes. [1] https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/organizations/ https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/organizations/ [2] https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Mozilla/Firefox/Firefox_ESR https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Mozilla/Firefox/Fir...
- heroprotagonist 8y agoI would add: - Public search for sources of other people's breached personal data via monitor.firefox.com (eg, you can enter anyone's email and see results, and not just your own, as there's no verification that you own the email until you sign up for continuous alerting) That said, I love Firefox itself and think Mozilla usually try to do the right thing. Someone just lost the security vs usability debate there I guess. Apparently informing people who won't check their email for a link but will enter their email into a form trumps protecting people who don't know the site exists from stalkers and other malicious actors.
- notamerican 8y ago> Public search for sources of other people's breached personal data via monitor.firefox.com That page is powered by haveibeenpwned.com. Mozilla just made a fantastic security tool available to user who don't know about Troy's site. > you can enter anyone's email and see results This data is all very easily available online anyway. It's just aggregating leaks that already public, and neither HIBP or the Mozilla page provide the _actual_ personal info that was leaked. > Someone just lost the security vs usability debate there I guess. That's the thing though; this _is_ a valid security tool. And a powerful and valuable one at that. HIBP has been used for years by thousands of users to secure their accounts after data breaches.
- heroprotagonist 8y agoIn other words, they have publicized the existing tool to make it available to a broader audience without adding anything on top to improve its security. They're both in the wrong on this. The argument of "Others are being irresponsible, so we should be irresponsible as well" does not stand up very well. The only valid use case for providing this information is for when a user no longer has access to the email address in question. In this case, they should still require it to be sent via email, and they should still send a notification to the email address being requested which includes details about the request like the IP it is made from and the email it would forward to, perhaps with a delay-and-prevent option so that someone who still owns the email can prevent the exfiltration by responding to the notice quickly. Otherwise, this enables anyone to solicit unauthorized PII data about basically anyone else from Mozilla. Even HIBP somewhat acknowledge the potential damage this can do, from the way they censor some results like the Ashley Madison data breach. They've made the decision that some personal information linked to a person's email address is more worthy of protection than other bits of personal information, which really shouldn't be up to them. They get away with it because of weak data protection laws and the fact that this caters to individual users who are more likely to opt themselves out if they become aware of it than to file a lawsuit or otherwise apply pressure to make them change.
- barrowclift 8y agoIf you use macOS, Safari since Mountain Lion has consistently hit all three of those checkboxes for me, you might want to consider giving it a shot.
- dingaling 8y agoToday I received promotional e-mails from Mozilla to my Firefox Account address. That really annoyed me, dipping into a privacy-sensitive database just to send marketing spam. How can marketing people even get access to that DB? No Mozilla, I don't want to watch your seasonal streaming music concerts. I want you to get on with building a better browser and stop undermining my trust. Sadly the top management think they're running a social experiment.
- Maskawanian 8y agoI agree, I was pretty pissed when I received this. I really want to support firefox, I really do...
- Digital-Citizen 8y ago> I want a browser that is reliable, high quality, respects my privacy, and nothing else. I don't want addons baked into it. I don't want to be spied on. I recommend that you look into what you're getting with software freedom -- the single most important aspect that makes Firefox different from Google Chrome, Microsoft's web browsers, Opera, or Apple Safari. All of the items on your list can be changed by using your software freedom. And this doesn't have to involve you learning to program (though that wouldn't be a bad idea). It could involve you asking programmers nicely to help you out, or hiring programmers to improve Firefox to be what you think it should be, or getting funds together with others who share your views to collectively fund programmers who work on your shared goals. As it stands your desire reads selfishly because it is indistinguishable from you saying that you want programmers to develop a free software (free as in freedom to run, inspect, share, and modify) web browser you trust without you doing anything to help vet its trustworthiness or modify the software until it becomes software you trust. We don't have to settle for doing nothing; software freedom lets us have as much control over free software as we wish to have. The limits are on us to make things better.
- gpm 8y agoI know how to program. I've contributed to Mozilla projects. Including minor contributions to components of Firefox. I do not have the time or the money to personally develop a secure web browser for the rest of the world, nor does any other individual. Your demand is unreasonable. Moreover, I'm not demanding that Mozilla do something. I'm explaining what would have to change for me to be able to promote Firefox and contribute to reversing the declining market share. Short of not breaking the law I make no claims that Mozilla must do anything. PS. Chromium is also free software. The difference is how Mozilla develops it's free software.
- Digital-Citizen 8y ago> I do not have the time or the money to personally develop a secure web browser for the rest of the world, nor does any other individual. Your demand is unreasonable. Apparently some people do, that's why we have Firefox derivatives like the Tor browser and GNUZilla, among others. Also, I made a recommendation not a demand. I continue to recommend that you consider what software freedom grants you in light of what you say you want other programmers to do for you.