4 ms·
I don't know about that. There's no doubt it happens that people artificially inflate their citations, but how often? The fact that this cases like this are rep
by YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
I don't know about that. There's no doubt it happens that people artificially inflate their citations, but how often? The fact that this cases like this are reported as something exceptional says that they are, most likely, exceptional, or at least surprising for the people who point them out (which again means that they are maybe not that usual).
In any case, if this kind of thing is reported in the popular press, blogs, etc, it's because a scholar caught it and reported it, which means there are checks and balances that don't let this behaviour run wild all the time.
And then again, there's going to be differences between fields- some will suffer from this kind of problem more than others, etc. There's no reason to "tar everyone with the same brush".
- jimhefferon 8y agoPerhaps, though, this is a three sigma case of a common phenomenon. There are a lot of journals and I expect that they consider that a half-full issue would be bad. There are a lot of paper-writers who are rewarded for more papers.
- jononor 8y agoIf we are to believe experiments by Dan Ariely, everyone tends to cheat a little bit. It is covered in one of his books, this article seems to contain the summary. https://fs.blog/2012/05/everyone-lies-dan-ariely-explains-why/ https://fs.blog/2012/05/everyone-lies-dan-ariely-explains-wh...
- conjectures 8y agoI didn't mean to imply outright plagiarism everywhere all the time. I think there are many ways to get inflated numbers. If a PI has 3 collaborator PIs and each PI has 4 students writing a paper every three months then the PIs can get 48 publications a year. Over 20 years, there's your O(1000) publications in a model with no substantial PI time contribution. Given teaching loads, home life, university admin, academic duties like reviews I'd be surprised if a senior academic got 3 days per week to do research. I'd say at that rate the 4 first-author level contribution publications per year model would be optimistic. So a more realistic cap on the quality work someone could do in 20 years might be 80 publications.
- gervase 8y agoI've worked in a similar system to what you described, with the top-most PI contributing essentially zero to publications directly. However, their fundraising efforts were singlehandedly paying the stipends/salary of 40+ researchers under them. I felt like it was totally fair to include them in the authors list, given that the research wouldn't have been possible without their efforts. I doubt the parent academic had O(1000) first author publications, nor is that mentioned in the article.
- bjourne 8y agoNo it isn't! That's like including your mom in an author's list because without her raising you, you wouldn't be a researcher.
- wolco 8y agoIf your mom is directly raising funds to support 40 paid position she should be included.
- jononor 8y agoIn the acknowledgements, not as an author. Especially not as primary author.
- FrojoS 8y agoThe grant application usually already laid out the research plan, hypothesis, state of the art etc. Even if there are massive changes later on, the person who wrote the grant application often provided enough scientific input to merit a co-authorship.
- conjectures 8y agoThis is a totally fair point. There is a contribution from leadership. But to track back to what was getting me bothered, it's the implication when Professor X is discussed or introduced somewhere that they personally thought up and wrote O(1000) publications. I know good PIs guide the research activities of their groups as well rather than just creaming off publications. But while I understand where you're coming from, stepping back and thinking about it 'authorship as a reward for leadership' could be a sign of unhealthiness in academia. Why can't authorship mean authorship and leadership be recognised separately? 'Professor X runs a highly successful lab of N researchers, who produced M papers last year, and manages a budget of Z dollars.'