5 ms·
While the world economy worked on real goods property had good understanding. services and intellectual property are challenging because ideas are ephemeral yet
by ggm 8y ago
While the world economy worked on real goods property had good understanding. services and intellectual property are challenging because ideas are ephemeral yet persist, and we have only social constructs to constrain them.
"I have the cake you don't unless you pay me" is very distinct from "You are not allowed to sing happy birthday without paying me"
One is an absolute. The cake is and moves. The other is an idea. You get rent from me expressing an Idea. Do I have to pay if I hum it inside my head? Do I have to promise not to tell anyone in written form? What if I change more than 90% of the notes but keep one theme?
I know this is a reductionist example, but IPR is like this: it has the terrible quality which goes to Patent process or patents over mathematics or physics. If you discover a specific dopant applied for a specific period of time in a specific way to silicon increases yield by 10%, Once the world knows this, why are you paid for the IPR licence time? If its to profit on the investment for research, remember that a huge amount of research is paid out of tax, not by investment returns. What if the counter parties invent a minor twist, or a related IPR moment? Yes.. people trade IPR rights, and collect IPR rights into agencies like the MP3 assciation.
This is a huge cancer on society. Its like CFDs. Its leveraging money moments out of thought.
International trade in real goods demands cheap. IPR demands rent which is "not cheap" -So the US demands for IPR rents on goods made in china, is like cutting your nose to spite your face: If you drive China to pay IPR taxes, you will drive china to seek IPR inside itself to avoid the taxes and charge YOU to copy them.
Better to have no IPR taxes than enforce payment.
- whatshisface 8y agoWhen the world economy worked on real goods, people frequently started wars to take them.
- criley2 8y agoI feel like your (and most) anti-intellectual property arguments are built on terrible strawman, so let's go through your terrible strawman. >One is an absolute. The cake is and moves. The other is an idea. You get rent from me expressing an Idea. Do I have to pay if I hum it inside my head? Obviously not, and to suggest that intellectual property laws would require rent payments for thinking about a song is so odious and unfair that the speaker must be assumed to be acting outside of the realm of honest discourse. >Do I have to promise not to tell anyone in written form? ? How is your concept of intellectual property so divorced from reality? In what country does one make a promise not to hum a song to a rights holder in written form? This beggars belief that you are anything other than some uninformed radical. >What if I change more than 90% of the notes but keep one theme? As with all of intellectual property, unless you are attempting to commercialize your idea, you aren't going to be seriously targeted for using someone's intellectual property. I struggle to treat this post as anything but the uninformed ramblings of a true radical. I mean, could you at least pretend to have a real world understanding of intellectual property when you create your examples? Here's a question for you: Have you ever created anything in your life with value that could be protected by intellectual property laws (copyright, trademark, patent, etc)? Have you ever created anything of value and given it away? Or are these ruminations about intellectual property purely hypothetical?
- Bored5809 8y agoAre you sure you're on the right track? The least you can do is not make the same mistake that you're accusing other of. > How is your concept of intellectual property so divorced from reality? In what country does one make a promise not to hum a song to a rights holder in written form? This beggars belief that you are anything other than some uninformed radical. Fallacy: 1) Ad Hominem > As with all of intellectual property, unless you are attempting to commercialize your idea, you aren't going to be seriously targeted for using someone's intellectual property. Fallacy: Appeal to probability > I struggle to treat this post as anything but the uninformed ramblings of a true radical. I mean, could you at least pretend to have a real world understanding of intellectual property when you create your examples? Fallacy: Ad Hominem > Here's a question for you: Have you ever created anything in your life with value that could be protected by intellectual property laws (copyright, trademark, patent, etc)? Have you ever created anything of value and given it away? Or are these ruminations about intellectual property purely hypothetical? Fallacy: Ad Hominem You could have ended your post by pointing out the fallacies, but Internet has taught you to go a step further (Look at me doing the same thing)
- criley2 8y agoFallacy: Fallacy fallacy. The worst kind of munchkin is the one that thinks A) a fallacious argument is a wrong one B) that reducing arguments to fallacies is a beneficial way to communicate and C) who misuses fallacies as a tool to avoid arguing merits. For shame. Utterly, you provided the worst response possible. Meta, petty, inherently fallacious and ultimately pointless.
- icebraining 8y agoAs with all of intellectual property, unless you are attempting to commercialize your idea, you aren't going to be seriously targeted for using someone's intellectual property. Yeah, tell that to Thomas-Rasset. Ordered to pay $220,000 for sharing 24 songs on Kazaa. Many others have had their internet connections cut off or worse.
- criley2 8y ago
- baybal2 8y ago> International trade in real goods demands cheap. IPR demands rent which is "not cheap" -So the US demands for IPR rents on goods made in china, is like cutting your nose to spite your face: If you drive China to pay IPR taxes, you will drive china to seek IPR inside itself to avoid the taxes and charge YOU to copy them. Back in Shanzhai days, there was a popular saying about the attitude of American "Big Business" to Chinese industry: "you do all the hard work, and we will do all the money." That's a very equitable separation of labour :) American Big Co. people are mad because they can't continue doing that.
- jeromebaek 8y ago> "I have the cake you don't unless you pay me" is very distinct from "You are not allowed to sing happy birthday without paying me" Sure, but what about "You are not allowed to make this cake unless you pay me"? There is no strict gap between what is and what is only an idea, which is what you seem to be implying. The problem isn't about what exists and what doesn't, the problem is a (necessary) bug in the way value is assigned.
- will_brown 8y agoYou can’t copyright a recipe
- jeromebaek 8y agoIf you're being literal, sure, but you can copyright an algorithm.
- fjsolwmv 8y agoNope, but you can patent it with a bit of fiction about inventing a computer that performs the algorithm.
- baroffoos 8y agoBut you can copyright a list of steps to make other things.
- dredmorbius 8y agoThe expression, possibly, though strong limitations exist. The functional consequence or idea, no. See Sega v. Accolade or Feist v. Rural Telephone. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sega_v._Accolade https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sega_v._Accolade https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feist_Publications,_Inc.,_v._Rural_Telephone_Service_Co https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feist_Publications,_Inc.,_v._R.... Patents cover ideas and inventions, including processes.
- ummonk 8y ago
- will_brown 8y agoThe excuse for a limited copyright in the United States is that an author who has produced a book and has had the benefit of it for that term has had the profit of it long enough, and therefore the Government takes the property, which does not belong to it, and generously gives it to the eighty-eight millions. That is the idea. If it did that, that would be one thing. But it does not do anything of the kind. It merely takes the author’s property, merely takes from his children the bread and profit of that book, and gives the publisher double profit. The publisher, and some of his confederates who are in the conspiracy, rear families in affluence, and they continue the enjoyment of these ill-gotten gains generation after generation. They live forever, the publishers do. -Mark Twain The questions you ask are complex legal questions but they aren’t novel by any means. There is over 100 years of case law in the US and I promise the courts have dealt with more interesting facts, cite more historical perspective, and use better logic and reasoning than you get in this thread. Hell you could read Mark Twain’s entire statement to the House and Senate Committee on patents and walk away with a richer person and in Twain like fashion I’ll even link you his statement in perpetual property rights via https://www.thepublicdomain.org/2014/07/19/mark-twain-on-the-need-for-perpetual-copyright/ https://www.thepublicdomain.org/2014/07/19/mark-twain-on-the...
- chmod775 8y agoThat mark twain quote was pre-internet age. Nowadays you don't need publishers to disseminate your work.
- will_brown 8y agoAll the most successful authors in the world all seem to use publishers. All you need to do is replace publisher with online ad companies, like google, who will reap all the reward. Say there was no publisher you, me, everyone publishes Harry Potter books on our website. People will use google to find them and google AdWords on own websites to try to monetize someone else’s property, but Only the ad company wins. Honest question have you ever created anything of value that someone with deep pockets cane along and ripped off?
- 8y ago
- chillacy 8y agoThe US has a 150 year head start on IP production, of course it benefits us to play by these rules. It also benefits China to say “yea IP isn’t real” but then again neither is the idea of the chinese nation or the unified states of America. human rights and property are also intersubjective reality.
- Brushfire 8y agoHuman rights turn out to be very real to people who do not have them.