3 ms·
> to light being quanta Courtesy of Planck, of course.
by Koshkin 8y ago
> to light being quanta
Courtesy of Planck, of course.
- nabla9 8y ago>Courtesy of Planck, of course. No. Absolutely not. This is where physicists get their history wrong and what the lecture explains. When Planck described black-body radiation, he wrote that it was "as if" there were resonators in the walls that can oscillate at certain discrete frequencies. He did believe that light was a wave. Even after Einstein published his paper much later, Planck and everyone else thought he was silly for almost twenty years. They accepted the photoelectric effect explanation but not how Einstein came to the result (photons).
- mhh__ 8y agoIsn't this somewhat simplified? The modern "proper" understanding/mechanistic explanation of the Quantization of (spin-1/2, massless - or symmetry groups etc.)fields resulting in photons came later still.
- nabla9 8y agoNo, I don't think so. You have to think how the ideas proceeded historically, not to try to retrofit current understanding backwards in time. For example, Isaac Newton believed light was composed of a stream of corpuscles, but he lost his case in 1801 when Young presented his double slit experiment. Einstein's idea at that time was more correct and provided better explanations and predictions.
- Koshkin 8y agoOK, but it is worth mentioning, then, that the quantum theory as it has developed in the later years has, in fact, rejected the idea of the light quanta as Einstein thought of them, being "particles of light," i.e. something that is localized in space, whereas Planck's notion of energy quanta (or energy quantization, of the light wave or in general) has remained in force.
- nabla9 8y agoWe are interested how the thinking and ideas behind physics historically proceeded. The important historical lesson is that Einstein had the correct idea and framework to think about light __at that time__ and advance physical theory, he wrote it down and people refused to accept it. * 1900 Plank describes black-body radiation in a way where energy is quantized. * 1905 Einstein describes light as having “corpuscular” nature and uses it to describe photoelectric effect. * 1923 Compton effect discovered. Einsteins ideas about light quanta explain them perfectly. Everybody accepts that light is also a particle and Gilbert Lewis coins the word photon.