3 ms·
If it was opt-in, all the people who didn’t care either way wouldn’t bother to opt in, because—even if you have ideals suggesting it’d be better if they knew wh
by derefr 8y ago
If it was opt-in, all the people who didn’t care either way wouldn’t bother to opt in, because—even if you have ideals suggesting it’d be better if they knew who used what features—satisfying that ideal isn’t worth the effort of finding and checking a box. (See also: the organ donor registry.)
Making something like this opt-in is equivalent to not having it at all. Not just because of how little pick-up there would be on the telemetry, but also because the type of people who would opt in are a skewed sample not representative of the larger user-base they wish to learn about. It’s like the bias introduced by doing an opinion poll by asking people to do a one-hour opinion poll over the phone: you filter out the average person who doesn’t have time to do a one-hour poll, and get responses only from people with too much time on their hands (= unemployed; teenagers pretending to be adults; old people who just want attention; etc.)
- laythea 8y ago"Making something like this opt-in is equivalent to not having it at all" People who say opt in, would generally opt out. People who say opt out, would generally opt in. This applies to anything. In this case, given its about collecting my data and processing me, I say Opt In. Not having it at all is a good thing.
- derefr 8y agoMy point was that the only useful options are “an opt-out telemetry system” and “no telemetry system.” An opt-in telemetry system is wasted effort from the point of view of gathering results with statistical power. And no, the people who want opt-out would not generally opt in in an opt-in system. That'd be their preference, yes, but you’re underestimating people’s laziness in practice. There are things I’d grant telemetry access to, but I don’t know how and don’t have time in the day to learn how, especially since it grants very little advantage to me personally.
- ohithereyou 8y agoMaybe if we got something in exchange for the actual value of our data (say, Microsoft paid us per machine, per user, per hour used) then it would be worth it to opt-in.
- m45t3r 8y ago> Maybe if we got something in exchange for the actual value of our data (say, Microsoft paid us per machine, per user, per hour used) then it would be worth it to opt-in. You get something, better software because developers can know what is being used and what it is not, what feature is bugged, etc etc.
- justinclift 8y agoHow's that working out for MS? /s
- mh7 8y agoOr you get something worse because you happened to be one of the few users of a niche feature that they decided the axe because they optimize for the telemetry data.
- olyjohn 8y agoPeople keep acting like telemetry is my problem as the end-user. I don't care about your development practices. I don't care about your telemetry. All I care about is if the software works, and my privacy is protected. The problems with getting telemetry data are your problem. The burden should not be on us to have to turn off all this data-gathering to protect my data. EDIT: The proverbial "you", not you in particular.
- scrollaway 8y ago> I don't care about your telemetry. All I care about is if the software works Newsflash: The latter requires the former, especially in large-userbase installations with tons of features. I say this as a huge defender of privacy: Telemetry is not evil in and of itself and I wish people would give it a rest when it comes to yelling about opt-in telemetry, because it seriously harms the cause in cases where it matters, such as actual transmission of personal data. Seriously, things like "Do you click the Edit menu a lot" is not useful data to anyone but the devs of the software, for development reasons.
- justinclift 8y ago> Newsflash: The latter requires the former, especially in large-userbase installations with tons of features. The vast majority of computing history argues for exactly the opposite. In fact, with it's new "all in on telemetry regardless of reputation damage" approach, MS's software often does not work. Clearly MS have taken a wrong approach, and seem completely unwilling to rethink it.
- scrollaway 8y agoThe vast majority of computing history did not have the iteration speed, the low barrier of entry, the complexity, etc etc of software today. Do you not remember using software back then? Waiting years for simple bugfixes?
- justinclift 8y ago
- zelon88 8y ago"Mass surveillance doesn't yield useful results unless you monitor everybody!" You're missing the point here. I don't care about the quality of Microsoft's metrics. I care about the privacy of my data. The results of your arbitrary one hour opinion poll don't mean anything to me. You wanted that data. It doesn't benefit me, as much as you want me to think it does. Infact, if I had the choice between not taking the poll and not having you call me in the first place guess which one I'm gonna pick.
- jhall1468 8y ago> You're missing the point here. I don't care about the quality of Microsoft's metrics. I care about the privacy of my data. And Microsoft only cares about the privacy of your data inasmuch as it has to, it DOES care about the quality of its metrics. > The results of your arbitrary one hour opinion poll don't mean anything to me. You wanted that data. It doesn't benefit me, as much as you want me to think it does. Infact, if I had the choice between not taking the poll and not having you call me in the first place guess which one I'm gonna pick. Sounds like you want to have your cake and eat it to. There's already global means to opt-out of telemetry data: don't use products that have it. Alternatively you can take the couple of minutes to turn it off yourself. Seems you think you're entitled to this, which is fine, but that entitlement should be brought to the attention of your government.
- ptx 8y ago> Making something like this opt-in is equivalent to not having it at all. Microsoft were doing opt-in telemetry in Office, Visual Studio and the .NET framework for a long time, so it must have provided value for them. The installer used to politely ask you to consider opting in to help improve the product. JetBrains products still follow this approach of respecting the customer and asking politely.
- derefr 8y agoSoftware that actively nags you at every opportunity to opt in isn’t really “opt-in” per se. There’s a third kind of system for polling preferences, which I’ll call “opt-forced” for lack of a better make: it’s where you are required at some point to decide whether to opt in or opt out, and neither option is the default. (Picture two radio buttons, neither selected, and you can’t proceed until you click one.) Nagging opt-in is a lot closer to opt-forced—you’re required to either press “OK” or “Cancel” to the opt-in dialog box. Except, since it just keeps asking whenever you “opt out”, you haven’t really opted out at all. Thus, this dark pattern is actually closer to the “opt-out” side of the fence, in terms of the number of people who end up in the program even though they’d actively prefer not to be (but this preference is weaker than their preference to stop being nagged.)