5 ms·
To be fair there's absolutely no frickin' way that you could predict that people would enter their bank in place of their employer.
by gaius 16y ago
To be fair there's absolutely no frickin' way that you could predict that people would enter their bank in place of their employer.
- eitland 16y agoNo, but there should be some way or another that those who create large, international websites should know that their websites are going to be used by non native english speakers :-) Still there is lots of web forms with a Country field and a State field. And in the state field you'll only find American states.
- whatusername 16y agoOr 5 digit "zip" codes. // I wonder how many Internet residents live in 90210? I know I do in a couple of places.
- smiler 16y ago:) Yup that is my standard zip code when I need it. What I find even more frustrating is that some US stores ask for your zip code when you make a purchase. (Is it ok to refuse?). Being English, I just state that I don't live in the US, but it's not a practice I've ever encountered in the UK.
- kenj0418 16y agoIt usually confuses them if you refuse. When they ask, I live in the zip code 90210 and my phone number is 867-5309.
- cullenking 16y agoOh that was mean mean mean. I don't know how long it will take that song to leave my head now :(
- CapitalistCartr 16y agoYeah, I usually refuse, and they simply enter 99999 or some such. It's only for marketing research, so they don't actually care.
- pmjordan 16y agoIt's happened to me in the UK (and in Austria) from time to time. Mostly seems to be shops with a relatively large catchment area. (something like Ikea, though I'm actually not sure they have ever asked me) Asking for the UK postcode is of course pretty sinister as it narrows it down to a couple of houses. Sometimes they only ask for the first bit. Based on the reactions I've received, I doubt many people opt out.
- tomjen3 16y agoIt happens in Denmark quite a lot, but I usually just give them a real zip code I don't live in.
- RyanMcGreal 16y agoExactly, which is why review and testing is so important.
- CWuestefeld 16y agoIn the abstract, this ought to be obvious. But as it relates to this specific example, I don't see how to test it. Surely you're not going to just randomly remove fields from forms, to see if anything good happens. The only way I can see to deduce this particular problem would be if the site is storing all of the failed checkout entries. And I think that's the wrong thing to do in this case, because of the privacy implications
- ig1 16y agoWho doesn't store failed checkouts ? - I can't see why you would consider that any more of a privacy violation than storing successful transactions. Especially in the travel industry where credit card fraud is very high, storing failures is important for auditing/anti-fraud activities, not to mention customer support. When a customer calls you to say "my transaction failed", and you respond "We don't have any record of your transaction" at best that makes you look unreliable and at worst the customer thinks you're calling them a liar.
- CWuestefeld 16y agoWho doesn't store failed checkouts ? - I can't see why you would consider that any more of a privacy violation It seems to me that a common failure mode would be entering a value into the wrong field, and that includes putting the credit card number into address or something. I want to do everything I can to avoid storing a credit card number (except for the one place it's saved, encrypted, at the customer's discretion).
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- ig1 16y ago
- staktrace 16y agoOn the other hand if they weren't trying to gather as much information about users as they possibly could this wouldn't even have been a problem in the first place. What possible benefit does an optional "Company" field provide?
- patio11 16y ago"It would be great if we knew what percentage of our customers were business travelers. It would really improve marcomm.". "The web guys say they can ask, it won't take five minutes.". "Brilliant! Do it. Next order of business..." Six years later, nobody has checked the form since. After all, that isn't their job.
- gaius 16y agoIn the event that there are several companies sharing the same address. E.g. my address here is <name>, <company name>, <building name>.