4 ms·
Just pick up any special relativity textbook (if you don't know Special Relativity, it really only requires basic algebra to understand most of it and is pretty
by gumby 8y ago
Just pick up any special relativity textbook (if you don't know Special Relativity, it really only requires basic algebra to understand most of it and is pretty intuitive once you've read it). I recommend Taylor's "Spacetime Physics" which has lots of fun pictures and examples.
Anyway, you can think of special relativity is being all about information: if I look at something moving, it takes time for the light to reach me and by the time it has the thing I see isn't quite there any more. When things go really fast this becomes noticeable, as information about where something is can only travel so fast.
If you think of the deformation of a transparent crystal you could see what's going on pretty much immediately (light is slower in a dense medium, but not appreciably so in this example). But in an opaque crystal only the waveforms due to displacement (AKA "sound waves") can transmit "state" information from one place to another.
So you can draw the same Minkowski diagrams you would for interstellar space, only instead imagine them being inside the crystal. You can pretty immediately see that the maximum speed of information propagation is the speed of sound, so any deformation can only be learned about by a signal moving that fast. The same pictures that show a speeding rocket foreshortened now describe your crystal deformation when seen from various perspectives. Of course with a crystal you can squeeze from multiple sides which can make the diagrams a lot more interesting!
- TeMPOraL 8y agoThings like this pretty much justify all the time spent procrastinating on HN. Thank you. (And also don't thank you, this is variable reinforcement at its purest.) So if you can formulate "sonic relativity" like this, what happens when you trick it to provide faster-than-sound signals? Say, you emit an acoustic signal in one place, and route an electric wire with sensors and actuators that transmit it outside of the medium and re-emit as sound closer to observer. I.e. a sound-world analogue to a wormhole. Can you some (or any) of the time travel trickery that is said to be implied by any possible FTL? Also, how is it that Minkovsky's diagrams work, apparently length contraction and time dilation can be seen as working too[0], and yet we know we can go faster than speed of sound in a medium? -- [0] - https://arxiv.org/abs/1612.06870 https://arxiv.org/abs/1612.06870
- gumby 8y agoOf course you can though the “time travel” is only apparent to someone who can only see as fast as Ma, not to someone who can see at, say, the speed of light. This is not really any more thrilling than the higher-dimensionality stores of “Flatland” And such time travel isn’t as interesting as it is in the story books.
- renox 8y agoWhile I agree that the maths needed to understand Special Relativity are simple, SR itself not so much: we get used to things like the twins paradox, but do we really understand it?
- gumby 8y agoThey seem pretty mundane consequences of SR and not even paradoxical. General relativity, on the other hand.....ok I passed some classes back in the day but looking back I’m not sure I ever understood it, except at a very shallow level.