2 ms·
> It's way too easy to set a project that takes too long. They do often take longer than they claim. That's true. > Take home projects inevitably have issu
by mcv 8y ago
> It's way too easy to set a project that takes too long.
They do often take longer than they claim. That's true.
> Take home projects inevitably have issues ("bugs", if you will). You can't just "resolve" those problems if the person who set it isn't sitting in front of you.
In my experience, you're usually assigned someone you can call or mail with questions. Asking questions is good. Though I usually figure it out on my own.
> Take home projects take employer skin out of the game. It's way too easy to give out twenty tests and ignore ten of them
Only if they do it wrong. The right way is to give this assignment only to candidates you will definitely want to hire, unless they produce terrible code. The candidate doesn't mail in their code, but presents it to a group of developers who ask questions about it.
This gives the employer skin in the game: they're not going to keep their developers off their work for dozens of candidates who are probably not going to make it; they only bring them out to assess a very likely hire.
I guess some employers use these coding assignments badly. You're totally right to avoid those.
> I could just have copied someone else's.
But could you have been able to explain the choices of that someone else?
> You lose a valuable source of feedback which allows you to iteratively improve the test if you're not watching the candidate while they do the test.
Maybe, but to many people, coding on the spot is more stressful than it is at home. Although I've also done some really enjoyable pair programming on what was probably my only long interview day (which had an interview, pair programming, and a game to get to know each other).
> It's valuable to talk through the solution with the candidate while they do it
But it's also valuable to talk through the solution after they've done it. That's when they have made those trade-offs.