2 ms·
(I'm a big fan of Buzz, and I loved FriendFeed enough to build a very similar service a couple of years ago) One of the problems with Buzz and similar apps is
by nl 16y ago
(I'm a big fan of Buzz, and I loved FriendFeed enough to build a very similar service a couple of years ago)
One of the problems with Buzz and similar apps is that they don't allow people/celebrities/marketers a way to control the view of the conversation like twitter does.
In Buzz (and blog comments, Facebook, FriendFeed, HN and just about any other service invented) the comment thread is attached to an original anchor post. That seems like a feature from the usability point of view - or at least I always assumed it was a feature.
BUT, it turns out that if you are famous you don't want random people's names and comments attached to your own.
On Twitter, Oprah can say something and no one else sees the millions of people who doubtlessly beg her for giveaways. Government departments can tweet and not have to deal with the politics of approving/disapproving comments on their posts, etc etc.
Buzz etc promote interaction, but it turns out the the grief associated with interaction simply isn't worth it after a certain point.
I'd note that almost all the Twitter leadership group use it continuously. OTOH, while there are assorted (great) Google developers and PMs using Buzz I haven't seen any senior leadership using it - let along interacting on it (OTOH, most of the FriendFeed leadership did use it - maybe that's what kept it going).
I'd also note that this problem applies to Facebook, too. I think that in many cases Facebook pages are run by professional marketing people, so that pushes back the critical level of grief somewhat
I'd love if there was a better explanation for this. If this theory is true then I'm not sure what Google can do to fix Buzz - attaching a broadcast-only mode would be a difficult change to make.
- wyclif 16y agowhile there are assorted (great) Google developers and PMs using Buzz I haven't seen any senior leadership using it Depends on what you mean by 'senior leadership.' Guido van Rossum uses Buzz and interacts with users there.
- nl 16y agoDepends on what you mean by 'senior leadership. Anyone listed on this page: http://www.google.com.au/intl/en_au/corporate/execs.html http://www.google.com.au/intl/en_au/corporate/execs.html
- wyclif 16y agoAh, but the fact that those people don't use Buzz doesn't correlate to the success or failure of Buzz. I suspect there may be good reasons the Google Executive board does not share on Buzz.
- nl 16y agoI suspect there may be good reasons the Google Executive board does not share on Buzz. I agree. In-fact, that's exactly my point!! I'd note that more that one of them use Twitter, so it's not a legal, policy or commercial problem. My theory it that it's too much work to keep the profile clean on Buzz. However, all those listed on http://www.quora.com/Twitter-company/Who-serves-on-the-Twitter-board-of-directors/answer/Adam-Rifkin http://www.quora.com/Twitter-company/Who-serves-on-the-Twitt... as members of the Twitter board do use Twitter. I'd love to hear a better explanation.