4 ms·
That's something that I like about experiments in "Container Tabs", where you get the power of separate profiles, but the ability to mix-and-match them in the s
by WorldMaker 8y ago
That's something that I like about experiments in "Container Tabs", where you get the power of separate profiles, but the ability to mix-and-match them in the same browser window and opening a profile can be as simple as opening a new tab.
I understand though why Mozilla seems to be having such a hard time converging on a UX for Container Tabs that makes everyone happy and it may be impossible to ever surface 100% of the power of profiles to the average user. But -ProfileManager is so long in the tooth and so clearly predates modern niceties that it would be great for better UI/UX out of the box today.
- navs 8y agoI don’t understand why Firefox removed the tab exposé feature they had. Clicking a button gave you a look at all your open tabs allowing you to then drag them into groups. Only your active group was displayed but you could always switch to another group when browsing in a different context. Combine that experience with the current Containers sandboxing feature and that would be a dream.
- sorenjan 8y agoYou can read more about the decision to remove it on Mozilla's Bugzilla [0]. There are extension providing pretty much the same experience, like Panorama view [1]. I agree that it's very convenient to separate tabs into separate topics, and only view the ones that are relevant at any time. [0] https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1222550 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1222550 [1] https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/panorama-view/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/panorama-view...
- alexis_fr 8y ago« Container Tabs » doesn’t build trust in user’s mind. You’re always one click away from sending data with the wrong profile. With Chrome, you get a separate window, and different skins, and a different data folder on the hard drive, you can at least comfort yourself with the idea that you’ve somewhat isolated your lives. Besides the classic work/home/sysadmin profiles, I also have a profile for browsing websites like /r/MensRights or christian websites: People have been fired for way less, so with such an incentive, Firefox tabs are way below expectations in terms of design.
- WorldMaker 8y agoThat's a solvable UX problem. Admittedly, it's a UX problem that Mozilla has struggled with trying to build a UX that is trustworthy for both inexperienced users and power users alike. Most browsers already have highly separated threads/processes for different tabs for performance reasons alone, but also cross-tab security issues. In most cases the technical difference between two tabs in the same window and two tabs in different windows is minimal. Technical differences in profiles such as different data folder on the hard drive is even already a part of Firefox's container tabs. There is definitely an experiential difference, but a lot of the same signifiers (different themes / different "title" bars / etc) can be brought in and applied to multiple tabs in the same window, switching with tabs themselves. Or perhaps new UX signifiers might be developed that work better in a mixed tab space. It was encouraging that Mozilla was experimenting in that space, at least, even if what they built they weren't entirely happy with user studies of it. Again, the fundamental issue should be solvable with enough applied UX. We likely haven't discovered the solution for that yet (especially not one usable by novice users), but its still something interesting to continue to research and something that I hope is continued to be researched. (PS If you are worried about getting fired over your dirty laundry, I'm not sure airing it in cleartext on HN is exactly the right idea either.)
- ppseafield 8y agoYou can configure container tabs to always open desired URLs in specified containers. You just click the containers button and check "Always open in <container>". After that when you click a link to that site from a different container, it will prompt you and ask if you want to use the other container or continue with the one you were just using. It will remember your choice.
- Tomte 8y agoBut it will not leave the container when clicking a link to "outside". One moment of inattention, and you're surfing the whole web for hours in your Facebook container.
- ppseafield 8y ago
- shittyadmin 8y agoI love container tabs, my biggest worry and the reason I'm hesitant to rely on them is that I suspect they'll get scrapped in the future because Mozilla seems to be building a Chrome clone lately.
- WorldMaker 8y agoYeah, I've been following with keen eyes Mozilla's efforts in the space. I really like that they are experimenting with it, and I really hope them success, or at least to continue to take risks and experiment with it, but also due to the nature of the experiments to date there hasn't yet been a case where I'd swap my existing profiles for container tabs (even with the headaches of maintaining -ProfileManager launch shortcuts and remembering when I need to --no-remote or use weirder workarounds/shortcuts to get things launched properly). In migrating the primary container tab UI into an extension, Mozilla seems committed to at least providing the functionality as a long term extension API. So I don't expect the feature to be scrapped at this point; maybe just to remain rather anemic "out of the box" for the time being as Mozilla iterates on its extension. That has me curious if there's a good power user-focused extension already to meet my profile needs (or how hard it would be to build one), but so far that's only been an idle curiosity.
- eikenberry 8y agoContainer Tabs give you no control over which extensions are used in that container. That is my main use of Profiles.
- WorldMaker 8y agoThey could. That seems to me like a useful feature to support. With the modern extensions (as opposed to old XPCOM/XUL components), that sounds technically doable to me.
- unqueued 8y agoI've posted this a bunch of times on HN, but these scripts I use let me launch a new instance of the Firefox engine with its own prefs.js and extensions from the terminal[1]. Profilemaker pairs perfectly with this. [1]: https://github.com/unqueued/foxbox https://github.com/unqueued/foxbox
- asdff 8y agoContainer tabs are so clunky in practice, they really need a lot of work. Google something in your Google container, click a link, and instead of just directing to the link, the link is opened in a new tab and the search result tab is closed instantly. You can't go back to the results, you have to unclose the tab. Container tabs also were terrible if you needed a persistent login. My school proxy for journal subscriptions has like half a dozen redirects with different URL names, I either had to not use containers here or add an exception for every step in the login process that it would break because of the container system. I hated constantly running into problems with containers breaking websites and making browsing so cumbersome that I stopped using them entirely. Like some of the esoteric Adblocker configurations favored here, they are good in principle, but in practice break 50% of websites on the internet without spending serious time crafting exceptions for every issue you run into on every new site you find.