3 ms·
Really unclear what communism has to do with any of this (population growth fell in the Warsaw bloc countries after the fall of communism BTW, and a country lik
by gumby 8y ago
Really unclear what communism has to do with any of this (population growth fell in the Warsaw bloc countries after the fall of communism BTW, and a country like Japan has negligible communist influence).
It's also unclear why the population derivative need be significantly positive, or, really, positive at all.
- graycat 8y agoThe message, the sabotage, was that being a wife and mother with young children in a middle class neighborhood in Long Island was a terrible situation. That message spread around the world and had people take family formation nowhere nearly seriously enough. Yes, the message also went to Poland, along with France, Italy, Germany, especially Spain, and, yes, the US. The Friedan message was one of the first of a flood of such, all claiming that people and especially women had some much better things go do than have families. Evaluate the evidence of the causes as you will. Maybe notice that the enemies of the US benefited. The results are beyond question. I can't prove this with the Radon-Nikodym theorem, the standard model of physics, a software proof of correctness, a solid engineering document, or a winning legal brief, but I can't ignore the message and its results. E.g., she told me "I don't want to get married."; "Women don't have to just be cared for. Women can do things too. I want a career."; "Having children just perpetuates the present and doesn't make any progress."; "I don't want to give up the best years of my life and my career just to have some man's children." She got these messages from Friedan, etc. She tried. She failed. At her mother's farm, for two days she was missing and her body was found floating in a lake. She would have done JUST FINE if I had just gotten her PREGNANT when we first met when she was 19; easy enough to do -- her brain said no; her emotions said YES. Then have kept her pregnant. Then learned enough about clinical psychology to have solved her problems with the toxic message from Friedan. I have a friend, bright guy, Courant Ph.D., Member, Institute for Advanced Study, who rates Friedan as the greatest cause of death ever, worse than Stalin, Mao, Pol Pot, Hitler, Tojo, all put together -- just count the babies stopped with birth control or abortion in the more advanced countries, done. In an important sense, he's correct. Positive slope is not necessary and maybe not even desirable. Negative slope is extinction.