2 ms·
Exactly. Somebody's freedom of speech does not override a service provider freedom of association. Freedom of speech is not a right to distribution and payment.
by wpietri 8y ago
Exactly. Somebody's freedom of speech does not override a service provider freedom of association. Freedom of speech is not a right to distribution and payment.
- apostacy 8y agoThese are not merely service providers. They are de-facto utilities. Just because Verizon does not like your politics, does not mean they can cut you off from their services. Same with Wells Fargo denying you a checking account (although they certainly did try in the past, if they thought you were a labor organizer). Patreon, and other payment processors (like Stripe.com) are having their arms twisted from the highest levels by Visa and Mastercard. Think for a moment if it would be ok with you if Visa and Mastercard were doing this because they wanted to silence people who advocated for women's rights. Would you still be so libertarian about it?
- wpietri 8y agoVerizon is a monopoly, and should be tightly regulated. Patreon is definitely not. And there's no particular reason here to think that Patreon is doing this under pressure from Visa. They were under plenty of pressure from their user base. I think there's also a fundamental difference between an organization that bans people who increase the rights of marginalized groups and one that bans people that are looking to further marginalize people, so your analogy doesn't do anything for me.
- apostacy 8y agoI was referring to the credit card companies as being a monopoly. They use their top-down power to impose their politics on people. It's not just Patreon. If anyone sets up a similar service, and does business with someone that Visa does not want, they will use their monopolistic power to shut you down. Imagine if they were doing this about a cause you disagreed with. Imagine if our financial industry was run by Trump supporters, and they were slowly squeezing their critics out financially. This is bad.
- wpietri 8y agoAs I said, there's no particular reason here to think that Patreon is doing this under pressure from Visa.
- daxorid 8y agoWe already lack freedom of association. In the United States, a business is not free to discriminate against certain classes of people, or on the basis of certain things. The only question is what is the precise coefficient of friction on that slippery slope. You can argue that wedding cakes should be baked for gay couples but that websites should not be hosted for nazis for reasons A, B, and C. But claiming that businesses have some sort of broad right to free association is not merely specious, but completely and obviously wrong.
- dragonwriter 8y agoBusinesses do, in fact, have a broad right of free association, limited only by statutory (and possibly State constitutional) limitations that comport with the high federal Constitutional bar for such limitations.
- wpietri 8y agoNo freedom is perfectly available. Freedom of speech, for example, doesn't allow you to commit perjury or fraud, and it doesn't entitle you to harass someone. Freedom of association doesn't let you stalk somebody, or let felons on parole talk to one another. All rights must be balanced against other rights. Businesses do have a very broad right of freedom to serve who they please. The one exception is when historically many businesses have used that power to participate in oppression against specific downtrodden groups. So a business can happily decline to serve US congressmen, freemasons, and people who have thrown up on their floor previously. But they can't decline to serve black people as a group. The specific groups who have been legally recognized for this are called protected classes, and it's pretty settled law in the US: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protected_group https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protected_group